It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Byrd
originally posted by: Astronomer62
We have already established that the Egyptians were fuzzy over the Sothic Cycle, and Sirius didn't rise with the Sun on even a small amount of times to how we could calcalate on the first day of Thoth being New Year in the Egyptian Calendar, because the Egyptian Calendar never had any leap days added, in 100 years Sirius would be approx. 25 degrees off rising with the Sun, so the working of their calendar it steeped in mystery.
They kept two calendars... a civil one of 365 days and a lunar one based on the moon and observation. They would add in the month of Thoth to adjust the calendar back to 365 1/4th days. www.britannica.com...
Julius Caesar instituted the leap year system we have today.
But legends persisted, so we come to Hermes Trismegistus, which i feel all these beliefs came from, that are apparent today in secret beliefs, link below:-en.wikipedia.org...
Possibly... though Hermes Trismegistus was more involved with alchemy. It's a concocted belief and has very little to do with the real beliefs and practices of ancient Egypt.
In 1582 these beliefs did creep into the Catholic Church during the time of Calendar re-calibration, you can see this in the floor of Siena Cathedral with picture of Hermes Trismegistus ( not sure he even existed), link below:-
operaduomo.siena.it...
He did not exist.
I would argue that Hermes Trismegistus was not part of the beliefs of the Catholic Church. He was considered a "wise pagan" who saw the coming Christianity and Hermeticism (a competing belief to early Christianity) had some small impact on Christianity itself. But that all fell out of favor until the late 1400's en.wikipedia.org... when there's a revival of interest -- but he never gets adopted as a saint and never appears in numerous cathedrals. Hermeticism is eventually tied to alchemy and then to practices they considered dangerous such as necromancy.
There's actually more references/art in cathedrals and Christian lore relating to King Arthur and his knights and the Round Table than there are to Hermes Trismegistus.
You say that you were trained as an astrologer, so it should be easy for you to use Astro-Dienst where you can calibrate a chart for yourself, use extented chart options to get projected fixed stars on the ecliptic, which isn't accurate to astronomy, so the first Gregorian New Year in Rome at midnight is time, 00:00 1st January 1583 after calendar reform, link below:-
en.wikipedia.org...
Link to Astro-Dienst below, work it out by yourself, remember you need to see connection to M.C. and Sirius:-
What, exactly, am I working out here? You gave a list of organizations with year dates; when the "birth" dates were looked at there was no correlation. Could you be more specific, please?
There is no need to debate early astrology attempts by the Egyptians, legends persisted and by 1582 astrology was well established, and the Catholic Church thought they would follow suit with the legends about Egypt and Sirius rising with the Sun on New Years Day.
Clocks by 1582 were being established, therefore the start of the day was changed to midnight with Sirius culminating!
It was the Romans (long before Christianity) who decided that the day began at midnight: en.wikipedia.org...
The ancient material about Sirius that comes down to us is mainly Roman, with some Greek notes as well. Remember that these languages persisted (where hieroglyphs and the writing of Egypt did not) and that every well-educated person was expected to be familiar with Greek and Roman writings. They form the basis of our philosophy and religion: articles.adsabs.harvard.edu...
In fact, the Romans had a very elaborate set of beliefs about Sirius (see Holberg, Jay B. Sirius: Brightest diamond in the night sky. Springer Science & Business Media, 2007. )
Egyptian legends persist only because Romans wrote about them, and the Romans and Greeks don't record anything about Sirius from the Egyptians (as far as I know... if you can provide references to contradict this please do.)
originally posted by: Astronomer62
Yes the Egyptians had two calendars, the other was a moon calendar, which will not keep things true with the Sothic Cycle, it is impossible to verify through astronomy.
The breakthrough with using midnight was the emerging clocks and people like Jost Burgi, quote from link below:-
"1576: Magnetic dip - variation between true and magnetic north - discovered by English mariner, compass builder and hydrographer Robert Norman.
What, exactly, am I working out here? You gave a list of organizations with year dates; when the "birth" dates were looked at there was no correlation. Could you be more specific, please?"
I thought i was specific, so i repeat again, midnight Rome, 1st Jan. 1583.
originally posted by: Byrd
originally posted by: Astronomer62
Yes the Egyptians had two calendars, the other was a moon calendar, which will not keep things true with the Sothic Cycle, it is impossible to verify through astronomy.
I'm a little confused with all the attention to human-made calendars relating to only a few civilizations. The Sothic Cycle is an astronomical observation. It doesn't rely on a calendar or clocks, which are arbitrary human constructs.
The breakthrough with using midnight was the emerging clocks and people like Jost Burgi, quote from link below:-
"1576: Magnetic dip - variation between true and magnetic north - discovered by English mariner, compass builder and hydrographer Robert Norman.
With all due respect, this does not support your statement that the day began at midnight as an invention of the 1500's. The concept of the day beginning at midnight is a thousand years older and dates to Rome.
What, exactly, am I working out here? You gave a list of organizations with year dates; when the "birth" dates were looked at there was no correlation. Could you be more specific, please?"
I thought i was specific, so i repeat again, midnight Rome, 1st Jan. 1583.
My question wasn't about that date. It was about the list of organizations that you gave, claiming they were all significant and making some sweeping claims (that I have some quibbles with) for them. You gave the years when they were organized (at least I assume so) but not the place and time and exact date of the formation (we would do a "natal chart" based off this.)
originally posted by: Astronomer62
originally posted by: Byrd
originally posted by: Astronomer62
Yes the Egyptians had two calendars, the other was a moon calendar, which will not keep things true with the Sothic Cycle, it is impossible to verify through astronomy.
I'm a little confused with all the attention to human-made calendars relating to only a few civilizations. The Sothic Cycle is an astronomical observation. It doesn't rely on a calendar or clocks, which are arbitrary human constructs.
The breakthrough with using midnight was the emerging clocks and people like Jost Burgi, quote from link below:-
"1576: Magnetic dip - variation between true and magnetic north - discovered by English mariner, compass builder and hydrographer Robert Norman.
With all due respect, this does not support your statement that the day began at midnight as an invention of the 1500's. The concept of the day beginning at midnight is a thousand years older and dates to Rome.
What, exactly, am I working out here? You gave a list of organizations with year dates; when the "birth" dates were looked at there was no correlation. Could you be more specific, please?"
I thought i was specific, so i repeat again, midnight Rome, 1st Jan. 1583.
My question wasn't about that date. It was about the list of organizations that you gave, claiming they were all significant and making some sweeping claims (that I have some quibbles with) for them. You gave the years when they were organized (at least I assume so) but not the place and time and exact date of the formation (we would do a "natal chart" based off this.)
The Sothic Cycles has always had disputes,A) where it was viewed from, and did it change viewing point after time.
B) The Egyptians didn't view this straight on the horizon, but rather a considerable period before sunrise, so begs the question how long before sunrise?
The Ancient Romans only had Sun Dials and water clocks, they NEVER started the day at midnight, water clocks were not accurate, the day started at sunrise, the same as Egyptians.
sites.google.com...
The third century grammarian Censorinus discusses the structure of the day in his De die natali (238 CE) and distinguishes the natural day (from sunrise to sunset) from the civil day (from midnight to midnight).
originally posted by: Astronomer62
The Gregorian Calendar become an icon of the Christian World, it was aligned to Sirius.
It is hypocrisy that the Catholic Church burned people for having different beliefs in the Inquisition, when all the time they were following ancient Egyptian beliefs.
In Rome on 21st July 1542 the Inquisition started, link below:-
en.wikipedia.org...
A few years later on 21st July 1550, the Jesuits gained acceptance.
en.wikipedia.org...
I'm only showing the Jesuit astronomy graph as the Inquisition graph would show the same, the powerful deliberate alignment, Sirius rising with the Sun!
originally posted by: Byrd
originally posted by: Astronomer62
originally posted by: Byrd
originally posted by: Astronomer62
Yes the Egyptians had two calendars, the other was a moon calendar, which will not keep things true with the Sothic Cycle, it is impossible to verify through astronomy.
I'm a little confused with all the attention to human-made calendars relating to only a few civilizations. The Sothic Cycle is an astronomical observation. It doesn't rely on a calendar or clocks, which are arbitrary human constructs.
The breakthrough with using midnight was the emerging clocks and people like Jost Burgi, quote from link below:-
"1576: Magnetic dip - variation between true and magnetic north - discovered by English mariner, compass builder and hydrographer Robert Norman.
With all due respect, this does not support your statement that the day began at midnight as an invention of the 1500's. The concept of the day beginning at midnight is a thousand years older and dates to Rome.
What, exactly, am I working out here? You gave a list of organizations with year dates; when the "birth" dates were looked at there was no correlation. Could you be more specific, please?"
I thought i was specific, so i repeat again, midnight Rome, 1st Jan. 1583.
My question wasn't about that date. It was about the list of organizations that you gave, claiming they were all significant and making some sweeping claims (that I have some quibbles with) for them. You gave the years when they were organized (at least I assume so) but not the place and time and exact date of the formation (we would do a "natal chart" based off this.)
The Sothic Cycles has always had disputes,A) where it was viewed from, and did it change viewing point after time.
B) The Egyptians didn't view this straight on the horizon, but rather a considerable period before sunrise, so begs the question how long before sunrise?
The "Sothic cycle" would actually have been pretty meaningless to the Egyptians. They didn't count years from a starting point, but rather "the year 12 of the reign of Ramesses II"... etc. So they just looked for the helical rising of Sirius and didn't bother with where it rose.
The Ancient Romans only had Sun Dials and water clocks, they NEVER started the day at midnight, water clocks were not accurate, the day started at sunrise, the same as Egyptians.
sites.google.com...
Your link very clearly says that there were two types of day measurements - civil day and natural day. So the idea of midnight beginning the day was, as I said, Roman and dates from earlier than 200 AD.
The third century grammarian Censorinus discusses the structure of the day in his De die natali (238 CE) and distinguishes the natural day (from sunrise to sunset) from the civil day (from midnight to midnight).
...and this still didn't answer the question of why you listed a group of departments by founding year rather than by natal birthdate of the organization or what it had to do with your astrology and Sirius.
originally posted by: Astronomer62
I have always said that dating by the Sothic Cycle going backwards and using dates regarding Pharaoh's is highly difficult, the legend that Sirius rose at the start of every year being first of Thoth is just a legend, as shown below:-
"Determining the date of a heliacal rise of Sirius has been shown to be difficult, especially considering the need to know the exact latitude of the observation.[3] Another problem is that because the Egyptian calendar loses one day every four years, a heliacal rise will take place on the same day for four years in a row, and any observation of that rise can date to any of those four years, making the observation imprecise.
. Firstly, none of the astronomical observations have dates that mention the specific pharaoh in whose reign they were observed...
Other criticisms are not considered as problematic, e.g. there is no extant mention of the Sothic cycle in ancient Egyptian writing...
One recent popular history of the Ancient Near East by Marc Van de Mieroop, in his discussion of chronology and dating, does not mention the Sothic cycle at all, and believes that the bulk of historians nowadays would consider that it is not possible to put forward exact dates earlier than the 8th century BCE.
"For many centuries, the fundamental unit of time was the rotational period of the Earth with respect to the Sun. Universal Time or UT (colloquially called Greenwich Mean Time or GMT) is based on mean solar time from Greenwich, England. Unfortunately, Universal Time is not a uniform time scale because Earth's rotational period is gradually increasing.
originally posted by: Astronomer62
Whatever you say Sunrise and Sunset were used for astronomical and astrological alignments not midnight, this they could calcalate after the Greek math and geometry teachers were able to plot the stars.
originally posted by: Byrd
originally posted by: Astronomer62
Yes the Egyptians had two calendars, the other was a moon calendar, which will not keep things true with the Sothic Cycle, it is impossible to verify through astronomy.
I'm a little confused with all the attention to human-made calendars relating to only a few civilizations. The Sothic Cycle is an astronomical observation. It doesn't rely on a calendar or clocks, which are arbitrary human constructs.
The breakthrough with using midnight was the emerging clocks and people like Jost Burgi, quote from link below:-
"1576: Magnetic dip - variation between true and magnetic north - discovered by English mariner, compass builder and hydrographer Robert Norman.
With all due respect, this does not support your statement that the day began at midnight as an invention of the 1500's. The concept of the day beginning at midnight is a thousand years older and dates to Rome.
What, exactly, am I working out here? You gave a list of organizations with year dates; when the "birth" dates were looked at there was no correlation. Could you be more specific, please?"
I thought i was specific, so i repeat again, midnight Rome, 1st Jan. 1583.
My question wasn't about that date. It was about the list of organizations that you gave, claiming they were all significant and making some sweeping claims (that I have some quibbles with) for them. You gave the years when they were organized (at least I assume so) but not the place and time and exact date of the formation (we would do a "natal chart" based off this.)
originally posted by: Astronomer62
The Vatican obelisk was aligned to Sirius by Sunrise while Sirius was culminating link below:-
civil.lindahall.org...
Epiphany is aligned to Sirius being when the alleged three wise men arrived in Bethlehem, first miracle and baptism.
This i will show tomorrow.
The early orthodox church in Egypt does show interest in Egyptian philosophy.
My carer is putting to bed i will be back tomorrow.
originally posted by: Astronomer62
a reply to: [post=25014734]Byrd[/post.
This doesn't make any sense, could you please show where i said that Epiphany was in September, obviously it is 6th January?
www.agos.com.tr...
You asked for any events in scriptures that were aligned to Sirius, the early church thought that the Birth, arrival of the three wise men, the first miracle of turning water into wine and Jesus's baptism were all on 6th January.
These events were not far from Bethlehem, and by Hebrew day start would happen at sunset on 5th January while Sirius was rising in the East.
Mirsilio Ficino who was slightly earlier than Calendar reform who was a Catholic Priest was heavily involved with Hermeticism, and many Popes did practice astrology of the period, as shown below:-
en.wikipedia.org...
en.wikipedia.org...
Quote from link below:-
"Emperors and popes became votaries of astrology-- the Emperors Charles IV and V, and Popes Sixtus IV, Julius II, Leo X, and Paul III. When these rulers lived astrology was, so to say, the regulator of official life; it is a fact characteristic of the age, that at the papal and imperial courts ambassadors were not received in audience until the court astrologer had been consulted."
www.newadvent.org...
The Coptic Church in Egypt still uses a remnant of the old Egyptian Calendar.
www.copticchurch.net...
As far as the Vatican Obelisk is concerned, i don't have more material, but what doesn't make sense is having a pagan symbol in the Vatican back yard in the first place, aligned to Sirius.