It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by spacekc929
Originally posted by daynight42
The great irony here is that you are furthering their message by talking about it. You have advertised their subliminal message over and over again to anyone who reads this. Do you see those words in your title? Reading those or hearing them is all it takes for the message to be conveyed. Sharpie made the commercial. You passed it along for them, as well as crafted it into a forum thread. What does that make you? Accessory to the crime?
[...]
Guys if you want to combat things of this type, you'll have to study their game first!
I think you are wrong about this. The entire point of subliminal messaging is to implant an idea into your subconscious mind without your conscious mind realizing it. By uncovering the issue, your conscious mind realizes the subliminal message is there, defeating the purpose. Consciously saying that advertising companies are telling us to stop protesting is very different from the advertising companies actually subliminally telling us to stop protesting. I am wondering if maybe you are the one who needs to study their game...
Originally posted by CountSymphoniC
Originally posted by spacekc929
Originally posted by daynight42
The great irony here is that you are furthering their message by talking about it. You have advertised their subliminal message over and over again to anyone who reads this. Do you see those words in your title? Reading those or hearing them is all it takes for the message to be conveyed. Sharpie made the commercial. You passed it along for them, as well as crafted it into a forum thread. What does that make you? Accessory to the crime?
[...]
Guys if you want to combat things of this type, you'll have to study their game first!
I think you are wrong about this. The entire point of subliminal messaging is to implant an idea into your subconscious mind without your conscious mind realizing it. By uncovering the issue, your conscious mind realizes the subliminal message is there, defeating the purpose. Consciously saying that advertising companies are telling us to stop protesting is very different from the advertising companies actually subliminally telling us to stop protesting. I am wondering if maybe you are the one who needs to study their game...
And study the game I have, I think many who know me personally would agree that I've spent too much time reading tons of books of many sorts relating to the psychology of influence. Allow me to get to the main question, is it conscious messaging or subconscious? Realize that the conscious mind can only soak in so much information at once. Pay attention, when you see that message "Stop protesting" and "Now" appears on screen, your mind is simultaneously processing what you hear the advertiser speaking, that goes without saying there are many colorful distractions on the screen as well... this all creates confusion and distraction of the conscious mind, where the subconscious will possibly soak in the subliminal information without many people noticing it. Sharpie knows exactly what they're doing. This is subliminal advertising. Some people just happen to notice, and sure Sharpie made it a little bit on the obvious side... but that changes nothing. I guarantee most people don't realize what they saw on that screen and how it relates to what's going on with the Occupy movement. They might see it, but do they "see" it?
I assure you the answer is most likely not.
Originally posted by spacekc929
Originally posted by CountSymphoniC
Originally posted by spacekc929
Originally posted by daynight42
The great irony here is that you are furthering their message by talking about it. You have advertised their subliminal message over and over again to anyone who reads this. Do you see those words in your title? Reading those or hearing them is all it takes for the message to be conveyed. Sharpie made the commercial. You passed it along for them, as well as crafted it into a forum thread. What does that make you? Accessory to the crime?
[...]
Guys if you want to combat things of this type, you'll have to study their game first!
I think you are wrong about this. The entire point of subliminal messaging is to implant an idea into your subconscious mind without your conscious mind realizing it. By uncovering the issue, your conscious mind realizes the subliminal message is there, defeating the purpose. Consciously saying that advertising companies are telling us to stop protesting is very different from the advertising companies actually subliminally telling us to stop protesting. I am wondering if maybe you are the one who needs to study their game...
And study the game I have, I think many who know me personally would agree that I've spent too much time reading tons of books of many sorts relating to the psychology of influence. Allow me to get to the main question, is it conscious messaging or subconscious? Realize that the conscious mind can only soak in so much information at once. Pay attention, when you see that message "Stop protesting" and "Now" appears on screen, your mind is simultaneously processing what you hear the advertiser speaking, that goes without saying there are many colorful distractions on the screen as well... this all creates confusion and distraction of the conscious mind, where the subconscious will possibly soak in the subliminal information without many people noticing it. Sharpie knows exactly what they're doing. This is subliminal advertising. Some people just happen to notice, and sure Sharpie made it a little bit on the obvious side... but that changes nothing. I guarantee most people don't realize what they saw on that screen and how it relates to what's going on with the Occupy movement. They might see it, but do they "see" it?
I assure you the answer is most likely not.
I totally agree it is subconscious. The person I was replying to was saying we were furthering the message by talking about it, I don't think it is true, because by discussing it we do truly "see" it.
Originally posted by notquiteright
I'm not buying it. I agree, it's observable in real time on the commercial. I think it is intended for us to see. It's an attempt at irony. Protesting to stop protests. Not a big deal. There is a lot of subliminal stuff going on, but not this.
Originally posted by Nobama
reply to post by ThoughtForms
Um this ad was made BEFORE the protests started thus it saying "Stop protesting" has no baring...
Originally posted by eonpeon
Hey, I'm actually IN that ad!!
I'm the guy at 0:05 holding up the blank placard in the football stadium, and then again at 0:17 saying "Put Me In Coach".
It was shot at the Sydney Football Stadium last year, by Jeff Darling, one of Australia's best cinematographers (he shot the ad on a Canon 5D with a 24-105mm F4 lens, for those interested).
Anyway, I'm here to tell you that the ad in question was put together by a bunch of effervescent bright-young-things whose thoughts were furthest away from mind control of the masses.
The 'Stop Protesting' bit was supposed to be pure irony - i.e. protesting against protesting. A joke. Nothing more.
It was a cool idea that got sliced down to a one-second slot in an ad designed to keep up with the attention spans of those watching today's TV.
Nothing sinister here..
Originally posted by CountSymphoniC
Oh I know, as Chief Advertising Officer of Sharpie,
Anyone can say anything, that doesn't mean much in today's world.