It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
reply to post by Willtell
TextThe word Hell, Arabic Jahannam, is derived from the Arabic word Janna, which means paradise and the Hebrew Gahanna which means Garden
So hell is derived from the word Paradise. This means Hell is a corrupted paradise.
Seede
@ Laz
Reading your reply to cross is somewhat nonsensical and double talk at the best. Cross did not state that the lake of fire was hell. What he did say was that the lake of fire proves to him that there is pain and suffering at the end of this age. Another point to consider, that you have not revealed, is that if this entire universe is destroyed by fire, which is scriptural, then your so called grave will also be burned up. So either way (hell or grave) is a loser. By the way Laz, how do you get out of that grave or do you? And then what happens after you crawl out of that grave? Do you stand in mid air? The reason I ask is that the entire universe will be gone. Kapoot, nada. I have been waiting for you to finish your eternal message.
jhill76
reply to post by freedom7
Is the literal fire and brimstone concept of Hell being an endless torture chamber for all of eternity valid?
The Bible does not state anywhere that man will burn in hell forever, this is brought on by the church to instill fear.
BellaSabre
It doesn't make sense; it's not reasonable.
A person has70-80 years average on this earth. He does some bad things, even against the will of God. But he's punished for eternity for some things he did over a very short 75 years while in the flesh on earth?
It's not rational.
BellaSabre
It doesn't make sense; it's not reasonable.
A person has70-80 years average on this earth. He does some bad things, even against the will of God. But he's punished for eternity for some things he did over a very short 75 years while in the flesh on earth?
It's not rational.
reply to post by Lazarus Short
Text
Seede, I was tired when I wrote to cross, but even so, your dismissive "...somewhat nonsensical and double talk at the best." is offensive. I'm even more tired of such.
reply to post by Lazarus Short
3NL1GHT3N3D1
Fear is a great method of control. There is absolutely no basis in reality or logic for a place like hell, and it is a conversion tactic to make people believe the unbelievable, period.
If you believe in a place like hell, you are afraid of the idea of going there. The only reason people believe Christian doctrine is because of the consequences that a place like hell brings. That's a fact.
IDNeon
3NL1GHT3N3D1
Fear is a great method of control. There is absolutely no basis in reality or logic for a place like hell, and it is a conversion tactic to make people believe the unbelievable, period.
If you believe in a place like hell, you are afraid of the idea of going there. The only reason people believe Christian doctrine is because of the consequences that a place like hell brings. That's a fact.
You're one of many who say there is no logical place for Hell to exist, but Jesus portrays a logical afterlife which is the dead are placed nearer or farther from God by their disconnect from Him, Abraham being closer, across an unbridgeable divide, and those farther from Him suffer.
It is the absence of God which is life, death is Hell, they are one in the same. The second Death is annihilation all together.
When God forgets all iniquity, those who are sin will perish away.
akushla99
IDNeon
3NL1GHT3N3D1
Fear is a great method of control. There is absolutely no basis in reality or logic for a place like hell, and it is a conversion tactic to make people believe the unbelievable, period.
If you believe in a place like hell, you are afraid of the idea of going there. The only reason people believe Christian doctrine is because of the consequences that a place like hell brings. That's a fact.
You're one of many who say there is no logical place for Hell to exist, but Jesus portrays a logical afterlife which is the dead are placed nearer or farther from God by their disconnect from Him, Abraham being closer, across an unbridgeable divide, and those farther from Him suffer.
It is the absence of God which is life, death is Hell, they are one in the same. The second Death is annihilation all together.
When God forgets all iniquity, those who are sin will perish away.
What is this little, complicated game?...seemingly perpetrated by the Almighty, perfectly loving God, that begets his/her 'children', to then 'annihilate' them, his/her own progeny for 'disobedience' when the mandate of FREE WILL (as gift) is freely given, and then is 'time-stamped', compartmentalised (christian adherants would like to believe this was so - the feeling of self-importance is one of the 7 deadly sins, but let's bypass that) populated (with the mandatory arch-villans)...all wrapped up in neat box that can only be opened by not practicing FREE WILL?...this version of god sounds like the 'fair-weather' god...and in a dynamic that embraces the procedural nonsense of at least 2000 years of but One interpretation, it is the only thing that makes sense...and that would be a grand assumption...
Hell, and denizens (whatever fanciful name or terrible personality you could clothe them/it in) are real, by dent of FREE WILL mandate...it is the creative principle in action...interpreting it backwards, one misses the feedback-loop corrections that would remove the extraneous turnoffs to macabre carnivals filled with fire and horned ringmasters...but, some seem to love circuses...and evil clowns...
Å99
Seede
reply to post by Lazarus Short
Quote "If you read the Law God gave to Moses, one of the principles you will find in it is limited punishment". Unquote
* You cannot show the punishments of the laws which God gave to Moses with out understanding the oral Torah and you will certainly not see oral Torah in the Hebrew bible that you have. There is a limit on punishment while the soul is alive but that does not apply to the conscious spirit that is in Gehenna. There you will find eternal damnation and discomfort till Gehenna (Greek rendition is called hell) is thrown into the lake of fire.
Quote "In like manner, when the Great Jubilee arrives (last trumpet) with the return of Jesus the Christ, we all go home free, and without debt (sin). Temporal sins in no way deserve eternal (open-ended) punishment, nor does God's Word, properly interpreted, say such. Even those who are thrown into the Lake of Fire (second death) do not stay there forever, for as the first death comes to an end, so does the second. We know this because Death and the Grave are both thrown into the Lake of Fire. Further, the last enemy to be overcome is Death, so that also tells us that the second death is not final. What is final is that God will become All in all, and that means that NO ONE can be dead and in Hell anymore". Unquote
* Temporal sin is a church concept and not taught by Jesus or the Christian Jerusalem church. Temporal sin requires a purgatory and that is not to be found in the true doctrine of Jesus. Death of the soul is a permanent effect and will never be repeated. Once the soul returns to its terrestrial elements it will never rise again from this earth. Gehenna (Greek rendition is hell ), is not a permanent prison for the unworthy spirits. It will eventually be thrown into the permanent place of the lake of fire. Once the spirit is thrown into the lake of fire it is forever the death of the spirit and will remain in the lake of fire forever. Just as the soul dies in this terrestrial world, so the spirit of that unworthy soul dies in the celestial world of the lake of fire. Both death and Gehenna (Greek rendition is hell ) will perish in the lake of fire. Naturally there will be no more death and there will be no more Gehenna. The manuscripts clearly state that this shall be forever and not temporal as you theorize.
reply to post by freedom7
Text From what I have researched, the concept of Hell as we know it today was never understood by the apostles around Jesus's time and shortly thereafter. In fact the word "Hell" from what I have read I actually translated as "Hades" Hades simply meant "death".
Text Ecclesiastes 9:5 ► For the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.
The above quote is understood, by me, as to say that: yes, the dead do not know anymore of this life simply because they are now in the celestial realm and yes they have no more reward or for that matter any more judgment from this life. Most of the dead are soon forgotten in this world by the living and that portion is true also. I do not read any more into this statement than what I believe is intended by the author. I do not believe that this pertains to a unconscious spirit or a sleeping soul. The spirit is never unconscious in death. The body is unconscious as a body but the spirit is judged and sentenced immediately after death. That is the difference between rabbinic philosophy and the doctrine of Jesus.
----------------------------------------------------
Text I believe in the bible, I believe in Jesus Christ as God and one may say I'm not credible if I don't believe in Hell but believe in Heaven- my response is that is a conditioned response and tradition to believe you cannot have one without the other. But God actually makes it clear when you read between the lines, that Hell is an eternal death/ annihilation- meaning once you die without repentance and acceptance of Christ you simply cease to be.
You are trying to rationalize God and that cannot be done. You say that you believe in the bible and then you say "but"-- There are no buts in the bible. You cannot pick and choose what you want the bible to say. You can not bargain with God and you cannot read between the lines.
Rev 20:10 And the devil that deceived them was cast into the lake of fire and brimstone, where the beast and the false prophet are, and shall be tormented day and night for ever and ever.
Isa 66:24 And they shall go forth, and look upon the carcases of the men that have transgressed against me: for their worm shall not die, neither shall their fire be quenched; and they shall be an abhorring unto all flesh.
The new age concept of the Creator is that He is all love and would not punish people as the Prophets and Apostles have written. Not true at all. God is both hate and love and this is written throughout both the Hebrew and Greek bibles. If God was all love then He would not have a Hell or Gehinnom or even a need for Sheol or the grave. Jesus teaches Hell and He teaches His Kingdom of Heaven both. That is His doctrine and that doctrine is also His Father's doctrine.