It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Xatnys
Earth Sister,
After reading this thread and good deal of your web page, I wanted to pop in and say hi as well as ask a few questions of you. Please take no offense by anything I post.
I wanted to start off by saying that your understandings, as personally revealed to you do come with an "air" of truth or at the very least, a confidence in your words.
I wanted to say that, as my heart truly does believe you are speaking from your inner self, and it's not a guise.
Don't mistake that for meaning that my brain or my logic structure(s) are in unison with my heart. They are much more skeptical. Again, take no offense to this.
1. How long, by your understanding, has this council been visiting the planet known as "Earth" in any manner? To what degree have they directly interacted with the general population of "Earth", and how much interaction was originally directed at just the governments of the population?
2. Is there a common or underlying belief system found amongst the various races that make up the council? What are some of the main points to the belief system(s) you are familiar with? Does that in any way relate to any of the various belief systems found here on "Earth"? I am far from a spiritual person by most common terms, but I will recognize how vital these belief systems are to the progress of cultures and entire civilizations. I state that so you know the motive of my interest.
3. It would seem to me that most of the time your apparent contact comes to you in a rather non-physical manner. That is to say that your consciousness is "taken" aboard alien ships and to visit alien lands. Is this due to any particular reason? I can understand the magnitude of logistics required for multiple biological entities to meet in a common, physical space. What I want to know is what are the other reasons for a lack of physical interaction?
4. Since you are advised by your contacts to never keep any uncontestable evidence of their existence, for protection from current government, how do you personally validate your experiences?
5. How can you truly be sure that your experiences are real? Furthermore, if you can truly be certain that they are really taking place, how can you be certain that what is being presented to you is, indeed the "truth". The "Truth" heh, I know that's really a loose term at best. But what I'm getting at is: How are you sure that these entities are not furthering an agenda which you are kept wholly unaware of? How are you certain the entities themselves are not a construct of a local (to "earth) government that is trying to steer civilization for their own reasons?
6. What do you feel is to come for the human civilization in the next 6-10 years? 50? 100? 1,000? No need to get too technical here, just general thoughts from your view.
7. If these contacts do in fact view current forms of government as adversarial towards their citizens, why do they allow it to continue? In my view of ultimate logic, it would seem that the alien race would choose to break all bonds upon the citizenry, and then provide them with a choice in the interests of free will and basic universal rights. Unless, of course, they wish for the citizens to first decide to break their own bonds, which is logical. But not practical when most citizens don't realize the bonds are there. Is it? I ponder this greatly in relation to your thoughts and experiences.
Thank you.
Originally posted by lendog
Hello All! It has been a while since I have been around, but I had to put my 2 cents in concerning Earthsister. As I read some of your responses accusing Earthsister of an agenda, I sit amazed. Although I have never met she or her husband, my wife and I have been in contact via e-mail and have found her to be most sincere, caring, concerned and informative. She has helped us to understand our own experiences and we have found truth in all that she has shared. It amazes me that people have a need to accuse her of an agenda on this board. I can assure you, she has never asked for anything and has always given of her time and energy freely. I suggest that those of you who can understand, listen to what she has to say. She has a wealth of experience and information...and she and her husband always give freely and without expectation. I can't say that about most people on this board. Thanks Earthsister!
Originally posted by EarthSister
Originally posted by Spiderj
I did not call her mentally unstable I question her mental stability.
None of us here knows this person, none of us here knows eachother, to take that person at their word is imo not the smartest thing to do.
Earthsister just like everyone else including myself is more than free to post their story but should I expect everything I say or write to be believed, if someone questions me and puts me to the test should I be allowed to scream personal attack and then make malicious statements towrad the poster, the simple answer is no.
If you followed the links I posted and read them you will see that I have been more than fair with earthsister in the past it is she who took it personally.
If I told the same exact story earthsister told, I would have to make sure I am open for debate and to prove my point, turning the attack on me is not debate.
In one of the links I asked her when she first started having experiences did she get herself checked out, a psychiatrist, a cat scan. her answer was no.
Honestly if I started having alien contacts on an astral or physical level the first thing I would do is attempt to rule out any medical, chemical or psychiatric problem I may be experiencing.
In my opinion someone unwilling to take this step is not doing their part to search for the truth.
You don't have to tell your doctor why you want the catscan done, he or she will do it if you ask and you're willing to pay or your insurance will cover it, a full check up also does not require the person to talk about their possible encounters either.
A psychiatrist may be different, but you could certainly go talk to one knowing that client confidnetiality will apply.
Is this not the reasonable thing to do?
To attack me invites me to defend, I will not accept anyones word at face value, and I would hope I'm not the only one.
SPiderj
Originally posted by EarthSister
Originally posted by TerraX
Umm, what was it again that I warned other contributors on this board off? Oh yeah, now I remember.If you go about claiming how everybody else is incorrect and how your own person is correct in every way, you're gonna bump into the next person (who sometimes does the same).Think I mentioned this in one of earliest posts, yeah...
TerraX
Tell me honestly, do you see any difference at all between those who are as completely sincere and as open with it to others as possible, and those who are completely fabricating their stories for a diabolical end? Or are we all the same to you?
Originally posted by skyblueff0
well, what is the space federation? Kinda sounds like star trek, but explain.....
LoL, hey if it does exist, sign me in, but what is it first
Originally posted by therichman_315746
The reason why extraterrestials aren't attacking Earth is because they know the Americans will use ICBM nukes or some other weapon from Area 51 to blow them to kingdom come.
I suppose yer flying yer Confederate flag too boy.
Ignorance Denied!
Originally posted by therichman_315746
I suppose yer flying yer Confederate flag too boy.
Ignorance Denied!
I'm canadian and i'm not some stupid confederate hick like u
Originally posted by Spiderj
In reference to Michaels post in which he made some rather interesting remarks toward me and my own beliefs in regards to some highly spirited postings between myself earthsister and others, let me ask the group. Is it okay with you folks if I go ahead and defend myself here?
Since ES already complained about me to a moderator, I'm just curious. Do you all mind if I go ahead and defend myself or am I the only one not allowed to make what you consider personal attacks. Or is it only okay for the followers of Earthsister to attack those who disagree with her.
Someone wanna get a moderator in here and let me know if it's okay for me to respond with my usual vigor.
But let me just say this to Michael. I do not have to be a doctor to want proof, that's just silly. I'm not a lawyer but I still expect others and myself to uphold the law. As for getting a catscan it's what normal, reasonable people do to rule out any dangerous condition whether mental or medical. To refuse to do it is not someone looking for real answers just personal truth and there is a big difference.
So don't start with me kid. Yeesh.
Spiderj
Originally posted by Spiderj
I've read alot of Earthsisters posts and imo she is either mentally unstable, a con-woman or a front for a more organized cult like The Family or Scientology (sorry dear).
She has no proof other than drawings she has made, she states opinion as fact and in the end just doesn't know the truth.
SpiderJ
Originally posted by Spiderj
I hope the other poster will correct me if I'm wrong, but I do not believe anything I said about you Earthsister could be construed as offensive or malicious. It's not like I didn't intend for you to read my posts and in my past dealings with you I have been as tolerant and kind as possible.
SPiderj
Originally posted by wyatt43
Thank you all for your posts.
The website is very interesting and i will continue reading more later.
As for you Spiderj, i think that you are ignorant, selfish and insulting. it seems thorughout all of your posts you seem to try and find every fault you can with Earthsisters opinions/experiences. It is to my experience that opinions/experiences/thories are all based on witness's, possible solutions and own pesonal experiences. For these things you do not need evidence because no one has anyhting to gain from them.
No one is saying that these thories are factual, earthsister said that they were factual to him/her.