It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Don't get me started on Roswell, though...folk wanna scalp me when I point out that it was, most likely, a morass of disinfo to hide earthly top secr...Oops.
Originally posted by The GUT
Originally posted by ImpactoR
How does one know that the information in this book isn't disinformation of another disinformation and that one isn't paid to once again distract from the real case.
The reason I don't personally believe that Dulce Base--the book--is disinformation is multifaceted. For one, I just read it and Greg comes across as both loving and respectful of his father. His sincerity seems apparent as well.
Then there's the fact that he's shedding more light on KNOWN disinformation scams and evidence that suggests the cattle mutilations are most likely tied to government projects rather than aliens. The books comes across more as a labor of love than anything.
Further, Greg states that he isn't addressing the UFO mystery in the book. Just specific events and topics that he has firsthand knowledge and experience with.
However, some of those cases have turned out to have credibility problems. Can I ask which researcher(s) you've been mostly reading as regards the UFO/nuclear missile cases?
Originally posted by ImpactoR
Phoenix Lights - the witnesses saw a an aircraft flying over with bottom of the craft seen as 'liquid metal' - liquid metal or I would say - the hot air around it made it looks liquid, thus a typical military ops aircraft, nothing to do with aliens. Kecksberg PA, Rendlesham Forest - military manless aircraft with symbols to look alien but in fact - not.
Originally posted by ImpactoR
Phoenix Lights - the witnesses saw a an aircraft flying over with bottom of the craft seen as 'liquid metal' - liquid metal or I would say - the hot air around it made it looks liquid, thus a typical military ops aircraft, nothing to do with aliens. Kecksberg PA, Rendlesham Forest - military manless aircraft with symbols to look alien but in fact - not.
I have no other source for the missiles shutdown other than Robert Hastings, Captain Salas and the group of people around them. So them. I have no evidence for them being phony, I think there is enough evidence of objects who were seen there and even audio record, probably lots of it still in secret.
Cattle mutilations - I never even thought aliens were doing that as humans are perfectly capable, only, specific cases have suggested that - the way the remains are left, as if they have never been dropped from the air, no broken bones, no one ever reported helicopters around the mutilations, there was only one case and I do not remember where - some mask and equipment or traces of it were found.
I am glad GValdez does not try to explain the whole UFO phenomena as disinfo, unless he has a solid evidence about that and I am glad that he focuses just on the Dulce base case
Now someone may want to pay me for posting the link and offering the book for reading at another site, that's like advertising for free..
Originally posted by jordan77
The whole "the government is responsible for cattle mutilation" theory never made any sense to me. Why would the government go through all these shenanigans to steal cattle in secret, and then just drop them back where they found them? It just seems stupid. Wouldn't it be infinitely easier to just buy a ranch/land and raise your own cattle or pay a rancher for access to their cattle? Just drive up, say you need cow 5, load it in a truck and drive off with it. The rancher doesn't have to know what you're doing with them, and when they cash the fat check, they probably don't care. You literally could make up any kinda story for why you need 'em. Why steal 'em and give back a mutilated corpse?
If they're doing all these cockamamie experiments, why not just treat them like lab monkeys. Nobody goes around stealing monkeys from the zoo for lab experimentation, why do it with cattle?
Originally posted by The GUT
Originally posted by jordan77
The whole "the government is responsible for cattle mutilation" theory never made any sense to me. Why would the government go through all these shenanigans to steal cattle in secret, and then just drop them back where they found them? It just seems stupid. Wouldn't it be infinitely easier to just buy a ranch/land and raise your own cattle or pay a rancher for access to their cattle? Just drive up, say you need cow 5, load it in a truck and drive off with it. The rancher doesn't have to know what you're doing with them, and when they cash the fat check, they probably don't care. You literally could make up any kinda story for why you need 'em. Why steal 'em and give back a mutilated corpse?
If they're doing all these cockamamie experiments, why not just treat them like lab monkeys. Nobody goes around stealing monkeys from the zoo for lab experimentation, why do it with cattle?
So...do you think it's more reasonable, then, that it was aliens...or do you subscribe to the predator theory...or something else?
There are, btw, a lot of reasonable theories, and even evidence, for why your uneducated postulations--as listed above--show a lack of acumen and research.
edit on 10-8-2013 by The GUT because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by jordan77
Typical retort when there really isn't an answer to the questions.
Originally posted by jordan77
I'm going to go out on a limb and say there's a whole host of things that would alarm the public that the government is doing. Doesn't stop them from doing them. All the things the black budget is used for, why would it have to be official? The public doesn't have to know anything.
Originally posted by jordan77
You sound like your feelings are hurt.
But listen, the government experimenting and the government choosing this overly elaborate and sophisticated method of acquiring the cattle for any such experiments are two totally different things.
Originally posted by cuckooold
Does the book have any discussion on UFOs as a real phenomena, or is it generally focused on Bennewitz and whatever black project he allegedly stumbled on?