It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Willtell
Sure, we don’t want a war with China but China has to be confronted on some level they are starting to fill the NAZI, Stalin position: interning their own citizens for religious beliefs, stealing Tibet (which wasn’t dealt with), threatening all kinds of nations and stealing their water rights, and is an outright surveillance state( though here the US might envy them) and then, whether deliberate or not, this coronavirus-- a total assault on humanity.
originally posted by: peck420
originally posted by: Willtell
Sure, we don’t want a war with China but China has to be confronted on some level they are starting to fill the NAZI, Stalin position: interning their own citizens for religious beliefs, stealing Tibet (which wasn’t dealt with), threatening all kinds of nations and stealing their water rights, and is an outright surveillance state( though here the US might envy them) and then, whether deliberate or not, this coronavirus-- a total assault on humanity.
If only we had developed some form of partnership to combat it.
I wish someone had thought of that before.
Firstly China has the biggest standing army from a long shot, so you got that wrong for a start.
originally posted by: PublicOpinion
a reply to: Irishhaf
Heck Russia can project their force better than China and they can barely get beyond about 200 miles from their borders.
*giggles*
Yeah. There we have it, the great threat China in a not so imperialist nutshell. Keep the warmongering coming, guys! Who doesn't enjoy a more goofy cartoonish show at times?
originally posted by: Irishhaf
a reply to: Jay-morris
Sure soon as you tell me what this quoted statement from you means in the context of the conversation.
Firstly China has the biggest standing army from a long shot, so you got that wrong for a start.
Korea has the worlds largest standing Army
originally posted by: Irishhaf
a reply to: Jay-morris
For active military you would be correct, but when you consider everything North Korea can put into the field vs everything China can North Korea dwarfs chinas military. (Hint north of 6 million paramilitary that would fight if ordered)
originally posted by: Jay-morris
originally posted by: Irishhaf
a reply to: Jay-morris
For active military you would be correct, but when you consider everything North Korea can put into the field vs everything China can North Korea dwarfs chinas military. (Hint north of 6 million paramilitary that would fight if ordered)
Active armies
China 2,183,000
India 1,444,000
United States 1,400,000
North Korea 1,280,000
China has the biggest population in the world, if China was brought into a world war, which is eould be, sorry but their army, active or not active would dwarf every nation on the planet.
originally posted by: BastogneFoxHole
originally posted by: Jay-morris
originally posted by: Irishhaf
a reply to: Jay-morris
For active military you would be correct, but when you consider everything North Korea can put into the field vs everything China can North Korea dwarfs chinas military. (Hint north of 6 million paramilitary that would fight if ordered)
Active armies
China 2,183,000
India 1,444,000
United States 1,400,000
North Korea 1,280,000
China has the biggest population in the world, if China was brought into a world war, which is eould be, sorry but their army, active or not active would dwarf every nation on the planet.
I'm not trying to be a smart ass here but how would China even move that many troops? Where would the war be? I think strangling them economically would bring them to their knees or at least create a reformist revolution? I guess they could lash out against Taiwan? Beyond that, I am thinking they can't project much beyond the South China sea unless they push into Russia or march into the giant "penalty box" that is the middle east?
originally posted by: Jay-morris
originally posted by: Iscool
a reply to: Willtell
Well let's see...China on the left hand...US and Britain, S. Korea and Japan on the right hand...
Screw China...
Oh come on! This would be a world war! Amazes armchair soldiers who just cannot understand this!
originally posted by: OsirianObsidian
originally posted by: Jay-morris
originally posted by: Iscool
a reply to: Willtell
Well let's see...China on the left hand...US and Britain, S. Korea and Japan on the right hand...
Screw China...
Oh come on! This would be a world war! Amazes armchair soldiers who just cannot understand this!
China has quantity.
The US has quality.
China will always be behind the United States in everything. Military, AI, robotics...everything. It's because they don't have a culture of encouraging innovation - everything they have has been stolen from other countries.
The PLA would be wiped off the face of the planet in a world war. You want to know why? Because the Chinese people hate the CCP. They would use it as an excuse to start a revolution. Half of their population would use it as an excuse to rise up for democracy.
The only thing China is good at is cyber warfare and taking out combat command stations. It's one of the reasons why Australia is developing Plan Jericho - which is what the US JEDI system will be when Amazon finally gives up their stupid court actions - a fully integrated, whole of military, AI augmented approach to battlefield tactics that doesn't rely on one central command.
Couple that with Boeing Phantom Works' AI powered UAV that can fly alongside F-35 and other aircraft that is being built at the moment in Australia, and I'd back an allied force of the US, UK and Australia against China any day of the week and twice on Sunday.
Let's put it this way: China has to pursue building a 6th generation fighter jet because their 5th generation fighter isn't as good as the F-22 Raptor. Their jet will be online in the 2030s...when the F-22 is 40 years old. And the US is building a new jet to replace the F-22 soon. It'll probably be fitted with scramjets and operate in LEO or something crazy.
That's how far behind China is when it comes to military tech. So as long as I've got a decentralised combat command that can be accessed from multiple locations (say, from the new Starlink array of satellites), I'm taking Team Blue.
Oh, you found ONE point to argue and even then, meaningless.
originally posted by: Jay-morris
originally posted by: Arnie123
Jay, he has not displayed any kinda of sense, and neither have you.
originally posted by: Jay-morris
originally posted by: AnonyMason
a reply to: toolgal462
This is incredibly naive thinking.
The Chinese control over 1 trillion dollars in US debt. The Chinese control nearly all rare earth minerals. The Chinese have more wealthy people than the US. The Chinese have a corporate espionage capability that's arguable better than any country in the world.
The PLA is twice the size of all US military assets combined. They also maintain an arsenal of nuclear weapons including about 30 mapped Dongfeng 5 ICBM launch facilities.
Fighting China is a huge mistake that would likely end the world as we know it.
Someone who speaks a lot of sense!
You're ideologically naive and that school girl persepctive doesn't work in reality, the cold cruel hard world. China doesn't care about you or your family.
Firstly China has the biggest standing army from a long shot, so you got that wrong for a start.
Its hard to debate with patriot fanatics, but I have to ask. You really think your government care about and and your family? Do you think they care if you live or die? Of course they do not!
It's naive to think that human beings should just let these sociopaths do what they do! Yes, we know that most of the population are conditioned and brainwashed to be patriotic for their country, but now we are seeing people, in this day and age, look at their leaders as mini Gods!
It's worrying indeed!
Oh, you found ONE point to argue and even then, meaningless.
Without force projection capabilities, majority of manufacturing capacity centered on their easily targeted coastal region and a couple dredged up islands serving as speedbumps, this will devolve into a war of attrition.
Point is, we're not the ones claiming vast lands beyond their reach into disputed territories from neighboring countries and creating artifical islands, causing chaos with their militant "fishing boats", something you've yet to admit and conveniently ignore, lol.
As for my Government caring? About my "best" education?
My "best" health an well being?
Plentiful food for my family?
NOPE.
However, because of the nature of our society, they shouldn't have to as we work for our needs, we provide our children with the means and motivation to strive for the best.
Because the truth is, Yes, the Goverment cares "enough" to keep us alive as we are the ones that provide it power
same for Patriotism and Nationalism, which serves as a multipler, because it's what Humans do, take pride in their "groups", "tribes", "clans".
Honestly, Bad Politicians is what creates rot and decay within the system.
You just think one dimensionally.