It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by robertfenix
Thats the secret bargining, let us come in and shake things up, give us some oil deeds and in return we will rebuild from two countries a powerful Islamic state for you. And then as long as you place nice you will have the middle east and money and what everelse you want as long as you help us get rid of the extremists and value "some" westernized ways of freedom.
Oh man its perfect
A common rumour - denied by the government but widely believed - is that Mr Ahmadinejad and his cabinet have signed a "contract" pledging themselves to work for the return of the Mahdi and sent it to Jamkaran.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
I've seen no indication that the Iranian President is trying to bring about the apocalypse of the world. You could say the same thing about a Christian president trying to bring about Christ's return.
This is just propaganda and rectal journalism operating on a "rumor."
[edit on 20-1-2006 by Jamuhn]
Originally posted by snafu7700
once again, fundamental christians do not believe that they can expedite the return of the messiah. these guys do, and are trying to acquire nuclear weapons. huge difference there.
A common rumour - denied by the government but widely believed - is that Mr Ahmadinejad and his cabinet have signed a "contract" pledging themselves to work for the return of the Mahdi and sent it to Jamkaran.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
Where is your evidence that "these guys" or whatever that means are trying to expedite the return of the 12th Immam?
Originally posted by snafu7700
where is your proof that they arent? even when asked in the video, he does not deny it....simply does the old political side step.
Originally posted by snafu7700
i have ignored the remarks of my acting as though i have only just learned about shia islam.
if Ahmadinejad is a "twelver"
then he by definition believes that the end times can be expedited.
my proof is already here....in the sources provided with the article and in infinite's video.
if you want to prove that he is not a member of this sect and therefore does not believe that he can bring the messiah back sooner, then the burden of proof is on you
Originally posted by Jamuhn
Actually, I was referring to the person who wrote the article, you simply copy and pasted parts of it and a link to it.
Well, most Shias do believe in the twelve imams....
To fulfill Muhammad's prophecy, the Iranian president would probably be an unjust ruler to his own people, persecuting them.
That's called speculation, not proof.
The difference is that you are trying to prove he is actively trying to summon their messiah, which you haven't proven.
Originally posted by snafu7700
Well, most Shias do believe in the twelve imams....
which is quite different from being a true believer of the hidden imam.
lets see.....he belongs to a sect (and contributes 10 million to that same sect) that believes they can bring the messiah back sooner.
guilt by association. like i have said, where's your proof that he's not?
Originally posted by Jamuhn
Please, explain to us the difference...with references of course. I'm always willing to learn.
Do you have any references verifying that people are actively trying to bring the Mahdi back sooner?
iran government urging the hidden imam to help
“You don’t understand. These non turbaned men like the Iranian President Mahmmoud) Ahmadi Nezhad and others like him are the real believer in Shi’a scripts, not most of the akhound, who are aware of the theatre their ancestors have written and they continue to play. Have you ever heard of an akhound going to war or commits suicide except some crazy like Moqtada (al Sadr, the Iraqi rebel cleric manipulated by the Iranians)?” my friend, probably one of best Iranian connoisseurs of the mollah’s mind system told me.
“At the start of the meeting”, Entekhab reported, “First Vice President (Parviz Davoudi) proposed that the same as a misaq had been signed between the ministers and the President, one such promise letter must also be passed with the Imam of All Times. The proposal was greeted by all the members of the cabinet who, after discussing the terms of the Pact, they signed it.
According to some Shi’a superstitions, Mehdi is supposed to come out from that well and anyone with any wish can help advancing the time of his apparition by writing to him and recite one thousand times “Mohammad is the Prophet of God and Ali is His Representative”.
reading iran
During my latest visit to Iran in November, I decided to visit Jamkaran after reading a report in a newspaper of a . In the speech he had urged Iranians to work hard for the return of the imam zaman, who, according to Shia eschatology, will return at a time of great crisis, defeat the enemies of God and establish an era of universal justice.
iran's leader's messianic end-times mission
He sees his main mission, as he recounted in a Nov. 16 speech in Tehran, as to "pave the path for the glorious reappearance of Imam Mahdi, may Allah hasten his reappearance."
Ahmadinejad's cabinet has given $17 million to Jamkaran.
I'm still waiting for you to offer more than your parrot-like repitition of what others are saying. C'mon, I know you can do better than empty words.
Originally posted by snafu7700
but considering that you havent bothered to back your own claims up with sources as i asked, while continuing to tell me that i need to provide more sources than i already have, i dont really feel too badly about it.
i guess if youre too lazy to look up the material yourself, i'll attempt to educate you.....just this once.
now, i'm sure you'll have a problem with these sources, just as you did the other. so before you ask for another source, how about you provide a source proving me wrong? if you cant do that, then you have no argument.
the only reason i have bothered to respond with more sources is because i believe in the concept of "denying your ignorance." actually holding a reasonable debate, now that takes talent...and so far all you've shown is your complete ignorance of the subject at hand.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
I thought you knew about Shia Islam, why would you need references?
Originally posted by Jamuhn
Please, explain to us the difference...with references of course. I'm always willing to learn.
Well, there isn't much "educating" going on here as there is copying and pasting links,
So now you do recognize that Shias as a whole believe in the 12th hidden immam and its return. The controversy surrounds that the president of a country is talking about this.
First, I would like to point out that the Supreme Leader of Iran is the only who can declare war, currently this man is Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. Second, this man issued a Fatwa against the stockpiliing, proliferation, or use of nuclear weapons. The President that we are speaking of carries out many of his daily tasks, but is not the commander-in-cheif of the military.
But, also, Iran is an Islamic Republic whose official religion is Shia Islam.
In 2004, thousands of candidates were banned from taking part in elections, which gave conservatives a significant boost in elected offices. I mean, this country's government is intertwined with religion. It's no wonder they have a president speaking of religion...
It seems the group that is trying to bring back the mahdi sooner and with chaos is the Hojjatieh. But there is just more speculation about who is part of that group.
Honestly though, I don't know why this Iranian president is such a big deal
as it seems the Ayatollah Ali Khamenei is the one we really need to wonder about, seeing as it is him who declares war.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
Wow, I am surprised by your lack of tact and your mean-spiritied approach to discussion. I feel there is a major lack of communication between us, and I'm afraid that you do not want to understand different viewpoints or do accurate research.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
Wow, it sounds like the person who wrote this article just found out what Shia Islam is.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
Please, explain to us the difference...with references of course. I'm always willing to learn.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
I thought you knew about Shia Islam, why would you need references?
Originally posted by Jamuhn
I'm still waiting for you to offer more than your parrot-like repitition of what others are saying. C'mon, I know you can do better than empty words.
Well, there isn't much "educating" going on here as there is copying and pasting links, not to be an ass about it,
Originally posted by Jamuhn
use your own mind and say what you really think, not what others tell you to.
One of my points is that news stories are simply being posted without explaining the significance of these stories, how they relate, or your opinions towards them.
What I'm trying to do and encourage others to do is to put these stories in the context of the social and cultural environments.
Another point is that there has been no reference to the commander-in-cheif of the armed forces in Iran, that of Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. You do realize that Nerdling's post referred to a different Ayatollah, don't you? There is no "the Ayatollah," there are multiple Ayatollahs in Iran, and the commander-in-cheif of Iran is Ali Khamenei, not Ali Akbar Hashemi-Rafsanjani. Do you understand this?
Next time, get off your high-horse, do some research, and stop spreading ignorance and propaganda about topics.