'Long Live October 7' Theme of NYC Pro-Palestine Protest

a reply to: Justoneman

Ah. Welsh. That explains it. More or less a Caliphate, Wales....

a reply to: Justoneman

I think I’ve made it clear I can see the distinction between people who say abhorrent things like that and others who are merely critical of the war as a whole.

My whole response was based off of the OP’s following remark.

Let there be no doubt that those calling themselves "Pro-Palestine" are 100% 'Pro-Hamass'!

a reply to: TheMinstrel

I’ve seen interviews from Israel, and the polls done by internal organizations.

It’s not absolute as you said. Like anything, there’s a spectrum of beliefs and opinions.

a reply to: TheMinstrel

You just said that the Jewish people who were protesting the war were orthodox. Now you’re saying a lot of them who are just claiming to be Jewish.

But alas, I can still comment on other groups or people even if I don’t belong to said groups or ethnicities. We all do it regularly.

a reply to: CriticalStinker

No. The ones in the Payees (the long curly locks of hair), beards and traditional clothing are the Satmar. When YOU said you didn't mean them, you meant the college protestors, I realized you meant the impostors who are trying to make Jews feel as if they are not alone. Try harder.

a reply to: TheMinstrel

I imagine you speaking for all Jews would be like me speaking for all Americans.

And it’s just like Americans who say so and so isn’t a real American because they believe in _______.

a reply to: CriticalStinker

You are not replying in good faith, but instead using strawman arguments. I won't interact further.

a reply to: TheMinstrel

And you want to be the authority on a whole group of people while using double standards.

You want to be able to claim to speak for the whole group while saying no one else outside of said group can even hold an opinion on the matters.

originally posted by: TheMinstrel
a reply to: CarlLaFong

It just disappeared for no reason. I didn't delete it.

Check your pms to see if the mods explained what happened.