It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: thepixelpusher
a reply to: zetaReticulous
Obviously you hear his answers and he was a pilot during one of the incidents. So watch it and listen to the testimony.
originally posted by: zetaReticulous
originally posted by: thepixelpusher
a reply to: zetaReticulous
Obviously you hear his answers and he was a pilot during one of the incidents. So watch it and listen to the testimony.
Why are you speaking to me like I haven't already done so? I've watched all the videos, read the pilot reports. The guy whos testimony you pointed out was the pilot on the NIMITZ video, which is not the video thats being looked at by Mick West at Metabunk.
originally posted by: coursecatalog
a reply to: SacredLore
Starting with this gun camera video as evidence is like trying to prove Bigfoot exists with a blurry 8 mm film while you have Sasquatch himself playing cards in the back room.
originally posted by: SacredLore
a reply to: KansasGirl
But as you have said, both videos are not good enough to prove this beyond any shadow of a doubt. I am actually quite impressed by the debunking efforts.
Maybe they are testing the waters: How will the public react? Mass panic? Wallstreet crash? If they see these signs they would come up with a mundane explanation and that was it. But as things are going, we might see a bit more in a few months.
originally posted by: vlawde
originally posted by: SacredLore
a reply to: KansasGirl
But as you have said, both videos are not good enough to prove this beyond any shadow of a doubt. I am actually quite impressed by the debunking efforts.
Maybe they are testing the waters: How will the public react? Mass panic? Wallstreet crash? If they see these signs they would come up with a mundane explanation and that was it. But as things are going, we might see a bit more in a few months.
Whether a landed craft, occupants, or just something that is at least a clear photo or video of an unknown craft, something more definitive could freak people the f out. Could be why info is slow in controlled bits
originally posted by: cosmania
a reply to: Iridomyrmex
Great analysis, and I love your respectfully critical style.
Having used FLIR pods and seen the variation from pod to pod and how different manufacturers make better/worse pods, I can say that your assessment is spot on. The Gimbal video is odd. It could be a camera/pod related flare/imperfection. If the audio is correct, I would speculate that would lend more credence to it being an actual flying object, but if the aircrew was looking solely at the FLIR footage, it could be some sort of lens flare.
Regarding your statement "The rapid switching between zoom and b/w mode by the pilot could possibly indicate that he was having trouble with a fussy ATFLIR pod."
Our RIOs/WSOs were trained to use different modes in order to best identify targets. They would frequently switch between White Hot and Black Hot because often, one of those modes would make the target clearer. Also, depending on the target, zooming in/out could also help identify the target. The technique is mostly used when using the FLIR pod in air to ground engagements, since finding the right target visually is so critical. But the WSO in that video is a colleague of mine, and he's very good. I didn't always work with the best back-seaters, but I can attest that this person is smart, thorough and knows the most recent/best techniques being taught by the tactics schools.
The technique of switching back and forth in modes relies upon the school of thought that the footage is being recorded and can be reviewed by the Intel guys, frame by frame. So, the technique is to go from one mode, hold a few seconds, switch modes, hold a few seconds, zoom in, hold a few seconds, zoom out, hold a few seconds. If they were going to launch/bomb that target, the WSO would evaluate the best view from what he saw, and keep that mode through employment of the weapon. If you ever get a chance to see some bomb footage with FLIR pods, you'll see the crew ID the target, drop the weapon and guide it, usually in a zoomed in mode. At impact, you'll see them switch to a zoomed out mode, in order to capture the bomb damage assessment footage required to ensure the target is effectively neutralized.
My guess is that the WSO didn't have a clear image of the tic-tac and kept switching modes because he never could clearly see what the object was. If it was a clearly identified object, let's say a helicopter, he would have kept it in one mode longer.