Flat earth theory?

a reply to: InfiniteTrinity

You apparently think yourself a wit. Regrettably, you are only half right.

a reply to: oldcarpy

Why don't you man up and answer my question?

Because I am not interested in you besides using you as a prop to prove a point since nothing you say is ever relevant, or original.

a reply to: neutronflux

Please explain how a geostationary satellite does not meet the listed parameters for orbiting the earth with earth as the primary.

Please explain how your irrelevant ramblings meet the parameters of the current topic?

It doesnt orbit around the Earth. That is what you guys claim. It doesnt move around the Earth. What is the problem? Do you need it to move around the Earth?

a reply to: oldcarpy

Let me give you another shot.

Can you explain why you need a geostationary satellite to move around the Earth? Honestly.

originally posted by: InfiniteTrinity
a reply to: oldcarpy

Why don't you man up and answer my question?

Because I am not interested in you besides using you as a prop to prove a point since nothing you say is ever relevant, or original.

Yet you expect me to provide you with explanations?

Super mature response, as ever.

originally posted by: InfiniteTrinity
a reply to: oldcarpy

Let me give you another shot.

Can you explain why you need a geostationary satellite to move around the Earth? Honestly.

Yes, I could but then you are not interested in me because i apparently have nothing original or relevant to say, remember?

Also, I grow tired of feeding trolls.

a reply to: oldcarpy

Yes, I could but then you are not interested in me because i apparently have nothing original or relevant to say, remember?

Did you already forget about the other reason for being interested?

Yes

So you can in fact explain why a geostationary satellite has to move around the Earth?

a reply to: InfiniteTrinity

www.verywellmind.com...

It's an interesting condition:

The Dunning-Kruger effect is a type of cognitive bias in which people believe that they are smarter and more capable than they really are. Essentially, low ability people do not possess the skills needed to recognize their own incompetence. The combination of poor self-awareness and low cognitive ability leads them to overestimate their own capabilities. The term lends a scientific name and explanation to a problem that many people immediately recognize—that fools are blind to their own foolishness. As Charles Darwin wrote in his book The Descent of Man, "Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge."

Isn't it?

a reply to: InfiniteTrinity

id you already forget about the other reason for being interested?

Yes, but I am afraid that you have mistaken me for someone who gives a toss.

a reply to: oldcarpy

So you can in fact explain why a geostationary satellite has to move around the Earth? But not gonna.

originally posted by: InfiniteTrinity
a reply to: neutronflux

Please explain how a geostationary satellite does not meet the listed parameters for orbiting the earth with earth as the primary.

Please explain how your irrelevant ramblings meet the parameters of the current topic?

It doesnt orbit around the Earth. That is what you guys claim. It doesnt move around the Earth. What is the problem? Do you need it to move around the Earth?

This is why you are trying to belittle people?

Because cited sources have been referenced and quote to convey why geostationary satellites are considered in orbit with earth, and the criteria cited why in fact geostationary satellites are considered to orbit by astronomers and astrophysicist? With the fact that once a day a geostationary satellite does complete a full circuit, loop, ellipse, orbit around earth.

a reply to: neutronflux

This is why you are trying to belittle people?

I have been been behaving better then some of you actually.


All I see is bla bla.

Do geostationary satellites move around the planet Earth or do they not?

Do you need to them to move around the Earth?

It seems like you need them to move around the Earth. Why else wont you admit that they dont?

Because you dont want to admit to your mistake?

a reply to: neutronflux

are considered in orbit with earth

Do they move around the Earth? That's what you guys said.

Why dont you admit that they dont move around the Earth.

Do you need them to move around the Earth?

originally posted by: InfiniteTrinity
a reply to: oldcarpy

So you can in fact explain why a geostationary satellite has to move around the Earth? But not gonna.

Well done. Got it in one. For the reasons I have already given ie. you said that you are not interested in anything I have to say. Do you have a problem with your short term memory?

originally posted by: InfiniteTrinity
a reply to: sapien82

A geostationary satellite still orbits earth in a repeating orbit ,

Does it move around the Earth? Why are you people even objecting. Do you need it to move round the Earth?

Yes it moves around the earth , in a curved trajectory , like every object which is considered in "Orbit"

a reply to: InfiniteTrinity

Again. A geostationary satellite stays above the same point on earth. Hence “geo” sstationary. However. A geostationary satellite orbits the same axis the earth rotates on. The reason This can be used as a point of origin is the center of mass and axis are essential the same reference point when considering orbits of objects with little mass. If this was not true, how would a geostationary satellite say above the same point above earth?

Back to the center of mass. The moon does not orbit the earth. The earth and moon orbit about a point called a barycenter. There is no barycenter for a man made satellite and the earth because the earth is so relatively massive the barycenter is essential the earth’s center of mass. When defining orbits, objects center of mass and resultant barycenters are used. A planet’s rotation is not a parameter when defining an objects orbit.

Please quote where any of the above is false with a credible argument and proof. Sorry. Geostationary orbit is a thing. And you have done nothing to debunk geostationary orbit.

originally posted by: InfiniteTrinity
a reply to: neutronflux

are considered in orbit with earth

Do they move around the Earth? That's what you guys said.

Why dont you admit that they dont move around the Earth.

Do you need them to move around the Earth?

They do move around the earth in a curved trajectory , it just so happens they are moving at the same speed the earth is rotating

what about that don't you understand ?

a reply to: oldcarpy

Well done. Got it in one. For the reasons I have already given ie. you said that you are not interested in anything I have to say. Do you have a problem with your short term memory?

Rofl.

So geostationary satellites have to move around the Earth. Why do they have to move around the Earth?

a reply to: sapien82

They do move around the earth in a curved trajectory , it just so happens they are moving at the same speed the earth is rotating

So how is it moving around the Earth? Is it moving away from the point on Earth that it is supposed stay above? Is a hovering helicopter moving around the Earth?

Again, a curved trajectory through space is not the same as moving around the Earth. It doesnt move relative to Earth. Its stationary.

As explained 400 times before.

Again, do you need it to move around the Earth?

All this is very reminiscent of the posting style of a banned poster called peacefulpete. He would argue semantic points until the cows came home - on and on and on, round and round in circles. He would throw childish insults at other posters and belittle their intelligence and generally behave like a petulant spoilt child until eventually he got done for manners violations and now he is no more. A most persistent and unpleasant little troll.

Now, InfiniteTrinity, do you believe that geosats are up there, or not? It's a yes or now so come now, don't be coy. Man up.

Frankly, I do not expect a straight answer from you but then hope springs eternal.

Does your all too evident pedantic obsession with being right and your persecution of others about perceived mistakes extend into other areas of your life apart from trolling the internet (assuming perhaps foolishly that you have any) I wonder?