It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: abe froman
What are the odds that the "small minority" of violent protesters were the black people that were surrounded by white liberals marching with them?
originally posted by: abe froman
What are the odds that the "small minority" of violent protesters were the black people that were surrounded by white liberals marching with them?
originally posted by: Jahari
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: lucifershiningone
hmm..when members of a black movement do something..blame entire movement.
When a white person shoots up theater, church...blame the individual not the influence certain white groups have had or it becomes about how society has failed them...typical.
Did you not see how racist white groups are treated in the media after the Charleston shooting (even before that they are mocked and looked at as evil people)? Did you not see the rush to take down a flag, move some dead confederate bodies, change the names of streets, get rid of monuments after that event? Did you not see all the articles dealing with white racism and we need to fix it after the shooting mostly from other white people? This isn't a one time event either members of the black lives matter all over America have been showed doing some pretty messed up things.
Here is the mind set of many of members of Black Lives Matter/similar groups
look up Latausha Nedd
I'm pretty sure there have been 2 killings of cops by Black Lives Matter Supporters (or at least sympathizers) and then you have that Virginia mass shooter who talked about the Charleston shooting in his manifesto.
Warning they are NSFW and really disturbing
www.youtube.com...
www.youtube.com...
What's your point?
originally posted by: lucifershiningone
a reply to: nancyliedersdeaddog
Really?
Read the those threads concerning them, people talk about drugs, mental illness, society failing them.
They rarely blame a group for the one shooter, but say a black protester or few of them do something..they demonize the entire movement.
originally posted by: OccamsRazor04
originally posted by: lucifershiningone
a reply to: nancyliedersdeaddog
Really?
Read the those threads concerning them, people talk about drugs, mental illness, society failing them.
They rarely blame a group for the one shooter, but say a black protester or few of them do something..they demonize the entire movement.
I already responded to your logical fallacy, you steered clear of my response as it destroyed your argument. Here is my response again.
When a part of the BLM group does something and they keep those members part of the group the whole group is sanctioning it.
When a white person shoots a bunch of black people we lock them up and ostracize them, we do not support them and welcome them with open arms to march with us while we tell the black people they can't join in.
That's what you get when only Black lives matter, not all lives.
originally posted by: lucifershiningone
a reply to: nancyliedersdeaddog
Really?
Read the those threads concerning them, people talk about drugs, mental illness, society failing them.
They rarely blame a group for the one shooter, but say a black protester or few of them do something..they demonize the entire movement.
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: lucifershiningone
a reply to: nancyliedersdeaddog
Really?
Read the those threads concerning them, people talk about drugs, mental illness, society failing them.
They rarely blame a group for the one shooter, but say a black protester or few of them do something..they demonize the entire movement.
A lot of these US mass shooters aren't shooting up these places because some group is telling them to do it and they aren't killing in the name of religion/politics. when someone like the Virginia shooter claims he was inspired from other mass shooters it's brought up. What recent mass shootings are you talking about that were inspired by a group and people didn't talk about it? I'm guessing you are missing what was said about Roof, the Oklahoma bomber, and that Bundy Ranch couple who committed a mass shooting (all those events were used against the right wing and many also wrongly used events like the Gifford Shooting/Boston Bombing to claim the right wing inspired the event). People bring up drugs and mental illness when it does look to play a factor in why the person might of done it but no one takes blame away from the person who did it.
The story about a Black Lives matter supporter who killed a cop wasn't talked about all that much and only really picked up by right wing news sources and I'm also pretty sure that shooting of 2 cops done in NY because of what happened to Mike Brown wasn't really a giant news story for more than a few days.
www.nydailynews.com...
en.wikipedia.org...
Can you list 5 2015 mass shootings that were inspired by a group and their motivation wasn't talked about?
originally posted by: Jahari
Lol those are two totally different crimes. I see where your trying to go but your not doing a good job getting there.
Your implying if a black person shoots a bunch of white people that black people will keep them around and I say either your intentionally saying things you know to be untrue or you have the slightest idea what your talking about. I in no way want to disregard what your saying just try to compare like scenarios. Murder>Name calling!
originally posted by: Jahari
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: lucifershiningone
a reply to: nancyliedersdeaddog
Really?
Read the those threads concerning them, people talk about drugs, mental illness, society failing them.
They rarely blame a group for the one shooter, but say a black protester or few of them do something..they demonize the entire movement.
A lot of these US mass shooters aren't shooting up these places because some group is telling them to do it and they aren't killing in the name of religion/politics. when someone like the Virginia shooter claims he was inspired from other mass shooters it's brought up. What recent mass shootings are you talking about that were inspired by a group and people didn't talk about it? I'm guessing you are missing what was said about Roof, the Oklahoma bomber, and that Bundy Ranch couple who committed a mass shooting (all those events were used against the right wing and many also wrongly used events like the Gifford Shooting/Boston Bombing to claim the right wing inspired the event). People bring up drugs and mental illness when it does look to play a factor in why the person might of done it but no one takes blame away from the person who did it.
The story about a Black Lives matter supporter who killed a cop wasn't talked about all that much and only really picked up by right wing news sources and I'm also pretty sure that shooting of 2 cops done in NY because of what happened to Mike Brown wasn't really a giant news story for more than a few days.
www.nydailynews.com...
en.wikipedia.org...
Can you list 5 2015 mass shootings that were inspired by a group and their motivation wasn't talked about?
That's where the problem lies. People seem to be grouping themselves by race on these topics. Nevertheless your spot on most mass shootings, race motivated or not are actions thought of and carried out by one person. Those idiot's at the BLM protest were also actions of individuals not the group/movement.
originally posted by: OccamsRazor04
originally posted by: Jahari
Lol those are two totally different crimes. I see where your trying to go but your not doing a good job getting there.
It's the example a pro BLM person used in this very thread.
Your implying if a black person shoots a bunch of white people that black people will keep them around and I say either your intentionally saying things you know to be untrue or you have the slightest idea what your talking about. I in no way want to disregard what your saying just try to compare like scenarios. Murder>Name calling!
If a White person chases a black woman screaming run you ni**a b*tch, we don't then cheer him on and ask him to join us on our "all white march" ... which we don't have anyways.
Because we recognize those are really racist things, and the majority white community ostracizes the minority who think that way. When BLM does not label those people racists, when they do not ostracize them, when they invite them in with open arms, they then welcome those things and the people who do them.
BLM is racist. All Lives Matter.
We do not need "black only" marches and spaces.
MLK did not have a dream of white and black people marching separately. BLM is divisive.
If I am wrong then show me where the majority white culture accepted a white man chasing a black woman out of a library screaming obscenities at her. BLM accepts it, or you can show me where BLM labels the black people doing this as racist.
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: Jahari
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: lucifershiningone
a reply to: nancyliedersdeaddog
Really?
Read the those threads concerning them, people talk about drugs, mental illness, society failing them.
They rarely blame a group for the one shooter, but say a black protester or few of them do something..they demonize the entire movement.
A lot of these US mass shooters aren't shooting up these places because some group is telling them to do it and they aren't killing in the name of religion/politics. when someone like the Virginia shooter claims he was inspired from other mass shooters it's brought up. What recent mass shootings are you talking about that were inspired by a group and people didn't talk about it? I'm guessing you are missing what was said about Roof, the Oklahoma bomber, and that Bundy Ranch couple who committed a mass shooting (all those events were used against the right wing and many also wrongly used events like the Gifford Shooting/Boston Bombing to claim the right wing inspired the event). People bring up drugs and mental illness when it does look to play a factor in why the person might of done it but no one takes blame away from the person who did it.
The story about a Black Lives matter supporter who killed a cop wasn't talked about all that much and only really picked up by right wing news sources and I'm also pretty sure that shooting of 2 cops done in NY because of what happened to Mike Brown wasn't really a giant news story for more than a few days.
www.nydailynews.com...
en.wikipedia.org...
Can you list 5 2015 mass shootings that were inspired by a group and their motivation wasn't talked about?
That's where the problem lies. People seem to be grouping themselves by race on these topics. Nevertheless your spot on most mass shootings, race motivated or not are actions thought of and carried out by one person. Those idiot's at the BLM protest were also actions of individuals not the group/movement.
When a Christian bombs an abortion clinic because of his religious views then that needs to be talked about and the fact that his religious views motivated him to do it shouldn't be censored, the same is done with militia members, far left extremist, animal rights advocates, Muslims, Jews, racist, and Neo Nazi's. So the anti-police chants, killing people/cops for revenge, being racist, acts of violence, and property destruction by BLM shouldn't reflect on the movement? Do you disagree and defend the KKK when people used the actions/words of KKK members to attack the KKK (and no I'm not comparing the 2 groups or claiming they have the same history so far, I just want to know if you draw the line with them or look at their group the same way)?
originally posted by: Jahari
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: Jahari
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: lucifershiningone
a reply to: nancyliedersdeaddog
Really?
Read the those threads concerning them, people talk about drugs, mental illness, society failing them.
They rarely blame a group for the one shooter, but say a black protester or few of them do something..they demonize the entire movement.
A lot of these US mass shooters aren't shooting up these places because some group is telling them to do it and they aren't killing in the name of religion/politics. when someone like the Virginia shooter claims he was inspired from other mass shooters it's brought up. What recent mass shootings are you talking about that were inspired by a group and people didn't talk about it? I'm guessing you are missing what was said about Roof, the Oklahoma bomber, and that Bundy Ranch couple who committed a mass shooting (all those events were used against the right wing and many also wrongly used events like the Gifford Shooting/Boston Bombing to claim the right wing inspired the event). People bring up drugs and mental illness when it does look to play a factor in why the person might of done it but no one takes blame away from the person who did it.
The story about a Black Lives matter supporter who killed a cop wasn't talked about all that much and only really picked up by right wing news sources and I'm also pretty sure that shooting of 2 cops done in NY because of what happened to Mike Brown wasn't really a giant news story for more than a few days.
www.nydailynews.com...
en.wikipedia.org...
Can you list 5 2015 mass shootings that were inspired by a group and their motivation wasn't talked about?
That's where the problem lies. People seem to be grouping themselves by race on these topics. Nevertheless your spot on most mass shootings, race motivated or not are actions thought of and carried out by one person. Those idiot's at the BLM protest were also actions of individuals not the group/movement.
When a Christian bombs an abortion clinic because of his religious views then that needs to be talked about and the fact that his religious views motivated him to do it shouldn't be censored, the same is done with militia members, far left extremist, animal rights advocates, Muslims, Jews, racist, and Neo Nazi's. So the anti-police chants, killing people/cops for revenge, being racist, acts of violence, and property destruction by BLM shouldn't reflect on the movement? Do you disagree and defend the KKK when people used the actions/words of KKK members to attack the KKK (and no I'm not comparing the 2 groups or claiming they have the same history so far, I just want to know if you draw the line with them or look at their group the same way)?
If your not comparing the two I suggest you come up with another group to compare them to. Apples and oranges and all. But like I said before I'm not pro-BLM.
But how about when a Christian (black) nation say bomb a Muslim (white/establishment/cops) nation killing innocent civilians (majority of unracist white americans), do christians condemn those acts or do they try their best not to think about the innocence lost and just the bad guys they were after? Bad guys that have done terrible things to them(slavery, war on drugs, jim crow, civil rights etc). I'm not saying it's right but white america were the equivalent of ISIS to many blacks throughout history(public lynchings/police brutality). So I guess a large minority of the black community has a bombs away mentality at this point.
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
a reply to: Jahari
I do hope you address my question about if you feel the same way about the KKK and if the things their members did/said should be used against their movement (and just to make this clear I'm not comparing BLM to the KKK).
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: Jahari
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: Jahari
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
originally posted by: lucifershiningone
a reply to: nancyliedersdeaddog
Really?
Read the those threads concerning them, people talk about drugs, mental illness, society failing them.
They rarely blame a group for the one shooter, but say a black protester or few of them do something..they demonize the entire movement.
A lot of these US mass shooters aren't shooting up these places because some group is telling them to do it and they aren't killing in the name of religion/politics. when someone like the Virginia shooter claims he was inspired from other mass shooters it's brought up. What recent mass shootings are you talking about that were inspired by a group and people didn't talk about it? I'm guessing you are missing what was said about Roof, the Oklahoma bomber, and that Bundy Ranch couple who committed a mass shooting (all those events were used against the right wing and many also wrongly used events like the Gifford Shooting/Boston Bombing to claim the right wing inspired the event). People bring up drugs and mental illness when it does look to play a factor in why the person might of done it but no one takes blame away from the person who did it.
The story about a Black Lives matter supporter who killed a cop wasn't talked about all that much and only really picked up by right wing news sources and I'm also pretty sure that shooting of 2 cops done in NY because of what happened to Mike Brown wasn't really a giant news story for more than a few days.
www.nydailynews.com...
en.wikipedia.org...
Can you list 5 2015 mass shootings that were inspired by a group and their motivation wasn't talked about?
That's where the problem lies. People seem to be grouping themselves by race on these topics. Nevertheless your spot on most mass shootings, race motivated or not are actions thought of and carried out by one person. Those idiot's at the BLM protest were also actions of individuals not the group/movement.
When a Christian bombs an abortion clinic because of his religious views then that needs to be talked about and the fact that his religious views motivated him to do it shouldn't be censored, the same is done with militia members, far left extremist, animal rights advocates, Muslims, Jews, racist, and Neo Nazi's. So the anti-police chants, killing people/cops for revenge, being racist, acts of violence, and property destruction by BLM shouldn't reflect on the movement? Do you disagree and defend the KKK when people used the actions/words of KKK members to attack the KKK (and no I'm not comparing the 2 groups or claiming they have the same history so far, I just want to know if you draw the line with them or look at their group the same way)?
If your not comparing the two I suggest you come up with another group to compare them to. Apples and oranges and all. But like I said before I'm not pro-BLM.
But how about when a Christian (black) nation say bomb a Muslim (white/establishment/cops) nation killing innocent civilians (majority of unracist white americans), do christians condemn those acts or do they try their best not to think about the innocence lost and just the bad guys they were after? Bad guys that have done terrible things to them(slavery, war on drugs, jim crow, civil rights etc). I'm not saying it's right but white america were the equivalent of ISIS to many blacks throughout history(public lynchings/police brutality). So I guess a large minority of the black community has a bombs away mentality at this point.
I said twice I wasn't comparing the 2 groups and you didn't answer my question so I will ask it again Do you disagree and defend the KKK when people used the actions/words of KKK members to attack the KKK?
originally posted by: Jahari
originally posted by: nancyliedersdeaddog
a reply to: Jahari
I do hope you address my question about if you feel the same way about the KKK and if the things their members did/said should be used against their movement (and just to make this clear I'm not comparing BLM to the KKK).
Their movement is a movement of hate so I don't need a member to say or do anything for me to dislike their movement. It's built on a history of widespread murder and violence not just a few bad apples.