It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by jfj123
I took a look at the site but didn't see any bodybuilders of notable size. Could you post the photos or links to the photos? I have a great deal of experience with training bodybuilders including vegans. Vegans do have a huge disadvantage due to the lack of necessary complete proteins, minerals, etc... I've never seen a big vegan bodybuilder unless of course they were taking steroids, growth hormone, insulin, IGF-1 ,etc...
For example, I had one client who had great genetics but couldn't gain size. I asked him to include red meat, chicken and fish in his diet. After 6 months of this, his body weight increased by 40 lbs and his body fat decreased by 2%. He went from looking like a weekend weightlifter to a bodybuilder who could compete in amateur competitions.
Originally posted by Cythraul
I didn't say plants don't feel anything. I said they're not sentient beings. I learnt long ago never to claim "plants don't have feelings" because some smart anti-vegetarian always likes to come along with the old "but scientists say plants DO feel pain" argument. The interpretation of pain is defined by the senses. When a chicken is electrocuted on a production line it feels, sees and hears the whole horrible experience. Pain might be universal, but suffering is exclusive to sentient beings.
As for land use and the environment, well:
- It takes more than 2,400 gallons of water to produce 1 pound of cow flesh, whereas it takes about 180 gallons of water to make 1 pound of whole wheat flour.
- It takes fifteen times as much land to produce food for a meat eater than it does to produce food for a vegan.
According to The Fertilizer Institute (www.tfi.org...), in the year from June 30 2001 until June 30 2002 the United States used 12,009,300 short tons of nitrogen fertilizer.10 Using the low figure of 1.4 liters diesel equivalent per kilogram of nitrogen, this equates to the energy content of 15.3 billion liters of diesel fuel, or 96.2 million barrels.
Modern intensive agriculture is unsustainable. Technologically-enhanced agriculture has augmented soil erosion, polluted and overdrawn groundwater and surface water, and even (largely due to increased pesticide use) caused serious public health and environmental problems. Soil erosion, overtaxed cropland and water resource overdraft in turn lead to even greater use of fossil fuels and hydrocarbon products. More hydrocarbon-based fertilizers must be applied, along with more pesticides; irrigation water requires more energy to pump; and fossil fuels are used to process polluted water.
It takes 500 years to replace 1 inch of topsoil.21 In a natural environment, topsoil is built up by decaying plant matter and weathering rock, and it is protected from erosion by growing plants. In soil made susceptible by agriculture, erosion is reducing productivity up to 65% each year.22 Former prairie lands, which constitute the bread basket of the United States, have lost one half of their topsoil after farming for about 100 years. This soil is eroding 30 times faster than the natural formation rate.23 Food crops are much hungrier than the natural grasses that once covered the Great Plains. As a result, the remaining topsoil is increasingly depleted of nutrients. Soil erosion and mineral depletion removes about $20 billion worth of plant nutrients from U.S. agricultural soils every year.24 Much of the soil in the Great Plains is little more than a sponge into which we must pour hydrocarbon-based fertilizers in order to produce crops.
Modern agriculture also places a strain on our water resources. Agriculture consumes fully 85% of all U.S. freshwater resources
A corn crop that produces 118 bushels/acre/year requires more than 500,000 gallons/acre of water during the growing season. The production of 1 pound of maize requires 1,400 pounds (or 175 gallons) of water.29 Unless something is done to lower these consumption rates, modern agriculture will help to propel the United States into a water crisi
Originally posted by ImaginaryReality1984
Originally posted by jfj123
I took a look at the site but didn't see any bodybuilders of notable size. Could you post the photos or links to the photos? I have a great deal of experience with training bodybuilders including vegans. Vegans do have a huge disadvantage due to the lack of necessary complete proteins, minerals, etc... I've never seen a big vegan bodybuilder unless of course they were taking steroids, growth hormone, insulin, IGF-1 ,etc...
For example, I had one client who had great genetics but couldn't gain size. I asked him to include red meat, chicken and fish in his diet. After 6 months of this, his body weight increased by 40 lbs and his body fat decreased by 2%. He went from looking like a weekend weightlifter to a bodybuilder who could compete in amateur competitions.
Agreed, i looked on the site and whilst there are some big guys, they are not the standard that enter the competitions and win. If they ate a little bit of lean meat, then they'd increase their size, it's a guarentee. That's why they all eat meat in the big leagues, it's not a choice it's the fact they have to to win.
The client you mention i think proves this, whist everyones dietary needs are different, when it comes to things like bodybuilding there are general set rules. The fact people are still arguing this amazes me and shows they don't want to face the truth. That the human body is naturally omnivorous and it stands to reason it would function best when given the diet it evolved to use.
That's not saying in our western society you should eat meat however, if you choose not to then good for you. However please don't tell use flesh rippers, as you so like to call us, that we're ignorant, cruel or evil. That's my major problem with the vegetarians and vegans in general. Some of us meat eaters don't have a go at you so please don't have a go at us.
Originally posted by azblack
Every year we try to drop one calf, slaughter the adult you're back to 5 w/ meat for all year. A garden of 30ftx40ft keeps me fed. I shoot or catch the rest of the meat the way it's supposed to be.
Originally posted by Cythraul
reply to post by jfj123
Ok, take a look at the pics about halfway down this thread:
vegan fitness
It's only logical that there are a lack of successful vegan bodybuilders - because only a tiny fraction of all people are vegan and the fraction of bodybuilders who are vegan less still because of the preconception that there's no point bodybuilding if you're vegan.
Additionally, when you're trying to build muscle, regular good quality meals (7 a day) - whether you're at home or out - are easier and quicker to come by if you're a meat-eater.
In short, vegans have the odds vastly stacked against them. That being said, without steroids, there is a limit to the size one can gain
and I believe it's entirely possible to reach that size as a vegan.
It might take longer but it's do-able.
Meat is a kind of short-cut
but even if I was a meat-eater, I wouldn't want to put my body through the strain of eating as much of it as a bodybuilder does.
All the nutrition necessary to build muscle is found in vegetables, grains, nuts and beans.
It just requires more time and attention as opposed to picking up a slab of meat and throwing it into a pan.
Additionally, vegan's tend to be more conscious about what they put in their bodies
so you'll pretty much never find one on steroids.
The guy in the pictures I linked to is living proof.
Originally posted by Cythraul
Additionally, when you're trying to build muscle, regular good quality meals (7 a day) - whether you're at home or out - are easier and quicker to come by if you're a meat-eater.
Originally posted by Cythraul
All the nutrition necessary to build muscle is found in vegetables, grains, nuts and beans.
Originally posted by Cythraul
Additionally, vegan's tend to be more conscious about what they put in their bodies so you'll pretty much never find one on steroids.
Originally posted by Cythraul
reply to post by ImaginaryReality1984
You seriously need to read what I've written more carefully. I've never said humans aren't natural omnivores. My very first post in the thread back on page 4 or 5 attests to this. I said "short cut" because it's easier to build muscle on a meat diet. I've never claimed any different and I've not once contradicted myself.
Originally posted by Cythraul
As for what vegan's put in their body, I've frequented both vegan bodybuilding forums and non-vegans ones. On the non-vegan ones, steroid use is a widely accepted "norm" whereas on the vegan one, people are proud to use the phrase "natural". Besides this, many people go vegan purely for health reasons so it goes without saying that many vegans are very health conscious. I'm certainly infintely more health conscious than my friends. I'm not saying ALL meat-eaters are unhealthy hedonists, I'm just saying that it is my observation that vegans/vegetarians tend to be more health conscious.
Originally posted by Cythraul
My continuing argument is quite simply that veganism is a healthy, productive diet - whether you're a bodybuilder or not. I'm not claiming that anyone is better off being vegan, just that they're equally well equipped. It seems that it is you who cannot accept this. You've maintained your ground and I mine, and now you're coming for an extra slice because for some strange reason you want me to admit that a vegan diet is no good for you. I'm not claiming an omnivorous diet is bad for you so why are you so desperate to convince me that a vegan one is so bad for me? I'm living proof that it's not and none of your science can change that.
Originally posted by ImaginaryReality1984
The point is and we've shown it scientifically here, and even you have admitted that meat is a "short cut", is that the body needs meat for optimal performance. Yes you can live and be very healthy eating only a vegan or vegetarian diet, however your body will only operate at it's peak when you have meat.