Question for Phage, Internos, Chadwickus and Easynow...

reply to post by Sam60


I'm referring to several 1-liners and posts that doesn't help the discussion from several different members, i.e. it was a general reminder.

reply to post by Gemwolf

Fair enough.
Let's hope he jumps in & livens things up!
Kind regards
Sam60

For what it's worth, yesterday in another thread Internos linked to this discussion of a series of NZ sightings that has always intrigued me.

www.abovetopsecret.com...

Still no Phage? Bummer, I wanted to hear from him...

Originally posted by add alone
Still no Phage? Bummer, I wanted to hear from him...

I don't expect an appearance from my intelligent friend Phage on this thread, as I see that he has been posting quite diligently on a couple of other threads in the past few days.

I, too, enjoy his knowledge. Maybe his name in the Title put too much pressure on him

Originally posted by DaMod
Phage, please report to the question thread!! Earth to phage!

I'll make another shot in the dark for a response from one of my favorite debunkers to report to duty!

seem like Phage has started posting again (www.abovetopsecret.com...)

maybe he just hasn't seen this thread so I'll give it a bump

[edit on 15-6-2009 by kronos11]

Quite unfortunate

Anywho,

Thank you fooff for your contribution

I spent hours indulging myself in all the replies!

Thx

Originally posted by bskivss3
Have you ever came across vids and pics that had you completely stumped? If so, please share. We would love to see

As a skeptic who has bothered to look, I have seen many pictures and footage of UFOs most of which is explainable. I thought the Great Falls, Montana fottage of 1950 quite interesting however, but enough to conclude the ETH.

Originally posted by bskivss3
I spent hours indulging myself in all the replies!

Well I sent him a 'nudge'

As to hours spent... this thread has saved me weeks digging through all of ATS for 'best case' files

Originally posted by StonyJ
I, too, enjoy his knowledge. Maybe his name in the Title put too much pressure on him

Tough luck Pressure goes with the position. Tarnishes the reputation when ya duck out the back when the going gets tough

Bumping for you-know-who

I wonder if he has seen this thread?

Originally posted by RiotComing
Bumping for you-know-who

I wonder if he has seen this thread?

Of course he's seen it!! Are you kidding me? We all know that guy only comes to a battle with his guns loaded and here there is no battle; he's being asked to come to us stumped and we know NOTHING stumps him!

all jokes aside this was still a fun thread containing a treasure trove of great cases that could give any so-called skeptic slash debunker a toughie.

a deserved bump.


[edit on 12-7-2009 by kronos11]

Originally posted by kronos11
Of course he's seen it!! Are you kidding me? We all know that guy only comes to a battle with his guns loaded and here there is no battle; he's being asked to come to us stumped and we know NOTHING stumps him!

He knows I asked him to come to the Mexican UFO thread that has over 500 flags already

Originally posted by zorgon
BTW missed your presence in that new spheres video from Mexico. I guess you missed that one I know how busy you are...

Originally posted by Phage
If I have something to say, I say it. If I don't have anything to say, I don't. Unlike some around here.

I don't think he is coming here

Just a hunch

Originally posted by zorgon

Originally posted by Phage
If I have something to say, I say it. If I don't have anything to say, I don't. Unlike some around here.

I don't think he is coming here

Just a hunch

Haha, I was about to post just the same.
Me is just toooo slow...
But no, I don't think he will post here either. I hope though. Would be interesting.

I don't have anything to say. But I'll say it anyway.

The OP asked if there are videos or images that have stumped me. My answer is that I can generally come up with a "mundane" explanation. When I can't, to my own satisfaction, I'll see what others think about it. As is seen, my (and others') explanations often don't satisfy everyone. I have to add that to my mind, "mundane" does not necessarily mean boring. I don't find ISS passes or planets transiting SOHO images boring in the least.

But there are also cases where there is just not enough information contained in the video (or image) or provided about it to make any sort of rational analysis or even an educated guess. It may be faked, it may be a perfectly ordinary occurrence viewed from an unusual aspect, it may be an unusual but natural phenomenon, it may even be a "genuine" UFO. In these cases there's not really any point. My opinion (or anyone's) would mean nothing. I don't consider that being stumped.

[edit on 7/12/2009 by Phage]

reply to post by Phage


Thanks Phage, only popped back in to see your responce....and it was a Phageism to say the last Which i thoroughly enjoy always

Can we make it a new ATS term?
Instead of rational thought processes....
"Phageism"


[edit on 12-7-2009 by zazzafrazz]

reply to post by Phage


Ahh, there you go. Thanks for the response Phage.
I think though some would have loved to see a video that had made you rather puzzled.
But if there are none...then that is fine for me. You responded atleast.

Cheers.

Ahh consistency Gotta love it

But I bet this one comes close

www.abovetopsecret.com...

reply to post by Akezzon


I didn't say I haven't been puzzled. Did I?
The question used the word "stumped".

Originally posted by zorgon
Ahh consistency Gotta love it

But I bet this one comes close

www.abovetopsecret.com...

474 flags...not bad, not bad at all.

That video is definitely on of the most unique of any UFO videos I've seen. I'm not sure if it deserves the blue ribbon for number of flags on ATS, but it's very believable, unlike some others (like the Haiti UFO hoax video).