originally posted by: CaecusII
a reply to: ksihkahe
Are you willing to name the "one particular secret society" you suspect Direne may be an initiate of, and/or is working on a book at this
time?
That's not what I meant. Sorry if anybody got that impression. The name will be be in the book, a couple names they had or still go by, along with
their account of their true history. To give the name now will just end up pointing you toward a front group that has little relevance to the actual
group. Their history is interesting, but the real meat is the initiation process.
I meant that comment within the context of having the knowledge of an initiate. There is no standard for what constitutes an initiate across the board
for base level competencies or even an agreed upon set of competencies. In my opinion the ranks of the initiated, across a range of secret societies,
are mostly full of dilettantes.
I was saying, in a roundabout way, that calling Direne an initiate could be considered somewhat insulting considering the low bar of initiation that
seems to be common in secret societies.
I don't have any evidence or reason to believe they're a member of any secret society. If I were held down and forced to give one, my answer would be
none. Initiation seems to involve lots of theater and dogma specific to whichever group is overseeing it. I don't imagine Direne jumping through hoops
like a circus dog. I wouldn't, but I don't see any value in it. I'm somewhat resentful of the idea of having to prove myself worthy of knowledge via
proscribed theatrics and oral examination, so that probably paints my opinion. At any rate, I don't wish to skirt close too what is an inappropriate
level of discussing another member. The intent of my post wasn't really to discuss them specifically, but to express that it didn't really matter.
I'm increasingly convinced that there aren't many esoteric secrets that are really that important to keep secret. I think that culture and society
have given people plenty of baubles to play with if they happen across secrets that are harmful to their payche. Most people don't care to know and
when they do care to know, they readily accept whatever explanation requires the least amount of personal growth or adjustment to the world view.
There are reasons for the theater and dogma in initiations and what leads up to it, historically. I think most of those reasons are no longer
culturally relevant or necessary, they're just still there. I think mostly the initiations today are to create a shared experience around the lore of
whatever the group is. They may do a very minor task of keeping out people that don't want to put in any effort, but they don't really seem to be
screening new membership as though their lives and existence depend on it.
I do understand screening people for membership if you're forming a group for a purpose, though.
I think many people consider FL a secret society, but is it really? I think most of the questions people have are right down in those citations that
virtually everybody ignores, or even in English in the articles themselves if one looks. It's much easier to ask somebody than to actually seek out
that information. I'm guessing that not answering every question that comes along isn't so much that they want everybody to remain ignorant, but that
there isn't enough time in the day to respond.
I enjoy answering questions or exchanging ideas, but I have learned to pick and choose when I think it brings value too. Sometimes I just do it to
indulge my joy of writing, even if I don't know that it's going to matter. You seem a thoughtful person though, so in this case it's the former.
That's all just my opinion right now. There's more that I'm ignorant of than what I know, by a distance spiraling off toward infinity. I have no real
grudge with secret societies or their initiates if the aren't trying to interfere with my ability to exist.
originally posted by: iaylyan
a reply to: CaecusII
I reckon it's the PFJ. They're notorious
Better explained above. I don't know if I'm even aware of what PFJ is. Is there any information about them out there? I'm not looking for a membership
application, but I'd be interested in seeing what their foundational texts are.