reply to post by RUSSO
ELENIN NASA'S ridiculous statements John Gorman
John Gorman seems to have a poor grasp of how astronomy on the one hand and NASA on the other, actually work.
All of the observations listed are those registered by the IAU clearing house. They were taken by both professionals and amateurs, few, if any, of
them in any way associated with NASA. These are people like Leonid Elenin and his buddies, who have a personal interest in the comet, as well as the
usual die hard comet fans.Morrison's statement is simply correct, there is a lot of "buzz" around Elenin because of the internet.
It is not NASA's business to look for or track comets; this is largely in the realm of the amateur now. They do sometimes observe a comet if it passes
within range of their instruments, and of course they've sent missions to comets as part of their planetary exploration program, but as far as NASA is
concerned, Elenin is just a fly in the Taj Mahal.
Morrison is perfectly correct in describing his response to the internet fear campaign: there were indeed mass suicides caused by Hale-Bopp and it is
only due diligence for NASA to try to contain the whacko effect. Gorman, however, will have blood on his hands for egging them on.
In order for Comet Elenin to "eclipse" the Sun it would need to have the same angular diameter as the Sun as seen from Earth. It is less than five
kilometers across, so if it does pass directly between the Earth and the Sun, the event would be called a "transit." Look it up.
As for the size being "unknown," that is correct. No reliable direct measurement has been taken of the nucleus
because it is too small. It is
therefore less than five kilometers across.
The main reason no NASA telescope has observed it may or may not have anything to do with night and day at the South Pole... there would simply be no
point looking for it; what observing time
all of the telescopes have is better used for something else.
As for the dearth of information in the news media... let's see... debt crisis, Euro-zone defaults, civil war in Libya and Syria, growing anarchy in
Yemen and Pakistan, famine in Africa...
stop press! there's a five kilometer comet that no-one can see without a telescope coming! Put that on
the front page!
edit on 5-8-2011 by DJW001 because: (no reason given)
edit on 5-8-2011 by DJW001 because: Edit to amend
style.
edit on 5-8-2011 by DJW001 because: (no reason given)