It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: confiden
a reply to: Adski989
I don't understand why you would remove data points like the cases on the cruise ship and from the church. The fact that we found and measured those 2 clusters they should remain. It's important to keep all measured data points to get a realistic picture, the clusters are good because they reflect how fast it is spreading, they are not an "outlier" number to be discarded. IMHO
originally posted by: ketsuko
a reply to: Adski989
You have to leave the church data in for South Korea.
That may have been an intentional incident for them, but the Korean authorities cannot track them, and they are not answering when they get called. So they are very much on the table in terms of spreading this thing in the wild right now.
It's an anomaly, but you have to leave them in I think.
originally posted by: Oppenheimer67
originally posted by: ketsuko
a reply to: Adski989
You have to leave the church data in for South Korea.
That may have been an intentional incident for them, but the Korean authorities cannot track them, and they are not answering when they get called. So they are very much on the table in terms of spreading this thing in the wild right now.
It's an anomaly, but you have to leave them in I think.
Well said. This is where the data is a minefield.
The cruise ship is an anomaly. But the so is Japan being so close to China. Iran is an anomaly because it is pretty clear things are more established there than has been previously reported. Italy is an anomaly because it's not representative of everywhere else. South Korea is an anomaly because they basically have an open border policy with China.
You keep removing the anomalies, and eventually we may end up with the only country that has managed to lie the longest.
Stats. I always hated stats. They can be very useful, but they can be very misleading. It's quite possible that with all the anomalies left in, it is actually much more representative of what is happening everywhere. At least 2 weeks ago.
originally posted by: SpartanStoic
Italy 2 deaths, 79 cases now
AFP Twitter
originally posted by: Oppenheimer67
a reply to: confiden
Thanks Confiden, glad to see you are still keeping an eye on things. Also being into numbers glad to have you on board.
Your chart outside China is worrying. I've done one without the cruise data, which was a bit more promising, but now with Iran, South Korea and Italy, it is tending toward exponential like yours. 6 day doubling might be hopeful based on my modelling.
Have you looked at data for China not including Hubei? Have a look, it's quite amazing how neatly it fits the quadratic. 99.9% I think it was a few days ago. would love your insights.
Regards.
originally posted by: SpartanStoic
Italy 2 deaths, 79 cases now
AFP Twitter
originally posted by: Adski989
originally posted by: Oppenheimer67
originally posted by: ketsuko
a reply to: Adski989
You have to leave the church data in for South Korea.
That may have been an intentional incident for them, but the Korean authorities cannot track them, and they are not answering when they get called. So they are very much on the table in terms of spreading this thing in the wild right now.
It's an anomaly, but you have to leave them in I think.
Well said. This is where the data is a minefield.
The cruise ship is an anomaly. But the so is Japan being so close to China. Iran is an anomaly because it is pretty clear things are more established there than has been previously reported. Italy is an anomaly because it's not representative of everywhere else. South Korea is an anomaly because they basically have an open border policy with China.
You keep removing the anomalies, and eventually we may end up with the only country that has managed to lie the longest.
Stats. I always hated stats. They can be very useful, but they can be very misleading. It's quite possible that with all the anomalies left in, it is actually much more representative of what is happening everywhere. At least 2 weeks ago.
Well said?? The cruise ship was an unnatural spread of the disease, it’s not a trend at all, plus you’re making stuff up, show the data how ever you like but it’s not credible. My last comment on the matter.
originally posted by: Adski989
originally posted by: SpartanStoic
Italy 2 deaths, 79 cases now
AFP Twitter
It’s been two dead all day, Milan are the latest cases.
Feb 22 - #Talesh, N Iran
Locals are protesting the transfer of four #coronavirus patients from Rasht to a hospital in this city. State security forces fired tear gas after protests erupted. “[/ex
twitter.com...
Breaking: The #COVID19 test of Mohsen Hashemi, Head of city council of Tehran came back positive for #sarscov2.
twitter.com...
Man says he had taken his mother to Baharloo hospital (Tehran, Iran) because she was suspected of #COVID19. He added that that the situation was terrible there with more than 10 cases at that hospital .He says even medical personnel were infected.
twitter.com...
Reports that Iranian Brigadier General in the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) and commander of the Quds Force infected with #COVID19
twitter.com...
Reports indicated that Mohsen Hashemi met, the head of Tehran's city council, Rahmanzadeh who possibly contracted the #Coronavirus (COVID-19).
Mohsen Hashemi then have met on Friday Javad Zarif and Hassan Khomeini in a polling station and hugged them with kisses on their cheeks.
twitter.com...
originally posted by: Adski989
originally posted by: confiden
a reply to: Adski989
I don't understand why you would remove data points like the cases on the cruise ship and from the church. The fact that we found and measured those 2 clusters they should remain. It's important to keep all measured data points to get a realistic picture, the clusters are good because they reflect how fast it is spreading, they are not an "outlier" number to be discarded. IMHO
The cruise ship is not a natural occurrence, it’s was a major balls up that led to unnatural exposure and spreading of the virus, the church can stay I agree. But 634 is the cruise ship, makes your graph less dramatic, sorry.
originally posted by: confiden
originally posted by: Oppenheimer67
a reply to: confiden
Thanks Confiden, glad to see you are still keeping an eye on things. Also being into numbers glad to have you on board.
Your chart outside China is worrying. I've done one without the cruise data, which was a bit more promising, but now with Iran, South Korea and Italy, it is tending toward exponential like yours. 6 day doubling might be hopeful based on my modelling.
Have you looked at data for China not including Hubei? Have a look, it's quite amazing how neatly it fits the quadratic. 99.9% I think it was a few days ago. would love your insights.
Regards.
I don't trust the numbers from CCP too much so I don't track them. I believe the real situation is 10x worse than the numbers show, even at the international level. I believe in the metaphor someone posted: we are in a golf cart chasing a sports car. What is measured will always lag reality and all we can do is take the numbers and multiply them by 10 to get an idea of the actual spread. I will relocate to a more secluded location (Northern Quebec) only when the schools close in my region. Travel only by night. I believe SHTF will closely follow the schools closing because they will use those places to expand hospital capacity. Just like they did during 1998 freezing rain crisis in Quebec (3 weeks without electricity). The army went door-to-door in certain places to force people to go to the schools with generators. I plan to relocate before this happens...
originally posted by: GlobalGold
a reply to: ketsuko
I'd think it would be hard to find human "guinea pigs" to run 1st human trials on!