It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by MarkScheppy
"A Marine who had been the leader of an eight-man sniper team in Afghanistan for several tours was looking for a job in Maryland when he was interviewed by a reporter. He said he was having great difficulty in getting a decent job. He said: "Maybe my skill set keeps me from getting a position." This war started as a disaster and is ending as one. We stumbled on the curve and lost the race and the war over eight years ago.
Just a week ago an Army Green Beret Soldier was killed during his 14th deployment to Afghanistan. He is part of the one percent fighting in a country that the other 99 percent don't give a damn about anymore. Why does history always repeat itself when it comes to war? What makes us think we can do better than Alexander the Great, the English, and the Russians in turning Afghanistan into an actual country instead of counties of troublesome tribal enclaves? Being there only emphasizes we are totally ignorant of the country."edit on 25-11-2011 by MarkScheppy because: add
Originally posted by SumerianSoldier
reply to post by EyesWideShut
Probably the best explanation given that I've heard. (Star for you, Sir!) When I returned home from USMC basic, I immediately felt the difference between my friends mentality and my own. My mentality was more mature, more confident. There really is no way to explain it, it is something that is experienced. On a side note, after I was discharged it took me many years to feel completely at ease around my friends again. By then, we were moving into other phases of our lives. Kids, careers, or in some cases, continued doing what they had been doing. I think we, meaning military personnel (Active or inactive) feel that we were doing something important. Upholding the beliefs our country was founded upon, regardless of how far our country's government may have skewed its direction in present day. I can promise you this: When the # hits the fan, you're gonna be damn happy that you know someone that's been in the service, they just might help to keep you alive. Then again, they may remember your (your: meaning some of the military haters) posts and leave you to fend for yourselves. To the OP, I hope you find some peace and comfort in your personal life!
Originally posted by MarkScheppy
Originally posted by Equidae
What do T.E. Lawrence's sexual proclivities have to do with anything? He really more or less BSed about his 'accomplishments' and their strategic implications in the Middle East (though apparently his fascination with S&M was true...) For a long time the only information about Lawrence was what he himself wrote (which was more or less that he's awesome and united every Arab tribe known to man.)
I'm a gay man, have been to the Middle East, and have not been struck by the urge to conquer/unite/whatever it. In fact what I would like to do once I finish med school is to go back to do relief work. Tbh we didn't get much in the way of propaganda other than 'they have Man Love Thursdays' and 'if you're about to be captured save a bullet for yourself because all they'll do is saw your head off and post the video on the internet.' The first bit seems more like confusion about their social norms (though I honest to Raptor Jesus saw what appeared to be a man and a donkey having some alone time on a thermal camera...) The last bit I more or less accept as probably if not guaranteed.
edit on 23/11/11 by Equidae because: (no reason given)
The propaganda that American forces face today in Iraq was already started by people like Lawrence of Arabia. This homosexual tendancy is crucial for venting angry and frustration in other parts of the world and destroying places (based on sexual preference). Not all homosexuals but when it comes to world politics then a man like Lawrence Arabia who is given authority to do the will of the British empire, to subjugate people and make them slaves for control. That gives it a different flavour I would say.
The psychopath takes on different meaning, where you are starting a war where before there was none. And men of deviant sexuality like Lawrence of Arabia who become these spiffy like-folk heroes, it just displays how this is all a big comic ritual by the people in empire who orchestrate wars. It is interesting that the Bohemian Grove club still do rituals where the grown men all get naked and do mock sacrifices to Mol-ech. Conquer a nation and the gay men (no offense) can happily dance around in poppy fields.
Probably most of what you say is true and most of what I say is not relevant. But I know that propaganda is what started the war and the occuption, in Arab lands. We aren't really writing their laws, we want them to write their own laws, while we continue stationing there. That is as you say Catch-22. "Man Love Thursdays?" That really has a Lawrence of Arabia sound to it, though I doubt his was just on thursdays!edit on 25-11-2011 by MarkScheppy because: add
Originally posted by steveknows
Originally posted by MarkScheppy
"A Marine who had been the leader of an eight-man sniper team in Afghanistan for several tours was looking for a job in Maryland when he was interviewed by a reporter. He said he was having great difficulty in getting a decent job. He said: "Maybe my skill set keeps me from getting a position." This war started as a disaster and is ending as one. We stumbled on the curve and lost the race and the war over eight years ago.
Just a week ago an Army Green Beret Soldier was killed during his 14th deployment to Afghanistan. He is part of the one percent fighting in a country that the other 99 percent don't give a damn about anymore. Why does history always repeat itself when it comes to war? What makes us think we can do better than Alexander the Great, the English, and the Russians in turning Afghanistan into an actual country instead of counties of troublesome tribal enclaves? Being there only emphasizes we are totally ignorant of the country."edit on 25-11-2011 by MarkScheppy because: add
I thnk the west needs to turn it's back on the whole region.
Originally posted by DrNotforhire
i wish there was a draft sometimes...
Originally posted by beautyndissonance
Originally posted by Hootsmanwheresmaheid
reply to post by beautyndissonance
Why can't the military just stop serving? All they have to do is wake up!!!
Because they are under a contractual obligation to serve a period of no less than 8 years active or inactive and they have more honor than to just quit and hide from their obligations to their country, and family. If everyone was a coward like you, our world would be far worse than it currently is. Our military training in today's society, is nothing compared to what it was thousands of years ago. Think about the Romans, Spartans, Persians, and Trojans, if you thank we are a blood thirsty pack, imagine living back then, when not only would they kill on impulse and desire, but would also rape, pillage, and plunder when they were finished.
Originally posted by Raivan31
Originally posted by DrNotforhire
i wish there was a draft sometimes...
Don't know about that. Not every one is suited to being in combat and would be more of a liability then anything else.
Originally posted by WatchRider
Originally posted by beautyndissonance
Originally posted by Hootsmanwheresmaheid
reply to post by beautyndissonance
Why can't the military just stop serving? All they have to do is wake up!!!
Because they are under a contractual obligation to serve a period of no less than 8 years active or inactive and they have more honor than to just quit and hide from their obligations to their country, and family. If everyone was a coward like you, our world would be far worse than it currently is. Our military training in today's society, is nothing compared to what it was thousands of years ago. Think about the Romans, Spartans, Persians, and Trojans, if you thank we are a blood thirsty pack, imagine living back then, when not only would they kill on impulse and desire, but would also rape, pillage, and plunder when they were finished.
Errrm, the modern day army's still do that sht and it's either covered up or done away from the media glare.
During high-intensity operations the rule's go out the window in warfare! Always have, always will.
Even during training excercises there's bloodlust and violence going on, albeit usually less-lethal than the real thing!
Roman soldiers served 25 years and got a pension (land).
Soldiers in modern forces like the UK (plus the US I think) serve 20+ years and get a pension.
Originally posted by tangonine
reply to post by Raivan31
Prescient post, Raivan. But you've forgotten that, and I don't want to sound too cliche', military people are also good at adapting.
Having said that, I've known people inside the military that served in high-speed jobs that weren't even able to make the transition back into the "regular" military. Those people are a personality type unto their own, and they have civilian equivalents.
Grimpachi
We may wind up attacking them if they continue to pursue nuclear weapons.
Are you of Muslim desent or is your family from Iran originaly.
As I stated before in a previouse post they attacked us and 9/11 is a fact it was supported by the factions I listed. The ones breeding terrerists are those factions.
PLASIFISK
Moving on, " many of the current military are so easily controlled and ordered to murder whoever they feel is inferior".
Well there is a chain of command. I'm in charge of some, and there are those in charge of me! Accordingly, we accept responsibility for the actions of those we are in charge of. Yes I give lawful orders, and am given direct orders. Now we are not ORDERED to murder anybody. We have a mission, and carry it out. Our rules of engagement give detailed rules of what justifiable use of force may be used in a situation. However, if you are showing an attempt to take my life, I will match your force with the same intent. Inferiority has nothing to do with it.
Next, "that they really are becoming the borg, a cult that all operate as one...a brotherhood of same minded beings that consider their way, the only way"
Originally posted by Equidae
Going to Afghanistan twice exposed me to levels of poverty that are hard to even contemplate. One of our local relief missions was bringing supplies to a village, and part of that was feminine products for the women. When we arrived the children mobbed us for stuff, and some managed to nab the box full of feminine products. In no time they'd ripped open the box. There were 4 and 5 year olds brawling over pads and tampons. They had no clue what they were for, but just to have something was worth risking injury to them even if it might not be useful to them.
That was one of the incidents I witnessed that made me not just want to go to med school, but do humanitarian work. Before deploying I might have considered a stint in the Peace Corps, but not devoting a large amount of time working in third world countries. Now I want to have nonprofit work be a large chunk of my career, and I really don't think I would have this mentality if I didn't have those experiences.
PLASIFISK
Calling you ICE CUBE was in response to you thinking I'VE lost my cool. Never happens.
Our way only matters to us, those going against us. OUR way has nothing to do with YOU. We are not trying to train you.
Lastly," But I see them as deluded and dangerous."