It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: anonentity
But the fact still remains the actual people that live in the Donbas speak Russian and wants to be Russian and voted to join the Federation.
originally posted by: Subaeruginosa
I mean sure, from what I’ve heard they have a robust welfare system. But I mean, it’s a country of over 140 million, with a gdp the same as Canada… no way they can in reality afford to be taking good care of all the people they have now, let alone the regions they’re trying to take by force in Ukraine.
I’m extremely skeptical that it’s all rainbows and lollipops living under Russian rule.
originally posted by: anonentity
a reply to: Xtrozero
But the fact still remains the actual people that live in the Donbas speak Russian and wants to be Russian and voted to join the Federation. The reasons are that the pensions get paid and the roads get tarmacked, they get subsidized heating and reasonable rents.The alternative is the western system where you have the alternative of the streets if you can't pay your rent, it is that simple, not some ideological faith in some stupid "Ism"If you can prove that the vote was rigged, anything else is BS Crimea was happy and thriving.
originally posted by: Xtrozero
originally posted by: anonentity
But the fact still remains the actual people that live in the Donbas speak Russian and wants to be Russian and voted to join the Federation.
It is not a fact because they didn't have any constitutional right to vote on it. So it is OK in your view that a chunk of a country can just leave and join another? It doesn't even make sense... Also, Russia didn't just try and take Donbas, they wanted the whole thing, but failed to do it. To be honest, if they just took Donbas and stopped there I would bet there would not still be a war today. Now that they wanted to take it all I guess they can just suck it when they come back to the oh we will just take Donbas now...
originally posted by: MisguidedAngel
If the Ukrainian Nationalists/nazis didn't overthrow the Ukrainian government in 2014 with the backing of THE US there would be no war right now either. There would have been no fighting in 2014-2021 either.
originally posted by: anonentity
In a democracy, the will of the people should be paramount not the rule of vested interests protecting their wealth. There is a good reason for this because it creates a free market system. Once it is taken over by a power source that just looks after itself the free market, and the wealth created from it disappears for all but those manipulating it. They haven't got to innovate or come up with the products for the times. It's too easy, look at China it just copied its way into the present.No real force is driving innovation. With necessity being the mother of invention. Thus you end up with a faked system that will eventually fail to deliver. Like it is doing now.
originally posted by: Freeborn
If The Kremlin hadn't funded and armed Russian Nationalist and extreme right-wing Militias throughout Luhansk and Donetsk pre-2014 onwards there wouldn't have been the fighting there either, which would mean there probably wouldn't be a war there now either.
originally posted by: MisguidedAngel
originally posted by: anonentity
a reply to: Xtrozero
But the fact still remains the actual people that live in the Donbas speak Russian and wants to be Russian and voted to join the Federation. The reasons are that the pensions get paid and the roads get tarmacked, they get subsidized heating and reasonable rents.The alternative is the western system where you have the alternative of the streets if you can't pay your rent, it is that simple, not some ideological faith in some stupid "Ism"If you can prove that the vote was rigged, anything else is BS Crimea was happy and thriving.
The Donbass and Crimea have been very happy under Russia, the Ukrainian supporters can't even argue that because they know its true. Mariupol wanted Ukrainian for es out of their city for years as well.
originally posted by: yuppa
Happiness under FSB surveillance is not real happiness. If you are unhappy you tend to dissapear.