Professor of Psychiatry: Transgender is a mental disorder that merits treatment

a reply to: Annee

In principle, all mental disorders need to be treated accordingly. When these politics and activism involved they result in much greater harm for those people who actually suffer from gender dysphoria. Unless someone thinks that hormones, drugs, and body part mutilations, are the answers to someone's false perceptions. Maximum harm is achieved this way.

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Astyanax
a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.

Sex is binary (not a claim but a fact)
There are no 72 genders ( fact )
Sex change is impossible ( fact )

Hardly any claims.

Are you the resident scientist?

Again -- physical sex and gender are not the same thing.

Personally -- I'd ask a real live transgender person what they think.

You are mistaken for a severalth time.

Gender is the manifestation of the chromosomal make up of an individual. And of course gender and sex are indistinguishable to each other.

Only in the minds of the gender ideologists and trans activists these two are different.

I'd say transgenders know more than you. And experts in the field of Gender Dysphoria know more than you.

Let's take Ben Barres for instance. He's a real scientist and transgender.

en.wikipedia.org...

Nobody doubts that there are people with gender dysphoria. They believe they are the opposite gender. And this could be treated, just as Dr McHugh said, from a psychiatric perspective, and not by affirming someone's false perceptions.

They KNOW their brain is the opposite of their physical body.

Non-gender dysphoric's can not speak for them.,

This is a baseless claim. And fact free as usual.
Gender dysphoria must be treated for what it really is. A mental illness. But politics and activism have decided it's not longer considered one... Instead they try to affirm someone's false perceptions.

I've spent years trying to debunk and deride the foundations of spiritual faith. Eventually it occurred to me that much of my endeavor was a waste of resources, for a variety of reasons you can guess at. This transgender ideology feels the same way, a crusade against thousands who haven't offered any criminal indication because they're guilty by association. Atheists, catholics, muslims, transgender, all persecuted by their neighbors and prejudiced in their own turn. In the end it's the division and doubt that hurts our society the most. The need to dominate rather than compromise and synergize. Let me state a simple fact: trans culture isn't going anywhere and badgering it mercilessly into acquiescence is a fool's errand. Explore other options.

originally posted by: TzarChasm

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Astyanax
a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.

Sex is binary (not a claim but a fact)
There are no 72 genders ( fact )
Sex change is impossible ( fact )

Hardly any claims.

Are you the resident scientist?

Again -- physical sex and gender are not the same thing.

Personally -- I'd ask a real live transgender person what they think.

You are mistaken for a severalth time.

Gender is the manifestation of the chromosomal make up of an individual. And of course gender and sex are indistinguishable to each other.

Only in the minds of the gender ideologists and trans activists these two are different.

I'd say transgenders know more than you. And experts in the field of Gender Dysphoria know more than you.

Let's take Ben Barres for instance. He's a real scientist and transgender.

en.wikipedia.org...

Nobody doubts that there are people with gender dysphoria. They believe they are the opposite gender. And this could be treated, just as Dr McHugh said, from a psychiatric perspective, and not by affirming someone's false perceptions.

They KNOW their brain is the opposite of their physical body.

Non-gender dysphoric's can not speak for them.,

This is a baseless claim. And fact free as usual.
Gender dysphoria must be treated for what it really is. A mental illness. But politics and activism have decided it's not longer considered one... Instead they try to affirm someone's false perceptions.

I've spent years trying to debunk and deride the foundations of spiritual faith. Eventually it occurred to me that much of my endeavor was a waste of resources, for a variety of reasons you can guess at. This transgender ideology feels the same way, a crusade against thousands who haven't offered any criminal indication because they're guilty by association. Atheists, catholics, muslims, transgender, all persecuted by their neighbors and prejudiced in their own turn. In the end it's the division and doubt that hurts our society the most. The need to dominate rather than compromise and synergize. Let me state a simple fact: trans culture isn't going anywhere and badgering it mercilessly into acquiescence is a fool's errand. Explore other options.

In terms of the transgender ideology.

The signs so far indicate that society had enough with this absurd ideology.

Several sports have banned transwomen from participating in female competitions.

Several States have banned transgender girls and women from participating in school and college female events

Also States made it either illegal or almost impossible to have 'gender affirming care' for minors.

Some of the States don't allow transwomen in female only spaces and so on.

So there is a lot done about this anomalous situation and more could be done in the future. Yes, I know the transgender ideology won't disappear but it seems to have been defeated on many fronts.

Speaking about 'gender affirming care' it seems again that Dr McHugh and many others are very correct pointing to the obvious i.e that mental illnesses and disorders cannot be treated with powerful drugs, hormones, and surgery of genitalia. I mean it's a really important statement that needs to be appreciated and stated again and again.

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Astyanax
a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.

Sex is binary (not a claim but a fact)
There are no 72 genders ( fact )
Sex change is impossible ( fact )

Hardly any claims.

Are you the resident scientist?

Again -- physical sex and gender are not the same thing.

Personally -- I'd ask a real live transgender person what they think.

You are mistaken for a severalth time.

Gender is the manifestation of the chromosomal make up of an individual. And of course gender and sex are indistinguishable to each other.

Only in the minds of the gender ideologists and trans activists these two are different.

I'd say transgenders know more than you. And experts in the field of Gender Dysphoria know more than you.

Let's take Ben Barres for instance. He's a real scientist and transgender.

en.wikipedia.org...

Nobody doubts that there are people with gender dysphoria. They believe they are the opposite gender. And this could be treated, just as Dr McHugh said, from a psychiatric perspective, and not by affirming someone's false perceptions.

They KNOW their brain is the opposite of their physical body.

Non-gender dysphoric's can not speak for them.,

There are many many mental illnesses where the ill swear they “know”. Typically what the say they know is a very sad set of false, fantastic claims.
So just for the one condition you believe in, the claims must be correct, and the professionals who share your beliefs have to be correct, and every competing belief has been debunked. I wish you didn’t think like this. It’s sad as well.

originally posted by: stevieray

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Astyanax
a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.

Sex is binary (not a claim but a fact)
There are no 72 genders ( fact )
Sex change is impossible ( fact )

Hardly any claims.

Are you the resident scientist?

Again -- physical sex and gender are not the same thing.

Personally -- I'd ask a real live transgender person what they think.

You are mistaken for a severalth time.

Gender is the manifestation of the chromosomal make up of an individual. And of course gender and sex are indistinguishable to each other.

Only in the minds of the gender ideologists and trans activists these two are different.

I'd say transgenders know more than you. And experts in the field of Gender Dysphoria know more than you.

Let's take Ben Barres for instance. He's a real scientist and transgender.

en.wikipedia.org...

Nobody doubts that there are people with gender dysphoria. They believe they are the opposite gender. And this could be treated, just as Dr McHugh said, from a psychiatric perspective, and not by affirming someone's false perceptions.

They KNOW their brain is the opposite of their physical body.

Non-gender dysphoric's can not speak for them.,

There are many many mental illnesses where the ill swear they “know”. Typically what the say they know is a very sad set

A brain disorder -- is not a brain illness.

originally posted by: TzarChasm

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Astyanax
a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.

Sex is binary (not a claim but a fact)
There are no 72 genders ( fact )
Sex change is impossible ( fact )

Hardly any claims.

Are you the resident scientist?

Again -- physical sex and gender are not the same thing.

Personally -- I'd ask a real live transgender person what they think.

You are mistaken for a severalth time.

Gender is the manifestation of the chromosomal make up of an individual. And of course gender and sex are indistinguishable to each other.

Only in the minds of the gender ideologists and trans activists these two are different.

I'd say transgenders know more than you. And experts in the field of Gender Dysphoria know more than you.

Let's take Ben Barres for instance. He's a real scientist and transgender.

en.wikipedia.org...

Nobody doubts that there are people with gender dysphoria. They believe they are the opposite gender. And this could be treated, just as Dr McHugh said, from a psychiatric perspective, and not by affirming someone's false perceptions.

They KNOW their brain is the opposite of their physical body.

Non-gender dysphoric's can not speak for them.,

This is a baseless claim. And fact free as usual.
Gender dysphoria must be treated for what it really is. A mental illness. But politics and activism have decided it's not longer considered one... Instead they try to affirm someone's false perceptions.

I've spent years trying to debunk and deride the foundations of spiritual faith. Eventually it occurred to me that much of my endeavor was a waste of resources

Didn’t you have other stuff to do ? Lol

Your description of what’s going on with trans is disingenuous. You’ve been told so many times that most of us wish we had zero interaction, let alone waste our time hating or scheming.
Just leave us alone. Don’t need your .0001 % lifestyle on our beer cans, in all of sporting events in one dopey way or another, chasing children, in womens toilets / showers waving your dongs, and so forth. It’s all so juvenile and worthless. It’s all “haha look what we can do and how much we can bug you!”
I’m happy to see you happy, cavorting and partying with each other, really I am. The L’s the G’s and the B’s too. Just realize that you don’t have a special license to make me squeal with joy and fall to my knees praising you. Or if I have the nerve to say “Leave me alone”, be lectured that this is hate and violence and genocide.
That’s what your thing has become, and why so many think it’s mental illness.
Why don’t you just do the things you want to do, knowing that most people don’t mind or care ?
But I think you can’t be happy without your revenge attack on everybody that’s not you. Force praise and participation, as a 4- year- old will.

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: stevieray

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Astyanax
a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.

Sex is binary (not a claim but a fact)
There are no 72 genders ( fact )
Sex change is impossible ( fact )

Hardly any claims.

Are you the resident scientist?

Again -- physical sex and gender are not the same thing.

Personally -- I'd ask a real live transgender person what they think.

You are mistaken for a severalth time.

Gender is the manifestation of the chromosomal make up of an individual. And of course gender and sex are indistinguishable to each other.

Only in the minds of the gender ideologists and trans activists these two are different.

I'd say transgenders know more than you. And experts in the field of Gender Dysphoria know more than you.

Let's take Ben Barres for instance. He's a real scientist and transgender.

en.wikipedia.org...

Nobody doubts that there are people with gender dysphoria. They believe they are the opposite gender. And this could be treated, just as Dr McHugh said, from a psychiatric perspective, and not by affirming someone's false perceptions.

They KNOW their brain is the opposite of their physical body.

Non-gender dysphoric's can not speak for them.,

There are many many mental illnesses where the ill swear they “know”. Typically what the say they know is a very sad set

A brain disorder -- is not a brain illness.

I can’t even …… all I can muster is a wuuuuuut … or maybe a lulz.
This is why people don’t like to talk to you. It’s clear that you’re not even trying to be serious or topical most of the time. Not sure what you’re actually trying to do.

originally posted by: stevieray

originally posted by: TzarChasm

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Astyanax
a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.

Sex is binary (not a claim but a fact)
There are no 72 genders ( fact )
Sex change is impossible ( fact )

Hardly any claims.

Are you the resident scientist?

Again -- physical sex and gender are not the same thing.

Personally -- I'd ask a real live transgender person what they think.

You are mistaken for a severalth time.

Gender is the manifestation of the chromosomal make up of an individual. And of course gender and sex are indistinguishable to each other.

Only in the minds of the gender ideologists and trans activists these two are different.

I'd say transgenders know more than you. And experts in the field of Gender Dysphoria know more than you.

Let's take Ben Barres for instance. He's a real scientist and transgender.

en.wikipedia.org...

Nobody doubts that there are people with gender dysphoria. They believe they are the opposite gender. And this could be treated, just as Dr McHugh said, from a psychiatric perspective, and not by affirming someone's false perceptions.

They KNOW their brain is the opposite of their physical body.

Non-gender dysphoric's can not speak for them.,

This is a baseless claim. And fact free as usual.
Gender dysphoria must be treated for what it really is. A mental illness. But politics and activism have decided it's not longer considered one... Instead they try to affirm someone's false perceptions.

I've spent years trying to debunk and deride the foundations of spiritual faith. Eventually it occurred to me that much of my endeavor was a waste of resources

Didn’t you have other stuff to do ? Lol

Your description of what’s going on with trans is disingenuous. You’ve been told so many times that most of us wish we had zero interaction, let alone waste our time hating or scheming.
Just leave us alone. Don’t need your .0001 % lifestyle on our beer cans, in all of sporting events in one dopey way or another, chasing children, in womens toilets / showers waving your dongs, and so forth. It’s all so juvenile and worthless. It’s all “haha look what can do and how much we can bug you!”
I’m happy to see you happy, cavorting and partying with each other, really I am. The L’s the G’s and the B’s too. Just realize that you don’t have a special license to make me squeal with joy and fall to my knees praising you. Or if I have the nerve to say “Leave me alone”, be lectured that this is hate and violence and genocide.
That’s what your thing has become, and why so many think it’s mental illness.
Why don’t you just do the things you want to do, knowing that most people don’t mind or care ?
But I think you can’t be happy without your revenge attack on everybody that’s not you. Force praise and participation, as a 4- year- old will.

Respectfully, you spent a lot of your remarks focusing on ME but you don't know the first thing about ME. In fact I expect you didn't read past the first two lines I typed, which you quoted purely for spite rather than to elucidate my intentions. Otherwise you would have seen this part:

a crusade against thousands who haven't offered any criminal indication because they're guilty by association

Perhaps next time you should read to understand instead of reacting and proving me right.

originally posted by: v1rtu0s0
This is an incredible amount of effort. Just curious, how long did that take? I think the question is, what age is allowing these surgical procedures appropriate?

I dunno? 10 or 15 minutes maybe and it wasn’t a big deal. I was trying to avoid going outside and doing yard work anyway. Why do today what you can put off until tomorrow, right?

Surgery, surgery, surgery… is that all people can think about? What kind of surgery are you specifically asking about?

originally posted by: TzarChasm

originally posted by: stevieray

originally posted by: TzarChasm

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Astyanax
a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.

Sex is binary (not a claim but a fact)
There are no 72 genders ( fact )
Sex change is impossible ( fact )

Hardly any claims.

Are you the resident scientist?

Again -- physical sex and gender are not the same thing.

Personally -- I'd ask a real live transgender person what they think.

You are mistaken for a severalth time.

Gender is the manifestation of the chromosomal make up of an individual. And of course gender and sex are indistinguishable to each other.

Only in the minds of the gender ideologists and trans activists these two are different.

I'd say transgenders know more than you. And experts in the field of Gender Dysphoria know more than you.

Let's take Ben Barres for instance. He's a real scientist and transgender.

en.wikipedia.org...

Nobody doubts that there are people with gender dysphoria. They believe they are the opposite gender. And this could be treated, just as Dr McHugh said, from a psychiatric perspective, and not by affirming someone's false perceptions.

They KNOW their brain is the opposite of their physical body.

Non-gender dysphoric's can not speak for them.,

This is a baseless claim. And fact free as usual.
Gender dysphoria must be treated for what it really is. A mental illness. But politics and activism have decided it's not longer considered one... Instead they try to affirm someone's false perceptions.

I've spent years trying to debunk and deride the foundations of spiritual faith. Eventually it occurred to me that much of my endeavor was a waste of resources

Didn’t you have other stuff to do ? Lol

Your description of what’s going on with trans is disingenuous. You’ve been told so many times that most of us wish we had zero interaction, let alone waste our time hating or scheming.
Just leave us alone. Don’t need your .0001 % lifestyle on our beer cans, in all of sporting events in one dopey way or another, chasing children, in womens toilets / showers waving your dongs, and so forth. It’s all so juvenile and worthless. It’s all “haha look what can do and how much we can bug you!”
I’m happy to see you happy, cavorting and partying with each other, really I am. The L’s the G’s and the B’s too. Just realize that you don’t have a special license to make me squeal with joy and fall to my knees praising you. Or if I have the nerve to say “Leave me alone”, be lectured that this is hate and violence and genocide.
That’s what your thing has become, and why so many think it’s mental illness.
Why don’t you just do the things you want to do, knowing that most people don’t mind or care ?
But I think you can’t be happy without your revenge attack on everybody that’s not you. Force praise and participation, as a 4- year- old will.

Respectfully, you spent a lot of your remarks focusing on ME but you don't know the first thing about ME. In fact I expect you didn't read past the first two lines I typed, which you quoted purely for spite rather than to elucidate my intentions. Otherwise you would have seen this part:

a crusade against thousands who haven't offered any criminal indication because they're guilty by association

Perhaps next time you should read to understand instead of reacting and proving me right.

I read your whole thing. It was just an endless diatribe comparing religious persecution to not celebrating the trans as you may demand.

I quoted your first bit because it’s richly indicative of the trans mission. You would have to to have no job, no family, no home to keep up ….. to fixate on such an obtuse myopic slice of life. If you just let your people do your thing and other people do other things, you wouldn’t need to create a personal mission of dismantling religion for 95% of the earth.
Trans is the same thing. Force 99.9999 % of the earth to attend your little party, or threaten people who won’t.
Oh, and the only “you” that was really you was the first bit, that you admitted to. The rest was the royal you, or the royal we.

a reply to: Asmodeus3

So much for that guys career. He'll be canceled into oblivion, if not attacked by some nutter.

originally posted by: TonyS
a reply to: Asmodeus3

So much for that guys career. He'll be canceled into oblivion, if not attacked by some nutter.

Dr McGugh is a distinguished professor of Psychiatry at John Hopkins University and he has a brilliant career. He is of some age and he is still providing his services.

The ideologists and activists cannot cancel scientists, generally speaking, and there is no way anyone can take them seriously.

The entire John Hopkins University has been criticised by various groups for not providing results and research that matches the expectations and absurd beliefs of the trans activists and gender ideologists.

This is what happens when gender ideology meets science and reality.

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Astyanax
a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.

Sex is binary (not a claim but a fact)
There are no 72 genders ( fact )
Sex change is impossible ( fact )

Hardly any claims.

1. Sex is Male or female genitals. Some chromosomes are not always MALE or FEMALE correct. men with 3 x chromosomes for one exmple.
2.DUH its a freaking JOKE about 72 genders. Im gender dysphoric and even I say that. Stop taking the minority voice as all our voices.
3. Legaly government recognizes people after sex surgery as that sex. Science relies on chromosomes not outward appereance. So you are HALF right.

4.SEX INFLUENCES your MENTAL gender,BUT it is not registering the same way as a normal person such as yourself registeres it. Ive been tested and i have more traits a female has brain wise. In short people liek me register our gender differently than a non gender dysphoric person does REGARDLESS of whats between your legs or chromosomes.
And Since I can reason and think rationally things a normal person does it also means I am not mentally sick.

originally posted by: TzarChasm

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Astyanax
a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.

Sex is binary (not a claim but a fact)
There are no 72 genders ( fact )
Sex change is impossible ( fact )

Hardly any claims.

Are you the resident scientist?

Again -- physical sex and gender are not the same thing.

Personally -- I'd ask a real live transgender person what they think.

You are mistaken for a severalth time.

Gender is the manifestation of the chromosomal make up of an individual. And of course gender and sex are indistinguishable to each other.

Only in the minds of the gender ideologists and trans activists these two are different.

I'd say transgenders know more than you. And experts in the field of Gender Dysphoria know more than you.

Let's take Ben Barres for instance. He's a real scientist and transgender.

en.wikipedia.org...

Nobody doubts that there are people with gender dysphoria. They believe they are the opposite gender. And this could be treated, just as Dr McHugh said, from a psychiatric perspective, and not by affirming someone's false perceptions.

They KNOW their brain is the opposite of their physical body.

Non-gender dysphoric's can not speak for them.,

This is a baseless claim. And fact free as usual.
Gender dysphoria must be treated for what it really is. A mental illness. But politics and activism have decided it's not longer considered one... Instead they try to affirm someone's false perceptions.

I've spent years trying to debunk and deride the foundations of spiritual faith. Eventually it occurred to me that much of my endeavor was a waste of resources, for a variety of reasons you can guess at. This transgender ideology feels the same way, a crusade against thousands who haven't offered any criminal indication because they're guilty by association. Atheists, catholics, muslims, transgender, all persecuted by their neighbors and prejudiced in their own turn. In the end it's the division and doubt that hurts our society the most. The need to dominate rather than compromise and synergize. Let me state a simple fact: trans culture isn't going anywhere and badgering it mercilessly into acquiescence is a fool's errand. Explore other options.

I see a difference.
It is the trans Activists (like many in this thread) that are the problem.
It is not actual trans folks.
Most true trans folks just want to live their lives and be left alone.
Trans activists are the ones pushing these moronic policies, that affect children.
The trans community is and will continue to get the blame.
Yet, the Trans activist does not care.
All they care about is trying to "help" those they think are marginalized.
If another group were to come along right now, they would drop the entire trans thing like a hot potato and move on to their next group of people they feel they MUST help.
These are mostly white leftists (not liberals, there is a HUGE difference).
These folks are the most racist and bigoted people among us.
They believe they are better than others.
They know what needs to be done, better than others.
Deep down, they actually know they are racist and bigoted.
This leads to their "white guilt".
Their "white guilt" leads them to act, with never a thought about the consequence of those actions.
A perfect example is the minority family structure, in low income areas.
It is yet to be seen how their new, virtue signaling, "look at ME", cause will turn out.
It won't be good though and they don't care.

originally posted by: yuppa

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

originally posted by: Astyanax
a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.

Sex is binary (not a claim but a fact)
There are no 72 genders ( fact )
Sex change is impossible ( fact )

Hardly any claims.

1. Sex is Male or female genitals. Some chromosomes are not always MALE or FEMALE correct. men with 3 x chromosomes for one exmple.
2.DUH its a freaking JOKE about 72 genders. Im gender dysphoric and even I say that. Stop taking the minority voice as all our voices.
3. Legaly government recognizes people after sex surgery as that sex. Science relies on chromosomes not outward appereance. So you are HALF right.

4.SEX INFLUENCES your MENTAL gender,BUT it is not registering the same way as a normal person such as yourself registeres it. Ive been tested and i have more traits a female has brain wise. In short people liek me register our gender differently than a non gender dysphoric person does REGARDLESS of whats between your legs or chromosomes.
And Since I can reason and think rationally things a normal person does it also means I am not mentally sick.

First paragraph of yours

You said:

Sex is Male or female genitals. Some chromosomes are not always MALE or FEMALE correct. men with 3 x chromosomes for one exmple.

Before you can have any conversation about these matters you need to get informed properly and not replying on false information, misinformation, and disinformation.

Now if you read on the subject of sex development disorders you can find out what is wrong with the claims you made.

I let you find it.

Example XXY or commonly known as Klinefelter syndrome

a reply to: Asmodeus3

I already posted the link in the thread. if you cant find it thats your fault. You wont read it anyway so whats the point in me posting it again?

Chromosomes are not the end al be all in sex determination. Even WITH extra ones or missing ones or swapped ones they still look male or female. Ever hear of girls being raised as girls and it turns out they are boys? their chromosomes are out of wack. Ill drop the link.

dont start deveolping a penis until 12

On the Opposite end In Swyer syndrome, individuals have one X chromosome and one Y chromosome in each cell, which is the pattern typically found in boys and men; however, they have female reproductive structures.

People with Swyer syndrome have female external genitalia and some female internal reproductive structures. These individuals usually have a uterus and fallopian tubes, but their gonads (ovaries or testes) are not functional.

Point is CHROMOSOMES are not infalliable. Same as science.

originally posted by: yuppa
a reply to: Asmodeus3

I already posted the link in the thread. if you cant find it thats your fault. You wont read it anyway so whats the point in me posting it again?

Chromosomes are not the end al be all in sex determination. Even WITH extra ones or missing ones or swapped ones they still look male or female. Ever hear of girls being raised as girls and it turns out they are boys? their chromosomes are out of wack. Ill drop the link.

dont start deveolping a penis until 12

On the Opposite end In Swyer syndrome, individuals have one X chromosome and one Y chromosome in each cell, which is the pattern typically found in boys and men; however, they have female reproductive structures.

People with Swyer syndrome have female external genitalia and some female internal reproductive structures. These individuals usually have a uterus and fallopian tubes, but their gonads (ovaries or testes) are not functional.

Point is CHROMOSOMES are not infalliable. Same as science.

I will insist that you should look at the facts and not guide yourself by misinformation and confused arguments.

First paragraph of yours for once more.

You said:

Sex is Male or female genitals. Some chromosomes are not always MALE or FEMALE correct. men with 3 x chromosomes for one exmple.

Before you can have any conversation about these matters you need to get informed properly and not replying on false information, misinformation, and disinformation.

Now if you read on the subject of sex development disorders you can find out what is wrong with the claims you made.

I let you find it.

Example XXY or commonly known as Klinefelter syndrome


(Your link above cannot be found. But the link is irrelevant anyway)

As I have pointed out to you several times in the past the medical condition called intersex has nothing to do with transgenderism. You don't remember our conversations. It looks that not only you don't know what intersex means but you don't even know what transgender is! You are not the only confusing these two.