reply to post by SimonGray
I think I put this on the wrong thread so I'll repost it here:
I HOPE, BTW, that something is being done in the overhaul to make finding replies to one's posts quick and easy.
I still say
WWW.FREEREPUBLIC.COM...
does the best on the web in terms of
COMMENTS pages where all the posts to the user and from the user are listed.
One can also go to one's FR home page and quickly click to get a listing of all their posts on the forum--in my case, all 90,000 + of them.
The ease of use and the ease of accomplishing all the basic common needs and desires in posting and navigating on such a forum are by far easier on FR
than any other forum. Virtually all FREEPERS assert that persistently.
One can quickly go to the various subforums on FR and get a listing of all the currently active threads--actually if one clicks back far enough--all
the threads in those forums.
FR only has a limited number of forums as that suits it's scope and needs. However, I think the model is great.
It also has 340,000 members--considerably more than ATS . . . and 1.2-2 million unique visitors/month.
I just think that if they can handle that much traffic with such quickness & ease of navigation on a volunteer donation NO ad basis, ATS can do a lot
better. It consistently takes a lot fewer clicks to accomplish the basics on FR than on ATS.
I'm convinced ATS could learn some good things from that.
The clunkiness of navigating ATS is one of the reasons I don't spend more time here. I particularly HATE not being able to QUICKLY, GET A LISTING OF
ALL THE POSTS TO ME IN RESPONSE TO MY POSTS.
Also, in each post on FR, there's a link to the post being replied to via it's number. And, the number of the post of that reply will be listed when
that post is posted . . . a continuous link back to the beginning of whatever chain of replies within a thread accrues thereby.
Another great feature is the capacity to address a post to specific users who may be interested. . . . individuals interested in that thread and that
sequence of main discussion or 'side-bars'
And there are dozens of PING LISTS. I maintain a couple with 150+ members--one on WYRD stuff . . . interested parties ask to be on the ping lists or
off if they get too bothered. Their screenames/user names are put in the addressee slot for that post. Very handy.
CONGRATS ON FINALLY GETTING AROUND TO SUCH A MAJOR OVERHAUL.
GREATLY APPRECIATE PROGRESS.