Professor of Psychiatry: Transgender is a mental disorder that merits treatment

You yourself seem to have run out of steam and resorting only to groupings of logical fallacies.
You are no victim here.
But it is getting repetitive.
This trans thing has my attention because it is a clear attack on women,femininity and motherhood/fatherhood.
The lea Thomas thing pisses me off.
He is an open satanist that brags about doing it all for kicks and gets off on exposing himself to young women.
Look at how dogmatic the transactivism is.
Competing for religious space not just social.
You are right though, in recognizing the Christian views and space in societies social sphere is the space that Astarte requires.
No way to return to temple prostitutes while it's ideology and moral influence act as bulwark to her rise after 2000 years of being forced into the catacombs so as not to be heard or seen.
The trans movement is true religion

originally posted by: AdifferentOpinion

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

Your may have missed my post earlier when I said:

"By the way, I see you are a new member and so welcome to the site. I know that my threads are quite attractive and they do attract a lot of attention. And what more proof I need when a new member creates an ATS account and his/her first post is in my thread and all other posts made so far can again be found here in this thread."

Yeah so what? All I see is you weakly trying to discredit and diminish my contribution to your thread as you do with everyone that doesn’t totally agree with you because my comments don’t fit your paradigm and because I don’t roll over like the rest of your sycophants without questioning your logic. Don’t worry, I am sure I will soon be disinvited from participating here.

(insert your fallback statement here about anyone that isn’t in lock step with your beliefs is a woke gender ideologue or a trans activist. Go ahead, you know you wanna)

You don't seem to want a discussion only dominance over the conversation and not a damn things anyone has said to you in all your multiple threads attempting to dehumanize trans people and rally sentiment in your favor has helped you not sound like a broken record sanctimoniously repeating the same thing over and over thread after thread because you are right and everyone else who doesn’t agree isn’t. I do however gotta give props to all those trans people living rent free in your head. If it wasn’t so sad and pathetic, it would almost be humorous.

posted by: scraedtosleep
What if souls have a gender and the soul
in that body happens to be a different gender . .

We all can see . . .
that those who try to
lure, to have minors unnecessarily mutilated,
have absolutely no soul to begin with.
. . . and your point, besides being a predator ?


____________

posted by:1947boomer
It looks like gender reassignment surgery saves lives.

right *sarcasm*
tell that to the family of these dead lab-experiments,
all while Dr. Frankenstein is $promoting
mutilating kids and minds.

en.wikipedia.org...

thepostmillennial.com...

STOP ADULTERATING THE KIDS
and keep YOUR kinks to yourself.


_______________

originally posted by: Nevercompromise

This trans thing has my attention because it is a clear attack on women,femininity and motherhood/fatherhood.

Perhaps speak for yourself.

I am a woman and a mother -- I do not feel attacked in anyway.

It is really a shame -- bullying in these threads takes priority over conversation.

posted by: Annee
I am a woman and a mother -- I do
not feel attacked in anyway.

People being mocked by black-face
shouldn't have been offended either ?
Enabling is a sickness in itself.
Just think,
at one time many thought
and endorsed black-face too, and thought
that was o.k.
It's not o.k. and neither is
it o.k. in pretending to be a
woman when you are not.


__________________

I left you out by saying feminine though.
You definitely express masculine untraditional feminine features.
Figures that would trigger you

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: Nevercompromise

This trans thing has my attention because it is a clear attack on women,femininity and motherhood/fatherhood.

Perhaps speak for yourself.

I am a woman and a mother -- I do not feel attacked in anyway.

It is really a shame -- bullying in these threads takes priority over conversation.

You are a bully anyway.
What are you doing mansplainin everything?
I was referring to a traditional, feminine woman/wife/mother.
You never tried it so how would you know?
So I am speaking for myself in defense of feminine women.
Now with the disclaimer: not for Anne, she is exempt. We offer a trade. That side can have Anne in trade for hmmmmm...who do we want?
The trans team gets Anne, we want Meghan Fox.
She is too pretty so it's confusing. (Did I gender her correctly)
If a representative from the other team can let us know if this is satisfactory as soon as possible that would be appreciated.
No offense Anne. But it's a good trade. We already have all your info from the other threads anyway. Each topic, same references and answers.

Btw you never answered the question from the other thread.
If a mother continually called their child fat for eating so much food from the time they were born.
Everyday saying things like, get off me you fat little nipple hog...you little pig. Look at you with all that creamed carrots all over your face you piglet.
You are so fat and chubby.
Your ass is fat in that diaper.

If the child becomes anorexic.
If the child is her brain as you say.
And the child at 3 years old thinks they are fat.
Is she fat?

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: yuppa
a reply to: lostgirl

Now that Post you made I think is how people should approach this. Yeah I think if you are under 18 you should not be able to change yourself or take hormones or anything related to it.

Great in theory.

But here's the problem. Everyone develops at their own rate.

Suppose you are a male to female transgender with Precocious Puberty. Your body starts changing to male characteristics at an early age. Females (in general) do not want male characteristics. The only way to prevent this is puberty blockers and/or hormone therapy.

I am not talking about any physical surgery.

They re even rarer though. the normies need a set age so they can move on so we should just give in to them. Cant argue their science is wrong either because they refuse to see that science is NEVER settled. Owner is right about how posters act in these threads.

originally posted by: yuppa

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: yuppa
a reply to: lostgirl

Now that Post you made I think is how people should approach this. Yeah I think if you are under 18 you should not be able to change yourself or take hormones or anything related to it.

Great in theory.

But here's the problem. Everyone develops at their own rate.

Suppose you are a male to female transgender with Precocious Puberty. Your body starts changing to male characteristics at an early age. Females (in general) do not want male characteristics. The only way to prevent this is puberty blockers and/or hormone therapy.

I am not talking about any physical surgery.

They re even rarer though. the normies need a set age so they can move on so we should just give in to them. Cant argue their science is wrong either because they refuse to see that science is NEVER settled. Owner is right about how posters act in these threads.

"Science is NEVER settled" -- I'm stealing that. So true.

I have a 15-year-old -- he and his mixed gender friends -- openly discuss sexual fluidity. Who you are attracted to is who you are attracted to. The man-made restrictions are dissipating.

Acceptance is the key -- gonna take awhile -- but it will be part of the "norm" as society evolves.

originally posted by: ToneDeaf

posted by: Annee
I am a woman and a mother -- I do
not feel attacked in anyway.

People being mocked by black-face
shouldn't have been offended either ?
Enabling is a sickness in itself.
Just think,
at one time many thought
and endorsed black-face too, and thought
that was o.k.
It's not o.k. and neither is
it o.k. in pretending to be a
woman when you are not.


__________________

Society evolution. What has always been -- has always been -- whether society accepts it or not.

Gender brain is not pretending.

originally posted by: AdifferentOpinion

originally posted by: Asmodeus3

Your may have missed my post earlier when I said:

"By the way, I see you are a new member and so welcome to the site. I know that my threads are quite attractive and they do attract a lot of attention. And what more proof I need when a new member creates an ATS account and his/her first post is in my thread and all other posts made so far can again be found here in this thread."

Yeah so what? All I see is you weakly trying to discredit and diminish my contribution to your thread as you do with everyone that doesn’t totally agree with you because my comments don’t fit your paradigm and because I don’t roll over like the rest of your sycophants without questioning your logic. Don’t worry, I am sure I will soon be disinvited from participating here.

(insert your fallback statement here about anyone that isn’t in lock step with your beliefs is a woke gender ideologue or a trans activist. Go ahead, you know you wanna)

You don't seem to want a discussion only dominance over the conversation and not a damn things anyone has said to you in all your multiple threads attempting to dehumanize trans people and rally sentiment in your favor has helped you not sound like a broken record sanctimoniously repeating the same thing over and over thread after thread because you are right and everyone else who doesn’t agree isn’t. I do however gotta give props to all those trans people living rent free in your head. If it wasn’t so sad and pathetic, it would almost be humorous.

Your contribution to my thread was minimal and you engaged in transgender-ideology apologetics and denialism of reality. You made a series of arguments which have all shown not to be true. And I have replied to you with plenty of explanations. Let's see them again.

1)You said that men and women are cultural labels based on societal roles, behaviour, and experiences. That's clearly wrong.

A man is an adult human male
A woman is an adult human female

What determines biological sex is the Y chromosome and not societal roles, opinions, feelings, politics, and activism. If the Y chromosome is present then you have a male, if the Y chromosome is absent then you are a female.


2) You said you are neither an activist or a gender ideologist.

From only a few of your posts that doesn't seem to be true.


3) You said that I am not that smart if I think that people really claim men can get pregnant and give birth.

I immediately answered that I am not the one who makes these kind of nonsensical claims. And I am not the one who isn't 'smart'

I don't think I am the one who has blown it out of proportion. If you take a look around it's an absurd ideology that is trying to establish itself against everything and everyone.

Here is example I gave you yesterday

www.theguardian.com...

The dad who gave birth: ‘Being pregnant doesn't change me being a trans man’

4) You asked how does a boy become a man trying to extract an answer based on the principles of the gender ideology.

I corrected you with the basics

I have just stated facts and was about to come initiate a conversation of how a boy becomes a man. He goes through puberty as we all know.

You insinuated that I am using a sophistic rhetoric to propagate my intolerant views and that I dehumanise trans people. That's demonstrably false. I am just stating facts.

5) You have said that there could be more genders other than the two they we know of as some women ate masculine and some men are feminine.

This is what I replied to you:

Being a feminine male doesn't make you a woman. Being a masculine female doesn't make you a man.

You have to ask yourself why the number of genders is usually two. And why transgenderism encourages people to explore and why not to change gender directly recognising that there are only two genders! What a coincidence between the number of genders and the number of sexes!

Maybe we all know the answer!



Everything you have argued is just false. Now you are trying to appeal to emotions after all these arguments have failed. You have called me a sycophant and someone who dehumanizes trans people. It's precisely what genders ideologists do and trans activists. They employ personal attacks when their fact-free assertions and opinions are not accepted by those who have opened a few books in biology.

The arguments you have made have been shown not to be true and don't hold. If you call basic science and genetics as sophistic rhetoric then I am afraid you are very confused and taken by this gender ideology.

a reply to: Asmodeus3

How predictable. Dude, whatever you need to tell yourself to cope, feel superior and be right is fine with me. I know you can't help it.

originally posted by: AdifferentOpinion
a reply to: Asmodeus3

How predictable. Dude, whatever you need to tell yourself to cope, feel superior and be right is fine with me. I know you can't help it.

You got no valid arguments I am afraid.

You still seem to be confusing gender ideology with science and reality.

I have explicitly shown you why your arguments have no basis. And no, a woman isn't a construct or a cultural label. There is no evidence for the existence of 72 genders just as there is no evidence for the existence of pink unicorns and goblins.

originally posted by: scraedtosleep
a reply to: Asmodeus3

What if souls have a gender and the soul in that body happens to be a different gender than the body? Then it wouldn’t be a mental illness at all. Anyone want to prove to me that souls don’t have gender?

What if your soul announces that it’s really always been 40 years younger than you thought, and it really must use the toddlers bathroom ?

What if it announces that it’s African American and wants it’s reparations ?

What if it’s always been a beautiful proud paraplegic and you’d better get rid of these disgusting legs ?

None of these is any more or less ridiculous than the gender/ sexual version. All retarded confusion.

Adult, rational wisdom will tell you not to go down the sad, sad path, of any one of them.

Do any one of them, you give credibility to all of them.

No extra credit for announcing they’re all yukky except for the one you like.

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: yuppa

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: yuppa
a reply to: lostgirl

Now that Post you made I think is how people should approach this. Yeah I think if you are under 18 you should not be able to change yourself or take hormones or anything related to it.

Great in theory.

But here's the problem. Everyone develops at their own rate.

Suppose you are a male to female transgender with Precocious Puberty. Your body starts changing to male characteristics at an early age. Females (in general) do not want male characteristics. The only way to prevent this is puberty blockers and/or hormone therapy.

I am not talking about any physical surgery.

They re even rarer though. the normies need a set age so they can move on so we should just give in to them. Cant argue their science is wrong either because they refuse to see that science is NEVER settled. Owner is right about how posters act in these threads.

"Science is NEVER settled" -- I'm stealing that. So true.

I have a 15-year-old -- he and his mixed gender friends -- openly discuss sexual fluidity. Who you are attracted to is who you are attracted to. The man-made restrictions are dissipating.

Acceptance is the key -- gonna take awhile -- but it will be part of the "norm" as society evolves.

I accept them all with love.

Just don’t cut em up before they’re 18.

Don’t talk children into it.

Don’t let the teens prey on each other or littler children.

It really shouldn’t be that difficult, for people who always claim to be most loving caring understanding person in the room.

originally posted by: AdifferentOpinion
a reply to: Asmodeus3

How predictable. Dude, whatever you need to tell yourself to cope, feel superior and be right is fine with me. I know you can't help it.

Lol the classic surrender without ever admitting it.

originally posted by: stevieray
Lol the classic surrender without ever admitting it.

I will admit it is pointless to suffer a brain locked know-it-all that righteously needs to feel they are morally and intellectually superior and that's about it.

Cheers!

originally posted by: stevieray

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: yuppa

originally posted by: Annee

originally posted by: yuppa
a reply to: lostgirl

Now that Post you made I think is how people should approach this. Yeah I think if you are under 18 you should not be able to change yourself or take hormones or anything related to it.

Great in theory.

But here's the problem. Everyone develops at their own rate.

Suppose you are a male to female transgender with Precocious Puberty. Your body starts changing to male characteristics at an early age. Females (in general) do not want male characteristics. The only way to prevent this is puberty blockers and/or hormone therapy.

I am not talking about any physical surgery.

They re even rarer though. the normies need a set age so they can move on so we should just give in to them. Cant argue their science is wrong either because they refuse to see that science is NEVER settled. Owner is right about how posters act in these threads.

"Science is NEVER settled" -- I'm stealing that. So true.

I have a 15-year-old -- he and his mixed gender friends -- openly discuss sexual fluidity. Who you are attracted to is who you are attracted to. The man-made restrictions are dissipating.

Acceptance is the key -- gonna take awhile -- but it will be part of the "norm" as society evolves.

I accept them all with love.

Just don’t cut em up before they’re 18.

Do you object to ear pinning, rhinoplasty, and other cosmetic surgeries for under 18?

What about puberty blockers and hormones?

AGAIN -- Suppose you are a male to female transgender with Precocious Puberty. Your body starts changing to male characteristics at an early age. Females (in general) do not want male characteristics. The only way to prevent this is puberty blockers and/or hormone therapy.

I do not support any physical surgery for gender dysphoria of a minor.

originally posted by: stevieray

Don’t let the teens prey on each other or littler children.

It really shouldn’t be that difficult, for people who always claim to be most loving caring understanding person in the room.

Preying on the innocent is hardly anything new.

Ah yes, Dr Paul R. McHugh, the same guy that feverishly defends Catholic priest pedophiles.

Big surprise

a reply to: Annee

McHugh Exposed: HRC Launches Website Debunking the Junk Science of Paul McHugh

Is there a scientific breakdown of McHugh's claims? I'd be interested in reading it. Please, no videos.