It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by IronDogg
Cool! Thanks for adding in here John. So you are the one who brought forward all this info to the public originally?
Yes.
Originally posted by yfxxx
Ok, let's go ...
So far, all this evidence could also be faked.
Therefore the more complex (and therefore difficult to fake for amateurs) a video is, the more compelling it is as evidence. Therefore I exclude printed documents, because these are just too easy to fake.. Sorry, but extraordinary claims require more than "vanilla" evidence.
Finally, the best evidence would of course be physical artifacts, like, say, an alien tool. I think we can assume that the aliens brought some of their hardware themselves. A metallurgic lab can quickly prove, if some artifact is of terrestrial origin or not. At least, a piece of metal which could be extraterrestrial takes more means to fake than are available to the general public.
I agree that such an alien artifact would only be very strong evidence of the presence of extraterrestrials on this planet, but not necessarily at Dulce.
However, if someone proves that the ETs are here, I'll grant you the existence of Dulce for free .
So, that's it. Now, Mr. Lear, please show us any evidence as defined above.
But I won't hold my breath ...
Originally posted by johnlear
Tim, this is the 5th time in 3 days that you have called me a liar. If you are going to keep that up you need to post proof exactly what I lied about.
As of now, your personal conduct is a violation of the T&C of Above Top Secret. Either you post proof that I lied or post an apology. If all you have is an opinion that I lied then you need to make that clear. Thank you in advance for your gentlemanly retraction and future conduct.
U2U from Ghost01
John,
I'm truely disappointed with your reply to my last post on Dulce. Once more you have shown your gift for petty insaults!
Granted, I know I have problems with spelling, and don't always have a dictonary handy. However, you chose to resort to cheap shots instead of addressing the issue.
I really thought that there was something more to the famous John Lear. I believed you were someone of honor. I think you have now proven to me that you are like many others on this list: You are petty and cheap in your tactics, Love cheap insults, and have no skills for dealing with other people. I tried to start over with you because I really hoped that I could learn something from you being here.
I'm sorry to say this so bluntly, but maybe it will open your eyes:
John Lear the legend is amazing, however, John Lear the Person has proven to be the biggest disappointment in my study of avation and Military technology.
I'm truly sorry that I had the misfortune of meeting the man behind the ledgend! :-(
Tim
Originally posted by johnlear
Originally posted by yfxxx
So far, all this evidence could also be faked.
OK, then no sense it presenting all that.
Originally posted by yfxxx
Therefore the more complex (and therefore difficult to fake for amateurs) a video is, the more compelling it is as evidence. Therefore I exclude printed documents, because these are just too easy to fake.. Sorry, but extraordinary claims require more than "vanilla" evidence.
OK. Then no videos (could be faked by professionals) no printed documents, too easy to fake.
OK. What will constitute proof that ET's are here? Specifically what evidence would convince you?
Unfortunately there is noting defined above. You have presented too many exclusions.
How about an alien tool that was rectangular with smooth rounded edges about 1 inch wide by 2 inches long and about 1/2" thick? Sapphire in color and so smooth it is slippery and difficult to hold on to. It looks like a large precious stone and would definately rival anything that could be bought at the most prestigious jewelry boutiques on New York's Fifth Avenue. Would you buy this as an alien tool?
Don't start holding your breath until we agree on what will constitute satisfactory evidence.
Originally posted by shadow fax
this obviously costs money. are you willing to fund such tests, reports and activity?
YOU want to disprove his statement of opinion (only 1 P Tim, really). Thus YOU need to get evidence that his statements are untrue. Not him.
right?
Originally posted by johnlear
Tim, this is the 5th time in 3 days that you have called me a liar. If you are going to keep that up you need to post proof exactly what I lied about.
I mentioned in another thread, I was the one that published the "Dulce Papers". I made the pen and ink drawings from the originals which were drawn in pen
How about an alien tool that was rectangular with smooth rounded edges about 1 inch wide by 2 inches long and about 1/2" thick? Sapphire in color and so smooth it is slippery and difficult to hold on to. It looks like a large precious stone and would definately rival anything that could be bought at the most prestigious jewelry boutiques on New York's Fifth Avenue. Would you buy this as an alien tool?
Originally posted by shadow fax
if you quote me timmy, quote the current (ie. correct) text. dont use my words to take a cheap shot at someone.
Originally posted by yfxxx
Originally posted by shadow fax
this obviously costs money. are you willing to fund such tests, reports and activity?
No, why should I? It's not me who wants to convince the world of the existence of alien bases on this planet.
Originally posted by shadow fax
YOU want to disprove his statement of opinion (only 1 P Tim, really). Thus YOU need to get evidence that his statements are untrue. Not him.
right?
Wrong!
By definition, I can't "disprove" an opinion.
All I'd like to know is whether Mr. Lear's "opinions"(*) have any firm base in reality (other than embellished stories). It appears that the answer is an outright "No".
So far, all proven facts are completely consistent with the "null hypothesis", i.e. that the secret alien/human underground base near Dulce, NM (or anywhere else) does not exist.
Mr. Lear can have as many "opinions" as he likes, but if he expects anyone to follow them, he should provide some evidence. Lacking such evidence, anyone who does follow him should be prepared to be regarded as uncritical and gullible.
Originally posted by shadow fax
for further explanation regarding the futility of yfxxx's and Tim's quest please refer to the idea's of some smart dudes:
en.wikipedia.org...ödinger's_cat
en.wikipedia.org...'s_teapot
Originally posted by johnlear
How about an alien tool that was rectangular with smooth rounded edges about 1 inch wide by 2 inches long and about 1/2" thick? Sapphire in color and so smooth it is slippery and difficult to hold on to. It looks like a large precious stone and would definately rival anything that could be bought at the most prestigious jewelry boutiques on New York's Fifth Avenue. Would you buy this as an alien tool?
Originally posted by shadow fax
i have a secret place in my house where i keep some extra cash, im not telling you where that secret hidden place is: does it really exist?
If you demand proof, then its only logical that you fund the aquisition of that proof.
I can tell BMW inc. that i want one of their top of the line limo's but without paying for it, i wont even get an official picture of it.
Originally posted by yfxxx
What you apparently do not understand is:
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence!
Regards
yf
Originally posted by shadow fax
yes. what has been, beyond a shadow of a doubt, proven is that if this secret hidden underground base does exist:
...
but as long as nobody starts digging, nothing is proven conclusively.