It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by GhostLancer
And, the little things we do, such as holding the door for someone or giving up a chair for the elderly/pregnant, smiling at someone and saying hello... can set into motion a chain events that might improve your current reality. I call it REALITY-SHAPING. Do good things, little, medium --huge, and it comes back to you in ways you will never know. Do bad things... and it comes back to you amplified as well.
Originally posted by Talltexxxan
Just had a wild thought. okay bear with me........ Some say that we are all from/part of the same creator, so that means we should think we are all one, one concousness anyways. So how bout this, all the possiblities of OUR lives are not happening in OTHER universes but happening to everyone else on earth right now, as we are all one. So the guy that grew up to be an astronaut is just one of the possiblities we hav as a colective conciousness, a girl that died in a car crash on her 3rd birthday is another possibilty, the guy that lost his job and family to drug abuse is another way our life could have gone. GET IT? all the possible cause/effect decision/outcome senarios are not splitting into other universes, they are all happening to someone else,which is you, just not the SELF that you see.
I need a nap after that one.
Originally posted by blivey
Very thought provoking thread. A great fictional novel based on this concept is "From the corner of his eye" by Dean Koontz. The eerie thing is, the cover of the book has a shadow standing in a heavily branched tree.
Originally posted by ufoinquirer
Guys you're making assumptions that free will exists to begin with.
You must prove that first.
: )
Originally posted by Talltexxxan
Just had a wild thought. okay bear with me........ Some say that we are all from/part of the same creator, so that means we should think we are all one, one concousness anyways. So how bout this, all the possiblities of OUR lives are not happening in OTHER universes but happening to everyone else on earth right now, as we are all one. So the guy that grew up to be an astronaut is just one of the possiblities we hav as a colective conciousness, a girl that died in a car crash on her 3rd birthday is another possibilty, the guy that lost his job and family to drug abuse is another way our life could have gone. GET IT? all the possible cause/effect decision/outcome senarios are not splitting into other universes, they are all happening to someone else,which is you, just not the SELF that you see.
I need a nap after that one.
Originally posted by GhostLancer
Originally posted by ufoinquirer
Originally posted by hederahelix
reply to post by Bob Sholtz
you still make all the choices, its just that you would have always made the same choices.
I don't know about anyone else... but I'm forced to make my decisions/choices based solely on information available to me... be it truthful or be it total BS. When you withhold critical information from decision makers... innocent people get hurt... in ALL realities. Fact.edit on 31-5-2011 by hederahelix because: (no reason given)
yes free will is an illusion
even if you're given new info to help your decision, that info only gets to you via simple cause and effect. we're not different than animals or ping pong balls. we're just a lot more complicated. : )
Hmmmmm... VERY INTERESTING. I had little idea that so many people do not believe in free will. I didn't realize that there were so many "Determists" around. For those who may not have heard, and I was one until I heard, "Determinism" is the belief that there is no free will, and that though we may *think* we have a say in things, that in reality, we're just playing out a scripted chain of events. Like, if you were choosing between a red car and a blue car, no matter what you chose, it was meant to be and that is all. You only *thought* you were choosing, but it was "in the stars" that you would choose the blue car no matter what.
Quantum Theory and Multiple Universes states that you freely chose BOTH cars, but as a singular entity, you can only perceive existence based on what choice you made in ONE universe, regardless if both choices played out and became two different realities. I don't have the link, but I do remember that last year or earlier this year, scientists actually suspended a particle in what is called a SUPERPOSITION (i.e. the particle was in both states AT THE SAME TIME). It was a valid experiment and scientifically proven; they had a particle in two states simultaneously. I believe in free will. Here's one reason why...
Someone mentioned the 2-slit experiment. Nutshell: photos are shot, singularly, from a photon-emitter at one end of a box. On the opposite end of the box is a sensor pad that records where on the pad the photon struck. In-between the photon emitter and the sensor pad is a wall. The wall has two slits in it. The photon must pass through either the left or right slit to get to the photon sensor. We know which slit it went through by which side of the photon sensor the photon strikes. Easy enough, right?
In that experiment, the "Universe" (or Entropy or Chance or whatever you want to call it) "chooses" a slit. It could be random or not, but for whatever reason, the photon must go through one or the other slit; there is no in-between (at least, not yet). So, after emitting scores or hundreds of photons, there is a pattern on the sensor pad, and as you would imagine, it's about 50/50 left/right. Things changed when the scientists decided to go have a cheeseburger (or whatever) and run the experiment again when no one was around to witness it. What they saw when they returned was baffling.
Instead of the proven "typical" pattern on the sensor pad, they saw a confused pattern filled with interference, nothing like when they were observing the experiment unfolding. Confused, they ran it again and got the "typical," expected result from the first time. What they learned was that when the experiment was observed (by the scientists, sentient, aware beings), the Universe had to CHOOSE a slit: left or right. But, when the experiment was unobserved, the Universe could choose BOTH slits since no SENTIENT OBSERVER was there to force it to **DECIDE** which slit to use. Think about that. It's very profound.
In essence, the 2-slit experiment says that THE MERE ACT OF OBSERVATION can affect the outcome, that there is something about an OBSERVER that forces the Universe to choose a slit without ambiguity. So, if our very presence forces the Universe Itself to choose an outcome (and not just cop-out and choose both outcomes), then we have a power that is very mighty indeed. It is because of this that I believe we have free will, for how can we be FORCE THE UNIVERSE INTO CHOOSING AN OUTCOME if we don't have the power of choice ourselves?
I also believe that ART (in all it's various forms) is what seperates us from simple chemical reactions. In art, we are as close to the Creator --or the act of creation-- as we can get, for we are CHOOSING methods to express ourselves, via paint, music, dance, acting, storytelling, fiction-writing, etc. Our imaginations are very powerful and when we *create* we employ that powerful ability of free will. Sure, you can say, well you were going to paint that Starry Night anyway. Well, I don't think so. I choose what colors to use, what brushes to use, what techniques, how much paint and where. I choose when to begin and when to stop. In art, I am the master of my universe.
I also believe that IF YOU BELIEVE YOU DON'T HAVE FREE WILL, then maybe you don't. --In the sense that our focus determines our reality. I have DECIDED I have free will, and thus it is so. If you don't believe in the power of free will and decision, then you simply probably won't ever have it. It's an easy path to take because there is no responsibility, no regret, no blame. And for some, that is the correct answer. Not for me and those of you who embrace free will and decision. Just my take.
"mixing"? hmmm:
Originally posted by isthisreallife
reply to post by GhostLancer
Well that makes a lot of sense. But could someone's own branches tangle with other branches from your own tree? So your tree becomes a twisted mess?
To me, that could create some problems if universes are mixing.
Originally posted by ufoinquirer
Here's why I find it hard to believe. The cat paradox makes sense, because as far as we know the radioactive process is random. So I think universes could be created for each random decision of nature - whatever there is to that.
But I don't believe in free will/choices. Your choice is based on events from before, that by the time of your choice are out of your control, so you only ever have one choice to make. The free will part is an illusion.
We know everything has a cause or a reason - as we learn more and more about the brain, we discover more and more that there is no free will or choice - there's just the decision you come to based on the thoughts you had prior to that (chemical reactions) which are based on biology and memories, on and on and on till you're that acorn again. In this sense, I actually think time may work forward and backward, but the causes just change their meaning. Let's say you drop a ball on teh ground. Is the ground throwin ghte ball back up to you, or forcing hte ball o come down? : )
So this theory works for truly random events or decisions, if they exist. But not otherwise.