It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Stormdancer777
APNewsBreak: Hawaii won't release Obama birth info
Jan 21, 10:05 PM EST
hosted.ap.org...edit on 093131p://bFriday2011 by Stormdancer777 because: (no reason given)
Hawaii's privacy laws have long barred the release of a certified birth certificate to anyone who doesn't have a tangible interest.
Originally posted by backinblack]
You'd think every US citizen would have a "tangible interest" in knowing if their president was infact eligible to hold that position
Originally posted by backinblack
You'd think every US citizen would have a "tangible interest" in knowing if their president was infact eligible to hold that position...
Or every soldier who has to fight under the "commander-in-chief of the United States Armed Forces. ..."
Originally posted by Arbitrageur
Two senior state officials and a senior elections clerk have commented on it, and their claims are contradictory.
"Our office does not have access to birth records," Takahashi said.
Former governor Lingle, who said he was born at Kapiolani and who directed Fukino to put that in the press release? Or Fukino who denies this and apparently refused to put Kapiolani in the press release?
Or Adams who says Kapiolani has no record of him being born there?
Dr Corsi said he hired some private investigators (PIs) in 2008 who reported that neither Queens nor Kapiolani had any record of Obama's birth, however I'm not sure how the PIs could find that out since I'm not sure the hospitals would tell them anything,
I don't think even Fukino has been entirely consistent with her own statements, like the way her later press release dropped the birth certificate claim that was in her earlier press release.
all birth certificates are vital records, but not all vital records are birth certificates,
“I, Dr. Chiyome Fukino, Director of the Hawai‛i State Department of Health, have seen the original vital
records maintained on file by the Hawai‘i State Department of Health verifying Barack Hussein Obama
was born in Hawai‘i and is a natural-born American citizen. I have nothing further to add to this statement
or my original statement issued in October 2008 over eight months ago.”
That is exactly why I have a really hard time even pretending many birthers are the least bit sincere. If that were the case, BEFORE the election would have been the time to call those things in to question. The fact that none of you cared about how eligible anyone was for president until AFTER Obama was elected is more telling than anything really.
First of all, I think he was born in Hawaii so I don't think that makes me a birther, but I would like to see Obama resolve the issue by doing what McCain did. The issue was raised before the election, and Alan Keyes filed lawsuits against both candidates (McCain AND Obama) because of what he felt were legitimate questions about the candidacy of both of them. McCain provided his long form birth certificate, Obama didn't, only the certification extract. And by the way, it's still before the 2012 election which the governor of Hawaii mentioned in the OP article:
Originally posted by Sinnthia
BEFORE the election would have been the time to call those things in to question.
I wonder if Abercrombie saw this:
Abercrombie told the Honolulu Star Advertiser he was searching within the Hawaii Department of Health to find definitive vital records that would prove Obama was born in Hawaii, because the continuing eligibility controversy could hurt the president's chances of re-election in 2012.
Now if Arizona is the only state to require the candidates to prove their eligibility, then we still may not see the birth certificate, but if Texas passes such a law, then Obama may have to do what McCain did and show some real records instead of computer generated extracts where we have to take the word of state officials who can't even keep their story straight, as we've had three different accounts from Lingle, Fukino, and Adams and they are in conflict. Adams I'm not sure about, but you'd at least think that Governor Lingle and Director Fukino could keep their story straight.
If Barack Obama wants to be on the ballot in Arizona in 2012, he had better cough up a long form US birth certificate –like the one that lawsuit after lawsuit has asked Obama to produce. ...
An article from KPHO.com, a Phoenix radio station, reports: “The Arizona House on Monday voted for a provision that would require President Barack Obama to show his birth certificate if he hopes to be on the state’s ballot when he runs for reelection.
Either we have some psychics in the thread, or it wasn't that hard to predict:
Originally posted by Stormdancer777
APNewsBreak: Hawaii won't release Obama birth info
Jan 21, 10:05 PM EST
hosted.ap.org...
I think that pretty much nailed it.
Originally posted by 46ACE
Abercrombie:"This birther thing is stupid!" I'll fix this..."
Democrats : " uh no please don't bother"..
abercrombie "Er ....uh...
uh....
crap..."
Maybe, the only thing that might change it is if some states pass laws which affect the standard of evidence required to get on the ballot for 2012. Arizona alone won't be enough, because Obama won't win that state anyway. And Okubo's offer to provide the birth certificate still stands for 2012, doesn't it?
Originally posted by Expat888
A grey alien riding nessie carrying the holy grail will appear before obamas birth certificate ever does...
Obamas birth certificate ( a real one ) has to be the most elusive item in the universe...
I haven't heard anyone from the state of Hawaii retract that offer, so I assume it's still valid for the 2012 campaign.
Okubo said, "If someone from Obama's campaign gave us permission in person and presented some kind of verification that he or she was Obama's designee, we could release the vital record."
Originally posted by Arbitrageur
First of all, I think he was born in Hawaii so I don't think that makes me a birther,
Alan Keyes filed lawsuits against both candidates (McCain AND Obama) because of what he felt were legitimate questions
Now if Arizona is the only state to require the candidates to prove their eligibility, then we still may not see the birth certificate, but if Texas passes such a law, then Obama may have to do what McCain did and show some real records instead of computer generated extracts
Originally posted by ipsedixit
The mere fact that this issue has played out in the way it has, tells me that there is something fishy about Obama's birth records.
Well it's funny you should say that, because another anti-birther accused me of being an idiot for questioning what was claimed by a state official as high ranking as the governor, and now I have another anti-birther telling me the opposite, that I should NOT take the word of Hawaii's governor because the governor doesn't have access to the records and may have gotten it wrong. Which is it? By the way I tend to lean toward agreeing with you on this issue, the governor MAY be wrong as you suggest but this is the kind of thing that reinforces why we shouldn't treat the statement of any one individual as godlike and infallible, since anyone, including Fukino, could make an error or "be mistaken". You were mistaken about this issue yourself as you may recall when you thought Fukino said it but she didn't. And I said I wasn't sure about Adams but you just ignored that and went on a rant about him, fine.
Originally posted by Southern Guardian
Which two states officials might you refering to again? Fukino and the Governor Lingle? How did they contradict each others statements again? Governor Lingle of Hawaii may have gotten information incorrect as she does not have direct access to the presidents information.
Originally posted by Arbitrageur
Two senior state officials and a senior elections clerk have commented on it, and their claims are contradictory.
Please tell me what makes you think I'm moving the goal post. Let me give you a clue: Read my signature, specifically the quote that I don't want to believe, I want to know. There's a difference.
Originally posted by Southern Guardian
Originally posted by Arbitrageur
First of all, I think he was born in Hawaii so I don't think that makes me a birther,
Oh so now you believe he was born in Hawaii ... I'd say you are merely moving the goal post.
Originally posted by ipsedixit
The mere fact that this issue has played out in the way it has, tells me that there is something fishy about Obama's birth records. There must be some irregularity that is irregular enough for Obama and supporters to want to conceal it. It's completely obvious that this must be the case. To pretend that this documentary issue is without some sort of questionable circumstance looks absurd and is absurd.
He may well have been born in Hawaii, but it appears that he can't prove it conclusively.
I'm really just looking for some confirmation, and governor Abercrombie got my hopes up it would be resolved, but now all he's done is really added more questions than answers.
Originally posted by Arbitrageur
Me too, the current governor does seem sincere and maybe he can straighten this whole mess out. That's apparently his intention and I hope he succeeds.
Originally posted by SilentKillah
I truly hope that they do produce something to satisfy most of those peoples' needs then. I believe that they will soon... but it will only quite some. This debate will never end for others, but I can only hope for the best.
Originally posted by Arbitrageur
Well it's funny you should say that, because another anti-birther accused me of being an idiot
You were mistaken about this issue yourself as you may recall when you thought Fukino said it but she didn't.
Originally posted by Arbitrageur
Please tell me what makes you think I'm moving the goal post.
Right now I can only believe because I have to take the word of state officials
even members of the Obama family have said contradictory things about where Obama was born.
I haven't seen enough evidence to make me believe
since all Fukino would confirm is what's on the short form which doesn't say anything about Kapiolani, and in fact her press release directly contradicted the governor's statement
he can straighten this whole mess out.
Originally posted by backinblack
reply to post by Southern Guardian
Since you seem obviously to be an Obama defender and know everything in regards to the Birther issues, can I ask you one question??
Why, knowing that it is there, do you think Obama refuses to show his LFBC and instead costs the tax payer money with all these challenges in court?
It simply doesn't make sense to me..
And please don't post the usual "because he doesn't have to"
There must be more reason than that seeing as how long this has gone on...
Originally posted by backinblack
Since you seem obviously to be an Obama defender
Why, knowing that it is there, do you think Obama refuses to show his LFBC
and instead costs the tax payer money with all these challenges in court?
It simply doesn't make sense to me
And please don't post the usual "because he doesn't have to"
There must be more reason than that seeing as how long this has gone on...
Fukino said the governor gave her no special instructions but the governor said she did, so they can't both be right:
Originally posted by Southern Guardian
No she didn't, it was the governor, and Fukino? She didn't deny the statement neither did she confirm it
Yes but I haven't seen the evidence Fukino has, and the evidence I have seen is contradictory, such as...
Do you want to know the truth? Neither you or I will ever know without a doubt the pasts of our presidents. We just take whats presented to us in the media, on the net, and we choose to run by what is presented. Even with a birth certificate, original or short form, we assume its authenticity despite our lack of knowledge over birth certificates and we choose to believe the evidence.
His sister said he was born at Queens. Then in another interview she said he was born at Kapiolani. And it wasn't just his sister. Governor Lingle said he was born at Kapiolani, but this UPI news article said he was born at Queens:
Which family member again? Care to reference here? Thanks.
Originally posted by backinblack
I guess we are all simple dumb sheep and ASSUME our officials actually check things like this..
It turns out they didn't...Though they were meant to vet any candidate..
So is it really my fault that our "payed" officials did not do their job properly??
Originally posted by Arbitrageur
First of all, I think he was born in Hawaii so I don't think that makes me a birther, but
I would like to see Obama resolve the issue by doing what McCain did.
The issue was raised before the election, and Alan Keyes filed lawsuits against both candidates (McCain AND Obama) because of what he felt were legitimate questions about the candidacy of both of them. McCain provided his long form birth certificate, Obama didn't, only the certification extract. And by the way, it's still before the 2012 election which the governor of Hawaii mentioned in the OP article:
I wonder if Abercrombie saw this:
Abercrombie told the Honolulu Star Advertiser he was searching within the Hawaii Department of Health to find definitive vital records that would prove Obama was born in Hawaii, because the continuing eligibility controversy could hurt the president's chances of re-election in 2012.
New Arizona Law Requires Proof of Citizenship for Presidential Race
Now if Arizona is the only state to require the candidates to prove their eligibility, then we still may not see the birth certificate, but if Texas passes such a law, then Obama may have to do what McCain did and show some real records instead of computer generated extracts where we have to take the word of state officials who can't even keep their story straight, as we've had three different accounts from Lingle, Fukino, and Adams and they are in conflict. Adams I'm not sure about, but you'd at least think that Governor Lingle and Director Fukino could keep their story straight.
If Barack Obama wants to be on the ballot in Arizona in 2012, he had better cough up a long form US birth certificate –like the one that lawsuit after lawsuit has asked Obama to produce. ...
An article from KPHO.com, a Phoenix radio station, reports: “The Arizona House on Monday voted for a provision that would require President Barack Obama to show his birth certificate if he hopes to be on the state’s ballot when he runs for reelection.