It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by projectvxn
reply to post by WiZKiD111
Somebody who previously served in the army and is protesting with the OWS supporters makes it a lot more plausible that they 'have woken up' then somebody serving in the army.Scrap that, you can't serve in the army and claim yourself to be enlightened, that's a joke.
Yep, this is exactly what I'm talking about.
Service members are worthless to you unless they serve your purposes.
Why Occupy? Why Tea Party? Why Protest? Simple; The US economy is broken. Incomes are less than they were 35 years ago. Everything costs more. We've had 17% unemployment (traditional measure) for 2 years and we're about to lose many more jobs.. Our collective debt is 370% of our GDP (from all sources, from consumer to gov't). Our financial system has a) enabled the transfer of our manufacturing jobs to a mercantilist (managed trade) China and b) stolen the rest of our wealth (and is in the process of gambling what's left of it away). Finally, given the ongoing instability of our economic system, we don't have long before the entire thing fails and with it our collective future (rich or poor). The question really is: why aren't you protesting? why isn't everyone protesting?
This chart (below) shows why the Tea Party is different than the Occupy movement
There's no question that the Occupy groups have done a great job with constructing the outlines of resilient communities in the heart of many of our most dense urban areas.
People pitch in to do work. They are considerate despite the difficulty of the arrangement. Food gets served. The area gets cleaned. There is entertainment. There's innovation (equipment, tech, workarounds). There is education (lots of seminars being taught). There is open, participatory governance. All of this is great and this experience will definitely pay off over the next decade as the global economy deteriorates, panics, fails. It will make building resilient communities easier (there are lots of ways to build a resilient community, we're trying to document all of the ways how on MiiU).
However, is this experience building a tribal identity? An Occupy tribe? Something that can eventually (there's lots to do in the short to medium term) go beyond protest and build something new? One even strong enough to create new resilient economic and social networks that step into the breach as the current one fails?
Welcome to MiiU ("me:you")
The Resilient Community Wiki
A resilient community is a place that produces most of what it needs locally. It connects virtually for everything else. It's a vibrant local economy as well as a community that is immune to a) global depression, b) political instability, c) shortages, famines, etc., and d) most effects of natural disasters. In short, it's resilient.
MiiU is a collection of all the resources and places that make personal, family, and community resilience possible. Resilience isn't only about surviving global failures, it's about building a better life for you and everyone around you.
Originally posted by gimme_some_truth
reply to post by WiZKiD111
Oh, did you mean me posting in this thread that I wish you would continue this debate?
If you think I am this guys buddy, honestly you could not be further from the truth. First, I barely know the guy and second we typically disagree... 9 times out of ten. You just caught us on that one time.
I was speaking for me and me alone. So, don't think that I represent him in anyway.
What I said was my own opinion. I would like to see you continue the discussion. And it is an observation of mine that it comes across as you being unable to rebutt his statements, when you run away from the conversation.
Like I said, If you feel that his statements are "dis-informational" why allow him to say them? Why not prove him wrong?
I just like a good debate. But I do apologize if my words came across as an attack. Not my intention at all.
Honestly, they were said because I am rooting for you in this debate..... I want him to be wrong about OWS....But I don't think he is. And I do agree with his statements in this thread... Though, you can probably gather that from my previous posts. I just simply wish it were not so...
So for what that is worth, yes I would love for you to continue this conversation.edit on 4-11-2011 by gimme_some_truth because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by WiZKiD111
I haven't spoken to you or about you once.
Originally posted by projectvxn
reply to post by WiZKiD111
Apolitical, don't kid yourself.
Yes it is apolitical.
I think you've displayed enough ignorance of how the military works that you should be more cautious of arguing these points with me.
We do what the POTUS tells us to do.
Don't like it? Vote in your own people to congress and get your own guy in the White House.
Originally posted by gimme_some_truth
Originally posted by WiZKiD111
I haven't spoken to you or about you once.
Well, excuse me for attempting to apologize to you for thinking that I had maybe offended you....
You had said you were attacked and mine was the only post that I saw that could be construed as an attack on you...
Sorry for being a decent human being?
edit on 4-11-2011 by gimme_some_truth because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by projectvxn
These veterans only matter to you people because they're participating in OWS.
If they are actually serving the country or aren't part of OWS then you people would be screaming about them being baby killers, murderers and what ever other anti-service member garbage you all spew..You use the veteran status as a symbol trying to siphon off the legitimacy of it while simultaneously holding contempt for the very actions that made it possible for you OWS people to use them like pawns in your stupid little propaganda war.
You make me sick.
edit on 4-11-2011 by projectvxn because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by Kali74
That's quite unfair to say, you don't know any of us personally nor what tugs at our heart strings. That man is a human first but secondly he is a human that put his life on the line to further the corporate cause under the guise of patriotism.
Originally posted by Kali74
reply to post by gimme_some_truth
It's disrespectul that a man was beaten to the point he has a lacerated spleen. But sure, be outraged at the people raising awareness of it as opposed to the crime.