It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Dr UAE
originally posted by: Woodcarver
By punishing more innocent people?
originally posted by: Dr UAE
a reply to: Woodcarver
i fully agree with him, that will make the terrorists think twice before killing innocent people, they should make an example of each and every family who breeds like rabbits and doesn't raise their kids in a proper way, those parents should teach their children how to love and serve the country that hosted them, they should tell their children right from the start that they should love the country that offered them a house, education, safety and jobs, that will make the terrorists think twice before killing innocent people.
and by the way i know a country that used to demolish houses because someone from those houses committed a crime with or without a evidence.
How far back would we need to look into your family history before we found a criminal?
the parents aren't innocent, they fully know their children, and if they cant raise children then they should not reproduce, and my family's history is irrelevant in this topic.
originally posted by: Woodcarver
Nothing can prevent crazy people from harming others. But it can probably be minimized by educating the people of the world beyond their stone age religions and their partisan politics. The problem with people like this terrorist is that they have bad ideas. You quelch bad ideas with better ideas and better opportunities.
originally posted by: RazorV66
originally posted by: Woodcarver
So, you propose to punish innocent people for the crimes of their families? Are you an innocent person? Do you have any criminals in your family? Should you be exiled too?
originally posted by: RazorV66
originally posted by: Woodcarver
So if we exile all of the relatives of the terrorist in question, will that prevent the next attack? Will it prevent all attacks? I would doubt it.
originally posted by: Freeborn
a reply to: Woodcarver
Why would you wish this on people who are not doing anything?
The thing is, its almost the unanimous consensus of everyone I've spoke to recently that this is exactly what we want to see the government propose to do.
We've simply had enough.
Yes we cry after every attack.
Yes we respect every minutes silence and express our outrage.
But who actually suggests something like a real and tangible solution or approach that may see an end to these horrific acts?
No-one!
We want our political and community leaders to stand up and shout out what millions of us are thinking and saying to each other right now.
And whether its politically correct or not the truth is the Muslim communities have NOT done enough to slay the wolf that is within its midst.
This man has hit every single nail on the head and needs commending.
If Muslims decide to stand up for what is right then I will be the first person to support them and offer them every bit of assistance possible, but they have to stand up for themselves and take action against the extremists and not to cow down to intimidation or succumb to indoctrinated belief in religious loyalty.
Every person suspected of having extremist sympathies should put on a plane and dumped in some ISIS infested area.
When the world whinges on about human rights etc they should be told to bugger off, this is OUR country governed by OUR rules and we the British people of all races and creeds will not allow these pieces of #e to remain in our midst any longer.
Maybe....maybe not.
But it would send a clear message that the civilized world will no longer tolerate innocent lives being slaughtered.
Other radical solutions will be needed for it to work.
What would your solution be?
What will stop the killing of innocent people?
this would need to be proven in a court of law before any action could be taken. If it is proven, then we have laws in place to deal with this.
originally posted by: PhyllidaDavenport
a reply to: Woodcarver
Nope I do not
You cannot in all honesty tell me that parents sisters brothers etc of these bombers didn't have a clue as to their siblings/sons intentions? Beliefs?
it is not all muslims duty to police other muslims right? You are still punishing people who have done nothing wrong. Remember after pearl harbor when japanese American citizens were put into internment camps? This is what you are calling for to happen again?
Perhaps just the threat of internment would prevent this kind of action? Perhaps it would make relatives Imams etc more vigilant.
ahh #!!! You are really using pearl harbor as an argument FOR the use of internment camps?!?!?!?!?
Seemed to work for the US when they did exactly that to the Japanese Americans during WW2. Harsh times call for harsh measures but I think as far as tolerance patience understanding etc go we've done more than enough now as Mr Khan says its down to the Muslim communities themselves to ask the hard questions
Sure, but you would still need to prove their involvement before taking action.
originally posted by: PhyllidaDavenport
a reply to: Woodcarver
We aren't talking of plain old criminals or killers we are talking terrorists from ONE specific group, a very close knit group, where the children quite often still live in the parents homes with their spouses and share everything. If one became radicalised you can bet everyone in that family knew. The difficulty with Muslims is their honour and their loyalty to their religion and family and the fear of being ostracised by others in that community
Incidentally, again I'll state if I knew my son was a serial killer or rapist I would immediately turn the little shi*t into the police no worries, clearly I have no honour
originally posted by: dfnj2015
a reply to: PhyllidaDavenport
Moderate Muslims never get a voice because it doesn't fit the Western war propaganda message.
well certainly any religious culture taken at face value is not worthy of being passed on to children, but if you advocate that islam doesn't make sense so it should be removed, then that necessarily includes judaism, christianity, and a slew of other outdated world views. Christians could always slink back to a literal interpretation of the old testament, and often do. Would you agree?
originally posted by: RazorV66
originally posted by: Woodcarver
Nothing can prevent crazy people from harming others. But it can probably be minimized by educating the people of the world beyond their stone age religions and their partisan politics. The problem with people like this terrorist is that they have bad ideas. You quelch bad ideas with better ideas and better opportunities.
originally posted by: RazorV66
originally posted by: Woodcarver
So, you propose to punish innocent people for the crimes of their families? Are you an innocent person? Do you have any criminals in your family? Should you be exiled too?
originally posted by: RazorV66
originally posted by: Woodcarver
So if we exile all of the relatives of the terrorist in question, will that prevent the next attack? Will it prevent all attacks? I would doubt it.
originally posted by: Freeborn
a reply to: Woodcarver
Why would you wish this on people who are not doing anything?
The thing is, its almost the unanimous consensus of everyone I've spoke to recently that this is exactly what we want to see the government propose to do.
We've simply had enough.
Yes we cry after every attack.
Yes we respect every minutes silence and express our outrage.
But who actually suggests something like a real and tangible solution or approach that may see an end to these horrific acts?
No-one!
We want our political and community leaders to stand up and shout out what millions of us are thinking and saying to each other right now.
And whether its politically correct or not the truth is the Muslim communities have NOT done enough to slay the wolf that is within its midst.
This man has hit every single nail on the head and needs commending.
If Muslims decide to stand up for what is right then I will be the first person to support them and offer them every bit of assistance possible, but they have to stand up for themselves and take action against the extremists and not to cow down to intimidation or succumb to indoctrinated belief in religious loyalty.
Every person suspected of having extremist sympathies should put on a plane and dumped in some ISIS infested area.
When the world whinges on about human rights etc they should be told to bugger off, this is OUR country governed by OUR rules and we the British people of all races and creeds will not allow these pieces of #e to remain in our midst any longer.
Maybe....maybe not.
But it would send a clear message that the civilized world will no longer tolerate innocent lives being slaughtered.
Other radical solutions will be needed for it to work.
What would your solution be?
What will stop the killing of innocent people?
What better idea or opportunities could this bomber have been given?
They don't want to be educated beyond their Stone Age religion.
Did you read in the article that the police were warned about this guy 5 different times? I am all for laying some blame on police and politicians before laying it on the guys family (unless they are proven to be radical terrorists as well).
originally posted by: PhyllidaDavenport
a reply to: Woodcarver
I wouldn't prove it I would leave that down to the Police
If I was wrong its on my head and my son would hate me but I'd be pretty damn sure I was right because I actually KNOW my son
i agree that some particular muslim cultures are more apt to be radicalised. I know this to be common knowledge, so i point a lot of blame towards the politicians for advocating a mass migration and mixing dissimilar and opposed cultures in such a haphazard way. I am an atheist so i see little significant difference between all abrahamic religions.
originally posted by: Dr UAE
a reply to: Woodcarver
first of all im a Muslim, and im only talking about those nationalities from Pakistan and Bangladesh, i know them very well, ive dealt with them, if they are raised well they will blend in and contribute, but if not they become a pack of wolves, hell i cant even go to their countries because of the crimes over there, so yes its the parents fault.
And if they are knowledgable or were involved, then they should be dealt with according to the law.
originally posted by: PhyllidaDavenport
a reply to: Woodcarver
I can't comment on Police or Military Intelligence's modus operandi. I cannot prove nor disprove that statement is true or false, we have always been drip fed information and told only what they believe we need to know. I have no clue how the Intelligence community work in these situations. I have read the father and brother were regularly tooing and froing from Libya so I'm just guessing that the Intelligence people thought he could lead them to more terrorists
As most of his family have now been arrested I'd say his family knew his intentions, maybe not specific to manchester but knew it would happen at some point
nothing i can prove, but I have some speculation i can share.
originally posted by: PhyllidaDavenport
a reply to: Woodcarver
Have you any theories on why this was allowed to happen? Nay encouraged to happen? Knowing full well the probably results?
...His post went completely viral with over 61k shares so I'm guessing a good number of Muslims will have seen it.
I wonder if he could now have made himself and his family targets?
One way to start introducing them to other ideas could be to force them to spread out into the surrounding countries, thereby forcing them to assimilate little by little, generation after generation. Eventually homogenizing all cultures into one easily manipulated worldview over a few hundred years.