mass grave of 2,000 ethnic Germans in Polish town

heres the sane argument. lol. the commentary is hilarious




look at the smirk on coles face. what the hell is he smiling about?

reply to post by ClydeFrog42


Can you name something that is false, I'm all ears and open to learning. Unlike some.

ahahaa. this is a good part. then, during commercial, he walks out!

I love how everyones like WOOO!

good debate...

reply to post by mayabong


So, you want me to pick apart that lunatics movie piece by piece, to prove the holocaust happened?

Thats pretty lame. Some historian you are. why dont you name one thing he says thats true? lol, cause i pretty sure theres next to nothing in there.

No comment on my videos eh? i guess you dont need convincing, you have all the "evidence" you need to make an informed decision.

...ridiculous. You clearly dont even have an argument anymore. Put up, or shut up.

reply to post by ClydeFrog42


Yes I do have a comment.

You said that you been to dachou and saw claw marks from all the people dying, but even on the donahue episode, everyone agrees (yes even donahue) that it wasnt used as a gas chamber.

...and for the love of god, dont point to david cole. after watching him squirm in his chair for 10 minutes i wanna punch him in his anti-semetic face

reply to post by ClydeFrog42


David Cole is an Anti-semetic jew? lol

reply to post by mayabong


They dont say equivocally, but they dont rule it out. Also, gas isnt the only way to die. Plus, i was 17 at the time, but I most definitely got the impression that people died in those chambers.

And yes... once again, pointing and arguing particulars well ignoring all the REAL evidence that exists everywhere. The one thing you argue with is my personal experience? 17 year old me is about as dumb as David Cole in those ridiculous videos.

You really need to re-asses your arguments, and your entire perspective. Because it is seriously biased, warped, and possibly racist...

reply to post by ClydeFrog42


Ah yes cool story bro.

Racist? Jews are a race now? come on make up your mind. lol

reply to post by mayabong


lol... he said hes an athiest... in the interview... are you deaf?

Nice try though.

I see your argument and evidence has broken down into, nothing...

I repeat. Put up, or shut up. I assume this is goodbye.

check yourself

reply to post by ClydeFrog42


David cole was born and raised Jewish. Every Jew I know is an athiest but still call themselves jews.

Originally posted by mayabong
reply to post by ClydeFrog42

 

David cole was born and raised Jewish. Every Jew I know is an athiest but still call themselves jews.

edit on 2-11-2011 by mayabong because: (no reason given)

to quote the prestigious and prodigious David Cole,

"I have always been atheist"
-source: that interview up there


Anyways, its beside the point that your wrong. roflcoptr

reply to post by ClydeFrog42


He says he was Jewish in the first documentary and even wears one of those funny hats the whole time. Jeez.

reply to post by mayabong


I think were just gonna have to agree to disagree

reply to post by mayabong


listen up:
IF you were a historian (which you are not) you would not set claims without showing proof befor doing so.
I am an studying german history with a specification in the republic of weimar. Sudying in germany.....I didn't mention it earlier as it had no relevanz. Yet a nameless american knows my country's history better than all the german historians do? PATHETIC. Quite the opposite to you, I collect my information from historical documents. You collect your's from dubious youtube videos...So everyone decide for themselves which of us two is more credible.

from historian to historian: you are honestly telling me you know what "actually" happened in WWII, yet you don't know the name of those "funny hats"? Kind of ironic, it's a kippa.

Historians give people facts, con-men tell people to look for themselves

Originally posted by ClydeFrog42
reply to post by blueorder

 

Lol. Once again, clearly you have no idea what your talking about. There is no substance to your argument, and clearly you lack the fundamentals to understand mine.

delusional

Hard to maintain a one sided argument. The victims were not equal, and that will remain true regardless of your confrontational attitude.

despicable elevation of victimhood, shame on you for classifying a mudered non jewish child as lesser than a jewish child

I'm not Jewish, so i don't see how "mines bigger" applies to me... Fortunately, the FACTS are more then enough verification for me. So, feel free to cling to the empty, idealized, "all suffering was equal" argument.

Whether you are Jewish or not, you are employing a "my victim group is bigger than anyone elses"- that does
not mean you are necessarily Jewish, just those are your CHOSEN victim group.

by the way, Apologists are the ones who make apologies for polish perpetration and equation of victimhood before, during and after WWII, and support the pre-1991, soviet-perpetuated idea that ethnic Poles didn't maim and slaughter Polish-Jews, and actively worked to repress the fact that jews were the primary target of mass extermination in the Bloodlands.

THat is not the definition of apologist, sort yourself out.

Yes, the primary target. For a large number of reasons. Which are all extremely and extensively verified in diaries, memoirs, newspaper clippings, military reports, books, museums, and by the people who still remember the events of those periods.

No they weren't, they were one of numerous targets stop desecrating the memory of non Jewish victims- many remember the events of those periods, not just jewish supremacists and their apologists.

So you can cry, and assume some sort of moral imperative, but your wrong, plain and simple,

There is no crying, just calling you out for the sort of person you are, the sort that elevates the murder of a jewish child over a non jewish one- what a pleasant person

The difference between imprisonment and extermination might not matter to you, but i bet that if any of those dead jews had an opportunity to speak, they would say differently. As would their children.

Some Jews were imprisoned, some were extermindated, you seem to think that extermination only applied to Jewish people- this is nonsense and ignores the tens of millions of non Jewish civilian deaths in WW2 all deliberately targeted.

Originally posted by ClydeFrog42
reply to post by blueorder

 

by the way, your wrong about the polish death toll. Its 3 million. and thats including 1.9 million civilians. rather then.. young know... between 6 (low figure) and 12 (high figure) million European jewish CIVILIANS.

And, your calling me a semetic? Figures. How about a realist, or... someone who actually knows what their talking about?

So... yes... my argument is muddled. Check yourself, again.

No you don't, my figures are correct, and EVEN, EVEN, if the Polish civilian toll was 2 million civilians (which it wasn't), how dare you dismiss 2 million souls as lesser than Jewish dead. Your Jewish death toll was discredited decades ago you ignoramus

ahaha. Just wanted to throw that in there for comic relief. spazz much? This isnt about each individual death. Yes, death is bad, great point! but thats not relevant to the argument...

edit on 1-11-2011 by ClydeFrog42 because: (no reason given)

Nice, "spazz", think the Nazis had issues with the infirm and disabled as well, speaks volumes for you

Originally posted by mayabong
reply to post by ClydeFrog42

 

David cole was born and raised Jewish. Every Jew I know is an athiest but still call themselves jews.

edit on 2-11-2011 by mayabong because: (no reason given)

EXACTLY, anyone with any understanding of Jewish culture realises that Jews self define as Jew for cultural reasons as much as religious- ffs Stephen Fry calls himself Jewish!

reply to post by blueorder


lol. oh god, its you again. Clearly you have failed to read anything ive said, and find it sufficient to re-state the same moronic talking points.

Yes, your right, the death of a polish child means nothing to me. Only jewish deaths are important. How wise of you



ur a scrub, and youve got nothing, alright little boy?

reply to post by purplemer


those poor peeps....may the rest in peace on the otherside x