It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Jahari
I challenge you to do the same in the black community.
Not just this incident. I don't know the details and neither do you. Neither one of us was there. Did somebody check them after the fact? Maybe. Oh and just be clear I'm not arguing in favor of BLM because like you said ALM. But what I've seen this last year on ATS is a lot of accepted bigotry and racism under the guise of discussion. I'm just trying to be the unbiased commentator on some of these many race related threads that pops up on a daily basis now. What I wouldn't do for a little doom and gloom poor like the good ol'days.
Let me ask you this. Do you have any racist in your family? If so are they still welcome at family functions?
What I have noticed is black people are more openly racist and white America too ashamed or scares to say anything. I find that a double standard that needs to be fixed if any tyoe of healthy dialog can be had. But then the argument can be justifiably be shifted towards why that's the case. Yes it's the actions of some old dead white guys that enslaved some old dead black people and that degree of hatred and violence towards them lasted up until say 45 years ago.
So as I'm sure you already know things aren't as simple as we like to pretend. We are a psychologically damaged country. Blacks see white people as the uncle that bought them toys and gifta but molested them and white people see black people as unwanted visitors in their country.
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
a reply to: Jahari
When cops kill innocent people then it does reflect on the American police force and the BLM are using the actions of police officers to bash cops! The BLM is using the actions of a few cops to force all cops to change their policies and their actions. When America bombs countries get's involved in a violent conflicts it also reflects on how the world views America and same goes for white people who were alive at those times.
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: Jahari
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
a reply to: Jahari
I do hope you address my question about if you feel the same way about the KKK and if the things their members did/said should be used against their movement (and just to make this clear I'm not comparing BLM to the KKK).
Their movement is a movement of hate so I don't need a member to say or do anything for me to dislike their movement. It's built on a history of widespread murder and violence not just a few bad apples.
BLM has plenty of hatred in their movement when it comes to white people, cops, America, Republicans/blue dog Democrats, and anyone who doesn't do what they want/say.
originally posted by: Jahari
It definitely does but you are doing exactly that. Your using the actions of a few AA college students to condemn what their movement stands for.
originally posted by: OccamsRazor04
originally posted by: Jahari
I challenge you to do the same in the black community.
We are talking about the BLM community. I did not say all blacks are racist, I said BLM was.
Not just this incident. I don't know the details and neither do you. Neither one of us was there. Did somebody check them after the fact? Maybe. Oh and just be clear I'm not arguing in favor of BLM because like you said ALM. But what I've seen this last year on ATS is a lot of accepted bigotry and racism under the guise of discussion. I'm just trying to be the unbiased commentator on some of these many race related threads that pops up on a daily basis now. What I wouldn't do for a little doom and gloom poor like the good ol'days.
Yes, we do. Not a peep from BLM about racist behavior of it's members, as I said feel free to show me.
Let me ask you this. Do you have any racist in your family? If so are they still welcome at family functions?
No, I don't. There is a whole half of my family I no longer have any contact with at all due to their behavior. No seeing them, no writing them, no email, no Facebook, they are dead to me. Nothing to do with racism, they simply did not treat my family as family should, they acted as strangers, so that is what they are to me now.
What I have noticed is black people are more openly racist and white America too ashamed or scares to say anything. I find that a double standard that needs to be fixed if any tyoe of healthy dialog can be had. But then the argument can be justifiably be shifted towards why that's the case. Yes it's the actions of some old dead white guys that enslaved some old dead black people and that degree of hatred and violence towards them lasted up until say 45 years ago.
Can't be justified. it's wrong.
So as I'm sure you already know things aren't as simple as we like to pretend. We are a psychologically damaged country. Blacks see white people as the uncle that bought them toys and gifta but molested them and white people see black people as unwanted visitors in their country.
Sorry, most white people do not see blacks that way. Many white people are disgusted by thug culture which is rampant in the black community, but they are equally disgusted by whites who embrace that culture.
originally posted by: Jahari
Both sides needs to take long look in the mirror and stop ignoring the things their own does right in front of their eyes. Thug culture is a black thing. It's a American thing. Poverty makes it more rampant in the black community.
originally posted by: Jahari
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
a reply to: Jahari
When cops kill innocent people then it does reflect on the American police force and the BLM are using the actions of police officers to bash cops! The BLM is using the actions of a few cops to force all cops to change their policies and their actions. When America bombs countries get's involved in a violent conflicts it also reflects on how the world views America and same goes for white people who were alive at those times.
It definitely does but you are doing exactly that. Your using the actions of a few AA college students to condemn what their movement stands for. My views are a little different when it comes to making real change. Lets be honest nobody is going to listen to a group of all black people protesting. Not until it gets violent anyway, because tbh that's when frustrations, and your not so occasional thug wannabe, boil over and things escalate. Change will only be made when it's not only black people rioting and burning sh*t up but when white people start doing it with them. I know violence should only be a last resort. I feel all other avenues have been tried and failed. It's a bigger problem now then race. Put differences aside and focus on the real adversaries to you and yours. Never know it might bring us closer together as a nation to put foot to a$$ and take back what I fought 8 years for in the USMC. Freedom from all threats foreign and domestic.
originally posted by: OccamsRazor04
originally posted by: Jahari
Both sides needs to take long look in the mirror and stop ignoring the things their own does right in front of their eyes. Thug culture is a black thing. It's a American thing. Poverty makes it more rampant in the black community.
No, White people don't ignore it. I don't know anyone that is ok with the KKK. BLM is a black KKK. Extremely racist.
As I said, show me where BLM condemns these racist actions. are you saying Whites do not condemn the actions of the KKK?
Your comment on thug culture is exactly what I said, most whites despise that culture, including whites in that culture.
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: Jahari
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
a reply to: Jahari
When cops kill innocent people then it does reflect on the American police force and the BLM are using the actions of police officers to bash cops! The BLM is using the actions of a few cops to force all cops to change their policies and their actions. When America bombs countries get's involved in a violent conflicts it also reflects on how the world views America and same goes for white people who were alive at those times.
It definitely does but you are doing exactly that. Your using the actions of a few AA college students to condemn what their movement stands for. My views are a little different when it comes to making real change. Lets be honest nobody is going to listen to a group of all black people protesting. Not until it gets violent anyway, because tbh that's when frustrations, and your not so occasional thug wannabe, boil over and things escalate. Change will only be made when it's not only black people rioting and burning sh*t up but when white people start doing it with them. I know violence should only be a last resort. I feel all other avenues have been tried and failed. It's a bigger problem now then race. Put differences aside and focus on the real adversaries to you and yours. Never know it might bring us closer together as a nation to put foot to a$$ and take back what I fought 8 years for in the USMC. Freedom from all threats foreign and domestic.
No I'm looking at event after event after event and then condemning the group. Are you forgetting what went on in Ferguson and Baltimore? Would you of defended 2nd amendment groups if they did similar things to BLM like getting violent, destroying cities, chanted anti-government slogans, tried to disrupt areas where minorities hung out at, and started harassing certain people based on race/class all because many in the public wasn't taking them seriously? I can't believe you are justifying violence and trying to act like you don't support BLM.
Because we recognize those are really racist things, and the majority white community ostracizes the minority who think that way. When BLM does not label those people racists, when they do not ostracize them, when they invite them in with open arms, they then welcome those things and the people who do them.
originally posted by: NateTheAnimator
a reply to: nancyliedersdeaddog
Generalizing an entire group based on the actions of a few regardless of what the majority of the movement does in response is wrong.
originally posted by: NateTheAnimator
a reply to: OccamsRazor04
Because we recognize those are really racist things, and the majority white community ostracizes the minority who think that way. When BLM does not label those people racists, when they do not ostracize them, when they invite them in with open arms, they then welcome those things and the people who do them.
You have to realize historically that wasn't always the case. The dominant culture a little over 50-60 years ago would accept that very act that is now condemned by most Caucasians.
originally posted by: NateTheAnimator
a reply to: nancyliedersdeaddog
So is your entire argument against Jahari a guilt by association fallacy? Basically your logic is that any individual(s) of a group who commit reprehensible acts should therefore represent the entire group/organizations public image and based on these individuals the entire group should be discredited.
It's redundant what the name of the group is and what it represents, whether it's the Muslims,Jews,Christians,BLM and or the KKK. Generalizing an entire group based on the actions of a few regardless of what the majority of the movement does in response is wrong.
originally posted by: ManBehindTheMask
originally posted by: NateTheAnimator
a reply to: nancyliedersdeaddog
So is your entire argument against Jahari a guilt by association fallacy? Basically your logic is that any individual(s) of a group who commit reprehensible acts should therefore represent the entire group/organizations public image and based on these individuals the entire group should be discredited.
It's redundant what the name of the group is and what it represents, whether it's the Muslims,Jews,Christians,BLM and or the KKK. Generalizing an entire group based on the actions of a few regardless of what the majority of the movement does in response is wrong.
Except that this behavior has become the typical MO for this group, from invading restaurants, to blocking traffic, to running rough shod over campaign speeches and taking over to call everyone white racists, to mobilizing and shouting racists chants, to calling for the death of cops, to this present situation on campuses
Exactly WHERE is the redeeming quality in this movement thus far? Every demonstration so far has been laden thick w hateful rhetoric
Your rational is roughly equivalent to saying " The KKK isn't so bad because they occasionally have a food drive for the hungry"
Sorry most Americans are starting to see through the facade
originally posted by: nullafides
a reply to: b14warrior
I posted a few threads about #AllLivesMatter.
I said a few things regarding the fact that #BlackLivesMatter was exclusionary, and self victimizing.
This was largely met with derision and cries that I was a racist.
This is an example of what I saw....what I saw of the #BlackLivesMatter movement. It is also an example of the selfish, snowflake mentality of college students today.
Of their myopic vision. Vision that can ONLY be myopic because they are so young...and have NO REAL CLUE as to what life is truly like or about.
I am not in the slightest bit surprised at this article about the events at Dartmouth.