'Long Live October 7' Theme of NYC Pro-Palestine Protest

a reply to: CarlLaFong

Wasn’t there a thread recently regarding stars

Imagine being an grown adult and requiring the dopamine hit from stars or flags

Surely the content of the reply is all that matters , otherwise are we heading for a future where gravestones instead of saying

amazing father/mother/brother/sister loved by all

We will get

Amazing one post of there’s once got 1000likes on twitter and 15 stars on ATS

Looks like you have accrued many stars for your post , does that make your words now more meaningful?

And neither side looks good celebrating the murder of innocent lives , let’s hope this religious war ends as soon as possible or just let the idiot politicians fight to the death instead , leave the rest of us out of it

and but and then 😃


Hamas response rejects hostage-ceasefire deal offer presented by Biden — Israeli official

and then remember again .. 😬

Israel says Iran launched more than 300 drones and missiles, 99% of which were intercepted

originally posted by: kwaka
a reply to: CriticalStinker

I don’t see much up for debate on what happened that day

In a democracy that is your call. Others disagree. There where lots of threads here at the time, the whole topic looks like a sore spot on the ignorance front. As a US site, it fits with US policy.

HAMAS has taken responsibility for the attacks and even went so far as to officially declare war on Israel.

www.bbc.com...

Unless you have a link to a better source, I think I'm stuck believing the official facts that remain undisputed.

originally posted by: CriticalStinker
a reply to: CarlLaFong

I have no doubt some of them are pro Hamas. But I think it’s hyperbolic to say any critical opinion of Israel’s action is pro hamas.

That would be like saying everyone who is pro Israel is anti free speech because of the antisemitism bill.

Not everything can be spoken in absolutes, and I’d go further to say few things in politics or geopolitics can be.

This just feels like the constant “if you’re not with _____, you’re a Nazi”. You can replace Nazi with any of the buzzword du jour.

These protesters are saying what they are saying. Should we not believe them because of hurt feelz?

originally posted by: xuenchen
and but and then 😃


Hamas response rejects hostage-ceasefire deal offer presented by Biden — Israeli official

Maybe if Biden says "DON'T" again?

a reply to: network dude

Unless you have a link to a better source,

I am not into wasting my time on deleted threads here. Sounds like Tick Toc has a more balanced view being based in China and with some US politicians trying to ban it. Telegram also done well on the censorship front during covid. Sure there are other places if you look.

originally posted by: FlyersFan

originally posted by: CriticalStinker
I think it’s hyperbolic to say any critical opinion of Israel’s action is pro hamas.

Celebrating Oct 7 absolutely IS being pro-Hamas.

Yes it is, but OP said pro Palestinians protesters are 100% pro hamas

originally posted by: network dude

originally posted by: CriticalStinker
a reply to: CarlLaFong

I have no doubt some of them are pro Hamas. But I think it’s hyperbolic to say any critical opinion of Israel’s action is pro hamas.

That would be like saying everyone who is pro Israel is anti free speech because of the antisemitism bill.

Not everything can be spoken in absolutes, and I’d go further to say few things in politics or geopolitics can be.

This just feels like the constant “if you’re not with _____, you’re a Nazi”. You can replace Nazi with any of the buzzword du jour.

These protesters are saying what they are saying. Should we not believe them because of hurt feelz?

Some of them are disgusting and we should take them at face value for what they say.

But are the Jewish protesters pro hamas? Or are they being critical of a government they might be citizens of?

We’re anti Iraq protesters pro terrorist? Some of them probably were. But not all of them.

originally posted by: CriticalStinker

originally posted by: network dude

originally posted by: CriticalStinker
a reply to: CarlLaFong

I have no doubt some of them are pro Hamas. But I think it’s hyperbolic to say any critical opinion of Israel’s action is pro hamas.

That would be like saying everyone who is pro Israel is anti free speech because of the antisemitism bill.

Not everything can be spoken in absolutes, and I’d go further to say few things in politics or geopolitics can be.

This just feels like the constant “if you’re not with _____, you’re a Nazi”. You can replace Nazi with any of the buzzword du jour.

These protesters are saying what they are saying. Should we not believe them because of hurt feelz?

Some of them are disgusting and we should take them at face value for what they say.

But are the Jewish protesters pro hamas? Or are they being critical of a government they might be citizens of?

We’re anti Iraq protesters pro terrorist? Some of them probably were. But not all of them.

I suppose it depends on what they are saying. These folks are saying things that sound a whole lot like they support the attacks on Israel. If you find someone from Israel saying things like this, please link it. I'm just accepting these folks are pro HAMAS based on their words. If you feel differently, please explain.

a reply to: network dude

Anyone who supports the attacks on Israel are abhorrent.

originally posted by: kwaka
a reply to: network dude

Unless you have a link to a better source,

I am not into wasting my time on deleted threads here. Sounds like Tick Toc has a more balanced view being based in China and with some US politicians trying to ban it. Telegram also done well on the censorship front during covid. Sure there are other places if you look.

so because Tick Tock told you something different than what HAMAS has stated on record, you disregard observable facts? I'm afraid we don't need to talk about this anymore, as my views are vastly different than yours.

originally posted by: CriticalStinker
a reply to: network dude

Anyone who supports the attacks on Israel are abhorrent.

Yes, that was also my point.

a reply to: CarlLaFong

You can lose your job, go to jail, if you call a man in a dress "sir" o object to him getting naked with young girls at the local swim club.

But calling for the extermination of all Jews is somehow free speech.

a reply to: CriticalStinker

Anyone who supports the attacks on Israel are abhorrent.

I have seen enough to keep Israel on that suspect list for what exactly happened. Know I wont get anywhere with it on these boards. That's ok.

originally posted by: kwaka
Tick Toc has a more balanced view being based in China .

OMG .. do you realize how funny that is? Probably not.
Balanced view and communist China ... yeah right.

originally posted by: CriticalStinker
Yes it is, but OP said pro Palestinians protesters are 100% pro hamas

ANYONE chanting 'from the river to the sea' is pro Hamas.
That is the Hamas genocide-the-jews and destroy-Israel chant.
The useful idiots either don't know what the hell they are chanting,
or they know and are willfully joining in the death chant ... either
way it supports Hamas.

originally posted by: CriticalStinker
But are the Jewish protesters pro hamas?.

If they are out there chanting 'from the river to the sea' rhetoric,
and if they are calling for a ceasefire leaving Hamas in tact, they
absolutely are.

a reply to: CarlLaFong

Apologists for HAMAS and supporters of October 7th and those calling for more are no better than the terrorist scum that they support.

Scum.

There. I have exercised my right to free speech.

Anyone got a problem with that?

originally posted by: Oldcarpy2
a reply to: CarlLaFong

Apologists for HAMAS and supporters of October 7th and those calling for more are no better than the terrorist scum that they support.

Scum.

There. I have exercised my right to free speech.

Anyone got a problem with that?

You were most eloquent.
Have a star...and a