It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: EKron
originally posted by: JadeStar
So like, my parents tried to nurture me to be a boy but I always knew I was a girl. That would seem to nullify a nurture hypothesis, at least in my case, wouldn't it?
I completely agree. I was just trying to sus out Anaana's comments to see where she was coming from.
Like you, I am not of the belief that anyone or anything made me this way and that I'm not a product of my environment or social conditioning.
Although I was given much programming and encouragement to be and act like a boy, there's no doubt and I won't deny I had a lot of contradictory nurture as well so one on must ask, what came first, the chicken or the egg? Who I was inside, and still am BTW, didn't match up so well with the outside but I know my mother and grandmother at least sensed part of the inside me, maybe even on a subconscious level, or I would never have been able to do some of the things I did or was exposed to that most boys weren't. All the signals I got were never mixed and loudly clear - be and act like a boy but at the same time, more often than not I was treated and allowed to do things more to my true my inner self and nature.
Ultimately, as I did not grow up to be a man, my exposure or nurture if you will, to things traditionally reserved for girls worked out pretty well. Did it make me this way? No. It was the other way around. Whatever nurture I did get was because of my nature in spite of the outside package.
originally posted by: EKron
originally posted by: Darth_Prime
a reply to: TamaraAndBrian
Always and forever..
i only wish i had this much support my life
Brings a tear to the eye, don't it Darth? I know you've had rough times and been through hell that makes my little slice of misery in the past look like key lime pie. It is hard not to be a little envious when you see this great loving, communicating family that actually works. Makes you go wow!
Jade's wit, knowledge, attitude and wisdom in things that far exceed her years and the way she writes and thinks reached out and grabbed and impressed me right away without even adding any of the other stuff. Now after getting to see the magic of their family dynamic in action, you can where she gets it from because they're all kickass folks.
originally posted by: BuzzyWigs
a reply to: TamaraAndBrian
Thanks to both of you, Tamara and Brian.
JadeStar is a wonderful girl. I have told her that, too.
Well done, both of you!!!
originally posted by: babybunnies
Sorry, but at THREE, you don't have an original thought.
This is totally parent driven, not parent approved.
A study with 32 transgender children, ages 5 to 12, indicates that the gender identity of these children is deeply held and is not the result of confusion about gender identity or pretense. The study, led by psychological scientist Kristina Olson of the University of Washington, is one of the first to explore gender identity in transgender children using implicit measures that operate outside conscious awareness and are, therefore, less susceptible to modification than self-report measures.
originally posted by: BELIEVERpriest
a reply to: TamaraAndBrian
Hello,
I understand that you wanted to speak with me. I do have a question for you. As a devout Christian, how do you justify supporting you're son's pursuit self feminization?
originally posted by: JadeStarSo they wanted you to live some kind of "dual life"? That is a lot to ask of someone.
originally posted by: TamaraAndBrian
originally posted by: BELIEVERpriest
a reply to: TamaraAndBrian
Hello,
I understand that you wanted to speak with me. I do have a question for you. As a devout Christian, how do you justify supporting you're son's pursuit self feminization?
(Brian again, Jade's Dad)
I will for a moment assume that you are referring to Jade and not her older brother. First of all she is our daughter and always has been. It just took us some time to understand that. I am not sure how much of our story you read but as my wife said, even before Jade was born she exhibited more behaviors in common with my other daughters.
That did not stop when she was born. As I said, she always had a kind of quiet, gentleness about her and that has continued through adulthood.
As a devout Christian, the good book teaches us that judgement is reserved for God. My wife who is even more devout than I will certainly have something to say here but I would just refer you to the Serenity Prayer:
God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change,
The courage to change the things I can,
And the wisdom to know the difference.
We had the wisdom to know the difference. Jade as she will tell you was experiencing what she described to us as "a living hell" until we gained the wisdom from medical professionals and Jade herself, to know that the best course was to let Jade be who she naturally was.
Jade was always feminine, regardless of her anatomy at the time of birth. God delivered her to us that way for reasons we do not know but we are very proud that we were able to help her escape the living hell she felt and helped her become a happy young woman with a bright future ahead of her.
I highly doubt that if you met Jade you'd even think of referring to her as our son. She's our daughter and we love her.
originally posted by: EKron
originally posted by: JadeStarSo they wanted you to live some kind of "dual life"? That is a lot to ask of someone.
Oh no, it was perfectly clear what they wanted me to be and how I was expected to act and was hounded to be like a boys but on the other hand, was allowed to play with dolls and dress up and such when young. After I was 8, was allowed to grow out my hair and my parents threatened to sue the school when they were trying to make me cut it. I made quilts and stuff and even in high school, did needlepoint and embroidery and knew all the different stitches and had my own hoops. I still have them in fact as well as one of the dolls I had when I was 6 or 7 that I kept all these years. I loved to bake and cook and was Suzy homemaker and although there was more to it, the running joke I heard several times a week was "you're going to make somebody a good wife one of these days".
I guess if there was any "dual life" it wasn't because I wasn't a girl on the outside?
Yes, I was bombarded to be more like and be interested in more boy things and was pushed and encouraged in that direction constantly. My parents didn't want me to be teased or have a difficult life or maybe my behavior just embarrassed them,
I don't know but had I been rigidly not allowed to do some of the things I did or the way I was at home, life would not have been survivable. Like I said when I was a small child, concessions were made for my behavior. I don't know how that happened.
originally posted by: BELIEVERpriest
a reply to: TamaraAndBrian
Hello,
I understand that you wanted to speak with me. I do have a question for you. As a devout Christian, how do you justify supporting you're son's pursuit self feminization?
originally posted by: TamaraAndBrian
originally posted by: BELIEVERpriest
a reply to: TamaraAndBrian
Hello,
I understand that you wanted to speak with me. I do have a question for you. As a devout Christian, how do you justify supporting you're son's pursuit self feminization?
(This is Tamara again)
Oh no you didn't!
Look, as my husband told you. Jade our DAUGHTER has always been a girl. It just took us some time to accept that. We helped her be who she is today starting when she was 7 years old.
How do I justify that? I justify that by one simple thing: I would rather have 4 happy children than 3. Now you go on and think about that for a moment. Because really that is what I was faced with. Trying to force Jade to be something she at her very soul is not, was killing her.
Jade once drew this picture of our house with the faces of Brian and I, and Jade's 2 sisters and older brother in the windows.
Where was Jade you might ask?
She drew a cross in our yard.
So, how about you read Matthew 7:1 and really take it to heart.
Anyone have any other questions?
originally posted by: JadeStar
It sounds to me like what you said: your mom just was waiting for you to tell her. I find it hard to believe that she didn't know. Like my mom says "Moms know."
originally posted by: BELIEVERpriest
a reply to: TamaraAndBrian
Well, I'm willing to bet that a genetic test will prove that you have a son, but whatever.
If you read the same bible I read, then you would know that God doesn't make mistakes.
People are born male, female or eunuchs. Men are prohibited from acting and dressing feminine and women are prohibited from acting and dressing masculine.
Your right, its not my place to judge, so I will discontinue this conversation, but I don't get your logic.
originally posted by: EKron
originally posted by: JadeStar
It sounds to me like what you said: your mom just was waiting for you to tell her. I find it hard to believe that she didn't know. Like my mom says "Moms know."
In retrospect, I wish I would have been able to say "mom, I DO want to make somebody a good wife one of these days".
Yeah, I'm sure my mom knew. How could she not? Her lack of surprise when I came out to her and her saying she always knew who I was inside leaves little doubt. FWIW, I was a good wife for the 11 years I was married.
There's a certain age or level of maturity when the relationship and communication between parents and adult children changes, maybe it isn't even until your children have children and realize their parents weren't so stupid after all that this happens?
On this subject, I was never far enough away from it to talk about it with my mother who died when I was 25 like I could now if she was still around. Sure would have been nice to have some of the gaps in things I don't remember or understand filled in.
originally posted by: JadeStar
How do you think she would have responded?
Well there ya go! She'd probably have been proud of you
I don't know. I have friends who say their mom is like their best friend but that was not the dynamic with my mom. She made it very clear to all of us that she was our mother and while we could talk with her about anything we knew our roles as children.
You mean like the "IQ" tests?
In my case they didn't even try to hide the intent of the testing I was given. I was told vaguely that it was part of a study of kids like me.
originally posted by: EKron
originally posted by: JadeStar
How do you think she would have responded?
That's a good question. As I posted somewhere, she told me this funny haha joke/teasing was supposedly a hint I failed to pick up on and she was trying to open the door to talk about it. I wish now I had especially in my senior year of hs
But you know, after hearing all my life about how I needed to be more like other boys, I felt it would be such a huge disappointment to her if I spoke up. In 72-73, I'm not sure what could have been done about it anyway? Probably just more IQ testing.
Well there ya go! She'd probably have been proud of you
Yeah, she would have been. I'm sure of that. I know she was proud to see me with her granddaughter. Even my real dad, who I haven't talked about much and who wasn't too sure what to think about me met my husband a few times and got along with him really well
- they talked about cars.
I sensed he was kinda proud? I think he might have just have been happier to see me settled down and stable though? He wasn't a talker.
I don't know. I have friends who say their mom is like their best friend but that was not the dynamic with my mom. She made it very clear to all of us that she was our mother and while we could talk with her about anything we knew our roles as children.
I hear what you're saying. My daughter and I were very close and open but I was the parent and she understood that. We had our share of battles and not quite to the same degree, but somewhat also the same argumentative communication style I had with my mom.
I don't know when it was but I had the realization at some point I had grown up and become my mother. With my daughter in her forties now, she's talking about how she has realized she's grown up and turned into me.
We had quite a laugh about it. Other than liking hockey (I'm not a sports fan) and being a black belt in tae kwan do (she rocks!), we are so much alike in so many ways it's almost scary. She even looks like me (poor kid!)
You mean like the "IQ" tests?
In my case they didn't even try to hide the intent of the testing I was given. I was told vaguely that it was part of a study of kids like me.
originally posted by: JadeStar
I remember having one of those "argue-scussions" with my mom when I was like 15 or 16 I forget but I was getting ready to go to a Paramore concert with my bf and some friends and she didn't like how I was dressed, thought my skirt was too short (as if), didn't like my fishnets, didn't like the goth style stuff I wore in general back then, etc, etc. We must have had one of those argue type discussions for like an hour and we both made compromises (ie: i changed to just black tights and she let me wear the same skirt).
So I guess this is how I will be if and when I raise a daughter? We all become our mothers? I can kinda see where that could happen.