It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Faiol
Originally posted by dragonsmusic
Originally posted by Faiol
no
you are wrong
people watch sports because they can relate themselves to a certain person/team, therefore get enjoyment or not to see them win
thats all .... its not about sex, thats just stupid in my opinion
You are entitled to your opinion. Though calling my postulate stupid just makes it seem like you have no valid argument and/or are upset somehow by this idea within your hierarchy of how things work.
I agree with you that when someone says stupid, it means that, but in this case, I really think it was stupid, I mean, come on, to put a ball thought something means sex?
thats your perspective, if you see sex everywhere, good for you, but thats not the intention of the game
and I thought my argument was valid enough to allow me to say stupid ...
Originally posted by badgerprints
Went to an all female roller derby saturday night.
Lot's of fun.
Sexual connotations anyone?
Originally posted by dragonsmusic
I never said that I see sex everywhere, that is an assertion that you have made up and projected onto me. And without being vulgar I don't know what else to tell you about my premise. Yes , it's about putting it into the hole. Is that so hard to understand? Most sports involve putting it into the hole. Yes it's my perspective, but calling it stupid only makes you look that way.
Originally posted by DISRAELI
Instead of interpreting sport and war in terms of sex, it might be better to interpret sport and sex in terms of war.
Sport is obviously modelled on war because they both have a double component- attack and defence.
War is partly about attacking your enemy's home, and partly about preventing the enemy from attacking your own home.
Most sports have got the same two components. In soccer, attack the opposing goal and defend your own. In chess, attack the opponent's king and defend your own.
And the needs of the two tasks have got to be balanced against one another. You send your army across to France, the French encourage rebellion in Scotland. You're so desperate to score an equaliser that you crowd into the opposing team's penalty area, and they score themselves "on the break" ("Some people are on the pitch! They think it's all over! It is now!")
You can't say war is modelled on sex because sex doesn't really have this double component. War is really about possession- trying to take the possesions of others, trying to keep your own. Since sex is sometimes described as an act of "possession", it might be better to think of sex as an aspect of war rather then the other way round.
Originally posted by LordBucket
reply to post by dragonsmusic
I postulate that all sports, in some form or another, and humanity's adoration for sport itself, can be reduced to a symbolic or re-creation of the process of intercourse.
"Can be?" Sure. And if you look hard enough you can probably find satanic messages encoded in beethoven symphonies.
Consider your example of rugby/football. It ignores a great deal to allow you to come to only the conclusion you're looking for. You could just as easily say that driving on freeways to work is symbolically navigating the fallopian tubes.
I think Carlin's war analogy is more descriptive, and requires less elements to be conveniently ignored. For example, in rugby/football you have two teams of players working against each other. What does that have to do with sex? What is the ball? Sperm? How does that make sense when you're passing it around to various teammates before scoring? But if the ball is symbolically a sabotague device or bomb of some sort, it seems reasonable to suggest that symbolically a team of covert operatives are working together to plant it at an enemy facility, and and the device is simply given to whichever operative is in the best position to plant it. Or that it's recognized as contraband, and the operatives are known by the enemy, but need to be caught in the act. So if they know they'll be searched (tackled) they simply pass it to another operative to continue the mission while they're being detained.
How do you explain this kind of thing as being related to sex?
Originally posted by OzWeatherman
Huh?
I play and follow sports because I enjoy them.
Playing has many benefits, like getting fit and it also gives me a good social life. In no way would I attribute the sport I play, to sex (Australian rules football, not that you americans know what it is, lol).
Originally posted by grey580
reply to post by Death_Kron
Well there's a difference. getting your hair cut is not a spectator sport. with people howling in lust over how well their team or person performs.
Originally posted by saltheart foamfollower
reply to post by dragonsmusic
Like Freud said, sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.
Huge American Football fan. It is like chess, or war. It is a ballet of power and finesses.
By the way, if anyone wants a flag made of whatever, I found a new .psd that creates a flag with any flat picture. If you want me to create one like what is in my signature, just send me a u2u with the picture location.
The size should be 412 wide x 217 tall. Or approximately those dimensions. I can modify the picture if it is close to that dimension. The website here has the .psd and the instruction if you want the ability to do it yourself-www.nomadthepirate.com...
Originally posted by UmbraSumus
Any Rugby fans here ............ ???????
You may enjoy this .
Dead Cat Bounce - Rugby
I know your angry and i know your ashamed
I`m kinda feeling the same
But we can hide our love if we pretend its a game
And give it a secret name
Lets call it Rugby .....
Originally posted by Death_Kron
I have only read the OP but I'll chip in with my thoughts anyway:
My favourite sport is Boxing, I'd be very interested in how someone could represent a boxing bout as being symbolic of sexual intercourse
Obviously, someone could "argue" that beating someone into submission is similiar to scoring a sexual conquest but I'm also pretty sure that one could argue that any sport represents mans desire to succeed and beat competition.
What I'm trying to say is that a sport could be argued to represent a whole host of human emotions, I think it's a flawed idea that sports are simply symbolic representations of sexual intercourse.
What's with all the sex threads recently
Originally posted by davespanners
Originally posted by dragonsmusic
I never said that I see sex everywhere, that is an assertion that you have made up and projected onto me. And without being vulgar I don't know what else to tell you about my premise. Yes , it's about putting it into the hole. Is that so hard to understand? Most sports involve putting it into the hole. Yes it's my perspective, but calling it stupid only makes you look that way.
I think your reaching this conclusion by cherry picking sports that involve balls and goals and ignoring those that don't.
Heres a simplified list of all sports in the olympic games and if they involve balls and holes
Diving No
Swimming No
Water polo Yes
Canoe/kayak No
Cycling No
Gymnastics No
Volleyball A ball but no "hole"
Horse Riding No
Wrestling No
Archery No
Athletics No
Badminton (I'll give you this one for the use of the word "Shuttlecock")
BasketBall YES
Boxing No
Fencing No
Football YES
Handball YES
Judo No
Rowing No
Sailing No
Shooting No
TableTennis Ball but no goal
Tennis Ball but no goal
Weightlifting No
So I think we can say that most sports don't involve putting things in holes
edit on 20-9-2010 by davespanners because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by dbloch7986
This is not stupid. This is actually very childish or maybe OP is a nymphomaniac, or perhaps you have just never had sex.
If you are anxious, as you are, to draw connections between everything and sex, it usually indicates that you are sexually starved.
Anything from putting a DVD into a player to driving a car through a tunnel to tuning a radio to eating or exercising in any form can look sexual in the eyes of the beholder.
Your own inner perversions may make a lot of things seem sexual. Walking through a door is crossing a threshold (membrane). Do you imagine yourself copulating every time you walk through a door?
There is very little in common with popular sports and sex. I don't know about you but I would hate to have my balls hit with a stick or kicked during fornication.