It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Phantom42338
a reply to: cooperton
My question is what about dinosaurs? According to YOU, dinosaurs and men walked the Earth together. Was Noah responsible for their extinction because he didn't pick them up?
These stories get to a point of ridiculousness that even a 10 year old could successfully challenge.
originally posted by: Phantom42338
a reply to: cooperton
My question is what about dinosaurs? According to YOU, dinosaurs and men walked the Earth together. Was Noah responsible for their extinction because he didn't pick them up?
originally posted by: FarmerSimulation
Certain fish and reptiles never stop growing in staure their entire lives.
And conform to the size of the environment they inhabit.
Small fish bowl, small gold fish.
Big lake, big goldfish. Long lifespans, great big fish and reptiles.
I think Noah would have been wise to take juveniles vs. Adult monsters due to size and space.
originally posted by: daskakik
a reply to: FarmerSimulation
No, it means I don't put stock in that story. Nothing more, nothing less.
Trey Smith may have answered it for you in the documentary, which I just took a quick look at. It is the same bunk being peddled here. You already buy into it, which is why it was easy to feel like they had figured it out.
originally posted by: andy06shake
a reply to: cooperton
Not what the fossil records show.
Dinosaurs varied greatly in size, ranging from small to gigantic.
And while it's true that some dinosaurs were relatively small and comparable in size to modern-day dogs, many others were much larger.
originally posted by: andy06shake
a reply to: cooperton
The question begs then, if Noah took ""baby dinosaurs"" onto his magic boat, to be saved like all the rest of the millions of other animals, then where are all the dinosaurs?
originally posted by: FarmerSimulation
And vice versa, doh.
originally posted by: andy06shake
a reply to: cooperton
Not what the fossil records show.
Dinosaurs varied greatly in size, ranging from small to gigantic.
And while it's true that some dinosaurs were relatively small and comparable in size to modern-day dogs, many others were much larger.
originally posted by: daskakik
Exactly, so don't say that guy answers things for me. He doesn't, he does the same thing you and OP are doing here, providing weak answers like, the ark didn't need to be steered, but things still had to be done to maintain things on it.
The ark would only need 1,800 trees without taking into account how long it would take to chop down and work that many trees.
Meanwhile, I look at the myths from around the world and realize people make up the most outlandish stories. To me it just makes more sense that this story falls in that category.
originally posted by: daskakik
originally posted by: FarmerSimulation
And vice versa, doh.
Exactly, so don't say that guy answers things for me. He doesn't, he does the same thing you and OP are doing here, providing weak answers like, the ark didn't need to be steered, but things still had to be done to maintain things on it.
The ark would only need 1,800 trees without taking into account how long it would take to chop down and work that many trees.
Meanwhile, I look at the myths from around the world and realize people make up the most outlandish stories. To me it just makes more sense that this story falls in that category.
originally posted by: FarmerSimulation
I answered a poster that claimed the boat had to be steered.
And before the flood lifespans were longer as per my example of what dinosaurs were most likely to be. Really old reptiles and fish.
But if so the vegetation would also have extended lifespans and overgrowth so as to be food for such behemoths.
It might have been one great big tree that got harvested to build the Ark.
That is not the best arg to hang your hat on.
Imo
originally posted by: andy06shake
a reply to: cooperton
The question begs then, if Noah took ""baby dinosaurs"" onto his magic boat, to be saved like all the rest of the millions of other animals, then where are all the dinosaurs?
Keeping in mind scientists have identified and named over 1,000 dinosaur species, and that's just to date.
How many of those "species" were actually the same species but a fossil @1 yo, another @50 yo, another @200 yo and yet another at 800 yo?
Most of them actually.
They do not discriminate.
They identify every fossil as a new species
originally posted by: FarmerSimulation
originally posted by: Phantom42338
a reply to: cooperton
My question is what about dinosaurs? According to YOU, dinosaurs and men walked the Earth together. Was Noah responsible for their extinction because he didn't pick them up?
These stories get to a point of ridiculousness that even a 10 year old could successfully challenge.
Certain fish and reptiles never stop growing in staure their entire lives.
And conform to the size of the environment they inhabit.
Small fish bowl, small gold fish.
Big lake, big goldfish. Long lifespans, great big fish and reptiles.
I think Noah would have been wise to take juveniles vs. Adult monsters due to size and space.