It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Adevoc Satanae
You are probably right. Any soldier with even a small amount of humanity might not do it. Unfortunately we have a video of people doing exactly what you just said would not be done. I guess that means there are soldiers without even a little humanity because no matter how many times you tell yourself that soldiers would not fire on innocent children even if ordered to, we can watch them do it in the video in the OP over and over and over again.
Originally posted by Gun Totin Gerbil
How do you decide it is muslims bombing muslims , when for example you have agencies like the UK SAS that have dressed up as the indigenous population in nations like the Sudan and Kenya , and have planted explosives for the sole purpose of appearing to be one faction attacking another to create internal discord and cross and extra-faction disharmony ?
And probably Basra too.
[edit on 15-8-2010 by Gun Totin Gerbil]
Originally posted by SeekerofTruth101
You revelation could not have come at a worse time on this thread.
It destroyed the comfort and solace that our boys belief that they are 'making a difference' and protecting the civilians. Just one day and look at how much worth were their protection????!!!!
Step back and reflect on the roles please. US is not making a difference and it had only escalated the violence. I know it hurts, but truth hurts all the time.
The real difference will not be made be bullets, but by changing mindsets, don't you get it???
Originally posted by Adevoc Satanae
Originally posted by mydarkpassenger
He begins to describe the AK47 fire and RPG fire at 5:45 in the video
Uh huh. There are reports of RPG fire.
Coming from where? These men casually standing around with reporters in the middle of the street? I guess I need a little verification on that as he does not say what you claimed. He does not say there was an RPG with these men that were mowed down by the chopper anywhere in that video.
Originally posted by Sinter Klaas
The problem is that our western society in an empire. We are all part of that empire, doing our job to keep it up and running.
The US have spend more money in the army then any other nation. They provide the force to protect, expand and consolidate power.
The only thing we could do right, is leave the area
Originally posted by JohnJasper
Originally posted by Sinter Klaas
The problem is that our western society in an empire. We are all part of that empire, doing our job to keep it up and running.
The US have spend more money in the army then any other nation. They provide the force to protect, expand and consolidate power.
The only thing we could do right, is leave the area
You overlooked your own point. We cannot leave the area because our empire wants to be there!
Before we can do anything otherwise, we must have regime change in the USA and other aggressor nations.
Originally posted by duality90
Given that the SAS are an extremely professional force, I find it highly unlikely that any such activity by them would be reported or betrayed to the press.
The two British undercover "soldiers", who were driving a car loaded with weapons and ammunition, were subsequently "rescued" by British forces, in a major military assault on the building where they were being detained:
"British forces used up to 10 tanks " supported by helicopters " to smash through the walls of the jail and free the two British servicemen."
The incident, which resulted in numerous civilian and police casualties has caused political embarrassment.
Several media reports and eyewitness accounts suggested that the SAS operatives were disguised as Al Qaeda "terrorists" and were planning to set off the bombs in Basra's central square during a a major religious event.
Originally posted by Reign02
Being in Iraq or Afghanistan is VERY stressful!!! Imagine everywhere you go today that someone has planted a bomb somewhere or his hiding with an AK-47 or a RPG just waiting for you to walk by so they can kill you. That is a fraction of what we go through everyday. Not to mention all the stress from leaving loved ones behind.
Originally posted by Reign02
I am a Tsgt. in the United States Air Force. I am a tactical air command and control specialist, otherwise known as TACP. I have served in both Iraq and Afghanistan for many tours. I deploy out with Army units, Special Forces, Rangers, SEALS, etc etc etc. I have been in the s*%@ and have seen a lot of stuff go down. You people act like they are so peaceful. Well the truth is that every single insurgents that attacks US troops would be just as happy cutting your head off because you are not a child of Islam.
Originally posted by Reign02
Terrorism will never die and will never go away but we are making a dent, believe what you want to believe but we are making a difference in both of these countries.
Originally posted by Xtrozero
Originally posted by Adevoc Satanae
You are probably right. Any soldier with even a small amount of humanity might not do it. Unfortunately we have a video of people doing exactly what you just said would not be done. I guess that means there are soldiers without even a little humanity because no matter how many times you tell yourself that soldiers would not fire on innocent children even if ordered to, we can watch them do it in the video in the OP over and over and over again.
So are we into 20 plus pages because of one soldier? You were in a gang fight that left 9 dead, so should we write 20 plus pages on that too? If I post about Darfur we might get 10 posts to it and that is millions, you my friend just have your agenda that you have nurtured in a very bias way. We are basially out of that country now and it is still not very nice.
Here is July 17th
Leading Sahwa member by roadside bomb in Abu Ghraib
Five Sons of Iraq members by roadside bomb in Dora, south Baghdad
Two sons of Kurdish goldsmith by bomb attached to car, Al-Jameela, Tuz Khurmato
Child shot dead in Al-Maqdadiya
Former intelligence officer from Hammam al-Aleel shot dead in Al-Rifaie, west Mosul
Man from Talafar shot dead at house in Tal al-Rimman, west Mosul
Body of 17-year-old girl found shot dead in west Mosul
I just do not understand everyones point, or are you all still speachless over this one day too....BTW I can list a few 1000 more days if you like.
Originally posted by Xtrozero
Originally posted by SeekerofTruth101
You revelation could not have come at a worse time on this thread.
It destroyed the comfort and solace that our boys belief that they are 'making a difference' and protecting the civilians. Just one day and look at how much worth were their protection????!!!!
It is true that the miscalculations were horrendous. To remove someone like Saddam one would think the population would enjoy freedom, but they decided to kill each other and are still at it, but at a much reduce rate.
Saddam was the terror and iron fist that kept them at bay and so I do feel that country would have been better off with a brutal dictator then left on their own.
Step back and reflect on the roles please. US is not making a difference and it had only escalated the violence. I know it hurts, but truth hurts all the time.
It is also true that the "war" was like a weeklong and these long years have been as I said above. We are finally making a difference now, but there is decades of further suffering by their own hands before they can finally say they are safe and free.
The real difference will not be made be bullets, but by changing mindsets, don't you get it???
I agree, but as in both Iraq and Afghanistan that mindset will only come from children not even born yet that maybe one day will live a life and go to schools with moderation and tolerance as a part of their lives. As long as extremist and intolerant views are the focus of teaching nothing will change.
I do feel it was all not worth it even if 50 years from now we might say it was good.
[edit on 15-8-2010 by Xtrozero]
Originally posted by Xtrozero
It is true that the miscalculations were horrendous. To remove someone like Saddam one would think the population would enjoy freedom, but they decided to kill each other and are still at it, but at a much reduce rate.
Saddam was the terror and iron fist that kept them at bay and so I do feel that country would have been better off with a brutal dictator then left on their own.
During the first weeks of the occupation, a U.S. military commander had showed up in Baquba, the capital of Diyala province located roughly twenty-five miles northeast of Baghdad with a mixed Sunni-Shia population. He had asked to meet with all the tribal and religious leaders. On the appointed day the assembled leaders were perplexed when the commander instructed them to divide themselves, "Shia on one side of the room, Sunni on the other."...
...There have been no statistical surveys in recent years to determine the sectarian composition of Iraq. However,when the Coalition Provisional Authority, led by Paul Bremer, formed the first puppet Iraqi government, a precedent was set. The twenty-five seats in the Iraqi Governing Council (IGC), were assigned strictly along sectarian lines based on the assumption that 60 percent of the population is Shia, 20 percent Sunni, and 20 percent Kurds, who are mostly Sunni.
Originally posted by Section31
After sticking around for a few weeks, I began to see ATS as an online bashing forum for people who are anti-military and anti-American. I don't know where most of you come from, nor do I really care at this point.
When I see a soldier defending himself in the first page (and people bash him for defending his country), I see something very-very wrong with how these wars have been perceived.
I don't know where everyone got their information, but both wars were/are very necessary for national security reasons. Saddam was a military tyrant, and Osama killed 3,000+ people on 9/11/2001.
Somewhere over the past nine years, the media entered into a horrific propaganda campaign.
MSNBC, CBS, ABC, NBC, and CNN set out on a goal to distort the facts, and a crap load of people bought into their lies. Sure, President Bush majorly messed up selling the wars, and also did a horrible job on planning and strategy. However, that should not overshadow why we 'counter-attacked' those countries.
Do we belong in Afghanistan at this point? No. Obama reignited a war that should have been let go, and Bush warned everyone about going back. At this point in time, we have to deal with the here and now. Afghanistan is a very hard country to control, and it put the USSR into a devastating economic crises. It eventually caused the country to split; thus, the USSR is no longer in existence. Afghanistan has now turned into a civil war.
Did we belong in Afghanistan after 9/11/2001? Absolutely, 100% Yes. I don't care about what type of propaganda you all heard, but the facts are as light and blue as the day. We were attacked by extremists who were living, operating, and hiding in Afghanistan. Period.
When it comes to the war on Iraq... It does not matter if Bush lied to us or not. Saddam's role model was noted as being Joseph Starlin. Everything Saddam had done over the years was in reflection of his hero. If an Iraqi spoke out against their leader, Saddam would have them publicly hanged. He also use to test chemical weapons on his people. He was a viscous, scheming, and cold-blooded killer. Period.
I don't care about anyone's theories or counter-arguments on what I just said, and I am not going to respond to anyone who thinks otherwise.
I don't like how people are addressing the United States military in these forums, and I ask you all to give them your respect.