It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Why would you wish this on people who are not doing anything?
i found the negative pretty easy just by reading his own words. I am an atheist so i think all the abrahamic religions are equally morally bereft. But he Is advocating that innocent relatives be punished by death or exile. Which is not the type of rhetoric that a civilised society would want supported. I'm sure he is angry and scared of the ramifications of these terrorists actions, but calling for punishment of people who are not involved in the crime is pretty extreme don't you think?
originally posted by: PhyllidaDavenport
a reply to: Woodcarver
The only msm it made it to was his own personal facebook page
"Eaten by pigs" is a common slur or curse in Islam I'm pretty certain this intelligent well spoken well educated man wasn't advocating punishment North Korea style
I see nothing extreme or irrational that I haven't seen in a zillion other posts on here and elsewhere, the only difference is that this is coming from an actual Muslim to his own community
We should also consider that anyone whether brown black white or blue who says they are standing up and speaking out against radical Islam should NOT be considered racist. It has zero to do with skin colour and EVERYTHING to do with a rotten medieval ideology and belief system that is in need of a 21st century overhaul.
Why is there always 1 that's never happy no matter what is said and happy to find the negative?
originally posted by: PhyllidaDavenport
a reply to: SirKonstantin
I understand the anger...I've felt it many times myself. My own daughter was attacked and raped years ago by a lovely group of misunderstood Pakistani teens in Bradford, so for years try as I might, I have disliked (not hated) mistrusted and generally wished ill upon them all. But I doubt very much I could carry out such punishment on an entire family. My son and I were talking about this last night, he's furious and angry (one of his friends and daughter were at the concert..no injuries alive and well) and he said the only solution is the genocide of every Muslim until the ideology is wiped out. I was severely shocked and a bit lost for words, however, he said there was no way he could or would do it. How many other people are thinking the same way? There are Muslims now who are pretty damn terrified of a backlash and of course the difficulty is that they are so identifiable as the refuse to wear even the most modest of Western clothing they stand out, unlike most Sikhs Hindus Chinese Vietnamese etc. In a way they have made themselves targets by specifically standing out and not blending and integrating.
Perhaps one overhaul would be NOT wearing your ex countrys' national dress, which by the way was designed for extremely hot weather not the temperatures of Britain! Even the most stupid thick idiotic racists can spot a Muslim a mile off due to their dress. Humans can't stand different its that simple....and this is coming from an ex goth who was regularly abused and picked on for being exactly that. By not accepting our culture and the benefits of living here and leaving their religion at home and in the Mosques they have made a rod for their own back, but trying to remove hundreds of years of indoctrination will be like flogging a dead horse
originally posted by: PhyllidaDavenport
a reply to: Woodcarver
Nope I do not
You cannot in all honesty tell me that parents sisters brothers etc of these bombers didn't have a clue as to their siblings/sons intentions? Beliefs?
Perhaps just the threat of internment would prevent this kind of action? Perhaps it would make relatives Imams etc more vigilant.
Seemed to work for the US when they did exactly that to the Japanese Americans during WW2. Harsh times call for harsh measures but I think as far as tolerance patience understanding etc go we've done more than enough now as Mr Khan says its down to the Muslim communities themselves to ask the hard questions
So if we exile all of the relatives of the terrorist in question, will that prevent the next attack? Will it prevent all attacks? I would doubt it.
originally posted by: Freeborn
a reply to: Woodcarver
Why would you wish this on people who are not doing anything?
The thing is, its almost the unanimous consensus of everyone I've spoke to recently that this is exactly what we want to see the government propose to do.
We've simply had enough.
Yes we cry after every attack.
Yes we respect every minutes silence and express our outrage.
But who actually suggests something like a real and tangible solution or approach that may see an end to these horrific acts?
No-one!
We want our political and community leaders to stand up and shout out what millions of us are thinking and saying to each other right now.
And whether its politically correct or not the truth is the Muslim communities have NOT done enough to slay the wolf that is within its midst.
This man has hit every single nail on the head and needs commending.
If Muslims decide to stand up for what is right then I will be the first person to support them and offer them every bit of assistance possible, but they have to stand up for themselves and take action against the extremists and not to cow down to intimidation or succumb to indoctrinated belief in religious loyalty.
Every person suspected of having extremist sympathies should put on a plane and dumped in some ISIS infested area.
When the world whinges on about human rights etc they should be told to bugger off, this is OUR country governed by OUR rules and we the British people of all races and creeds will not allow these pieces of #e to remain in our midst any longer.
This seems the most likely understanding that we should be discussing. There are undercurrents and motivations which we do not understand.
originally posted by: PhyllidaDavenport
a reply to: RazorV66
Good post I agree entirely....although I just can't see it happening
Somewhere deep in the undergrowth there is an agenda that we don't know about and probably never will.
The thing is, its almost the unanimous consensus of everyone I've spoke to recently that this is exactly what we want to see the government propose to do.
originally posted by: PhyllidaDavenport
a reply to: Woodcarver
It would sure as hell send a significant message
What do world leaders do now? Absolutely nothing of any substance except wring their hands and tiptoe around politically correct words and actions. The terrorists know this and laugh all the way to their next target
So if we exile all of the relatives of the terrorist in question, will that prevent the next attack? Will it prevent all attacks? I would doubt it.
originally posted by: Woodcarver
So if we exile all of the relatives of the terrorist in question, will that prevent the next attack? Will it prevent all attacks? I would doubt it.
originally posted by: Freeborn
a reply to: Woodcarver
Why would you wish this on people who are not doing anything?
The thing is, its almost the unanimous consensus of everyone I've spoke to recently that this is exactly what we want to see the government propose to do.
We've simply had enough.
Yes we cry after every attack.
Yes we respect every minutes silence and express our outrage.
But who actually suggests something like a real and tangible solution or approach that may see an end to these horrific acts?
No-one!
We want our political and community leaders to stand up and shout out what millions of us are thinking and saying to each other right now.
And whether its politically correct or not the truth is the Muslim communities have NOT done enough to slay the wolf that is within its midst.
This man has hit every single nail on the head and needs commending.
If Muslims decide to stand up for what is right then I will be the first person to support them and offer them every bit of assistance possible, but they have to stand up for themselves and take action against the extremists and not to cow down to intimidation or succumb to indoctrinated belief in religious loyalty.
Every person suspected of having extremist sympathies should put on a plane and dumped in some ISIS infested area.
When the world whinges on about human rights etc they should be told to bugger off, this is OUR country governed by OUR rules and we the British people of all races and creeds will not allow these pieces of #e to remain in our midst any longer.
By punishing more innocent people?
originally posted by: Dr UAE
a reply to: Woodcarver
i fully agree with him, that will make the terrorists think twice before killing innocent people, they should make an example of each and every family who breeds like rabbits and doesn't raise their kids in a proper way, those parents should teach their children how to love and serve the country that hosted them, they should tell their children right from the start that they should love the country that offered them a house, education, safety and jobs, that will make the terrorists think twice before killing innocent people.
and by the way i know a country that used to demolish houses because someone from those houses committed a crime with or without a evidence.