It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: BlueAjah
a reply to: Willtell
By that reasoning, we should never put Americans in jail when they break the law if they happen to have children.
There are many children in the US Foster care system because their parents are in prison.
About 5.1 million children in the US have an incarcerated parent.
www.aecf.org...
When parents break the law, children suffer. That's a fact.
But illegal immigration is... illegal.
The head of the Department of Homeland Security bashed the media Sunday for their reporting on the increasingly volatile immigration controversy, writing in a string of tweets: “We do not have a policy of separating families at the border. Period.”
Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen added: “This misreporting by Members, press & advocacy groups must stop. It is irresponsible and unproductive. As I have said many times before, if you are seeking asylum for your family, there is no reason to break the law and illegally cross between ports of entry.”
www.unhcr.org...
Introduction
Article 31 of the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees provides as follows:
1.The Contracting States shall not impose penalties, on account of their illegal entry or presence, on refugees who, coming directly from a territory where their life or freedom was threatened in the sense of Article 1, enter or are present in their territory without authorization, provided they present themselves without delay to the authorities and show good cause fort heir illegal entry or presence.
Congress could also fix the problem, says Lowry. It could change the rules so the Flores consent decree will no longer apply and it can appropriate more money for family shelters at the border.
This is what the Trump administration has called for, but Congress doesn’t seem interested. From the Democrats’ perspective, I suppose it’s better to keep the family separation issue alive. It’s win-win for the Dems. Either illegal immigrants get to take advantage of the seeking asylum loophole or the Dems get to rip the president for being “inhumane.”
The Trump Admin in following the law is choosing to ignore the bad optics which creates the conditions.
Has anything even gone to committee? Democrats don't have much say in getting anything to the floor, or keeping it off. Do they?
Ask yourself why the Democrats don't come out supporting the administration which has called for a fix to this.
originally posted by: Phage
a reply to: Alien Abduct
Yes.
Are their children institutionalized?
Are their families permitted to visit them? To communicate with them?
originally posted by: RowanBean
originally posted by: Xenogears
originally posted by: RowanBean
a reply to: Xenogears
Are you aware that drug cartels force people to become their mules? By your logic the parents in the Middle East are irresponsible parents. Like when ISIS presence precedes them.
Look if ISIS invades your country, that's not your fault. But if ISIS is occupying your country and taking say every 5 year old girl to their camp, and you have a baby girl that's on you.
Yeah.
"Be responsible and don't have sex. Oh BTW you're not welcome here. I don't care if you have no where to go."
originally posted by: Beaux
originally posted by: BlueAjah
a reply to: Willtell
By that reasoning, we should never put Americans in jail when they break the law if they happen to have children.
There are many children in the US Foster care system because their parents are in prison.
About 5.1 million children in the US have an incarcerated parent.
www.aecf.org...
When parents break the law, children suffer. That's a fact.
But illegal immigration is... illegal.
Adults do not have their children removed for trespassing which is the same illegality as this.
They are not authorized by law to be on "our land" so they are charged by our law for it.
We are just not sure how to best remove them for it but taking their kids over 5 from them is not the way in any civilized society.
Equating it to felons is disingenuous and lazy logic.
originally posted by: Xenogears
originally posted by: RowanBean
originally posted by: Xenogears
originally posted by: RowanBean
a reply to: Xenogears
Are you aware that drug cartels force people to become their mules? By your logic the parents in the Middle East are irresponsible parents. Like when ISIS presence precedes them.
Look if ISIS invades your country, that's not your fault. But if ISIS is occupying your country and taking say every 5 year old girl to their camp, and you have a baby girl that's on you.
Yeah.
"Be responsible and don't have sex. Oh BTW you're not welcome here. I don't care if you have no where to go."
There are plenty of homeless. You know what happened to the woman who took one in and was brutally murdered? Oh yeah that's right she was brutally murdered.
You cannot have open borders and a welfare state, it is unsustainable, the world has finite resources, know your facts, understand reality. What you're trying to do in terms of the future of america, is no different from jumping off a rooftop, do not fight reality, reality cannot be denied no matter how much you call it a social construct.
originally posted by: RowanBean
originally posted by: Xenogears
originally posted by: RowanBean
originally posted by: Xenogears
originally posted by: RowanBean
a reply to: Xenogears
Are you aware that drug cartels force people to become their mules? By your logic the parents in the Middle East are irresponsible parents. Like when ISIS presence precedes them.
Look if ISIS invades your country, that's not your fault. But if ISIS is occupying your country and taking say every 5 year old girl to their camp, and you have a baby girl that's on you.
Yeah.
"Be responsible and don't have sex. Oh BTW you're not welcome here. I don't care if you have no where to go."
There are plenty of homeless. You know what happened to the woman who took one in and was brutally murdered? Oh yeah that's right she was brutally murdered.
You cannot have open borders and a welfare state, it is unsustainable, the world has finite resources, know your facts, understand reality. What you're trying to do in terms of the future of america, is no different from jumping off a rooftop, do not fight reality, reality cannot be denied no matter how much you call it a social construct.
Not sure what that have to do with children?