It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: windword
a reply to: Lazarus Short
Further, God describes Himself as a consuming/cleansing/refining fire. Further, Death and the Grave (not Hell) are to be thrown into the Lake of Fire, and how can anyone be dead and/or in Hell after that? It's absurd.
Threatening eternal torture as punishment for non-belief and finite crimes is absurd. I was answering the claim that Christianity doesn't promote it, but it does.
originally posted by: windword
a reply to: Lazarus Short
Further, God describes Himself as a consuming/cleansing/refining fire. Further, Death and the Grave (not Hell) are to be thrown into the Lake of Fire, and how can anyone be dead and/or in Hell after that? It's absurd.
Threatening eternal torture as punishment for non-belief and finite crimes is absurd. I was answering the claim that Christianity doesn't promote it, but it does.
originally posted by: yuppa
a reply to: Lazarus Short
duh i know we all have a limited time. what does that have to do with will? also apparently you dont believe in free will right? predetermination correct? Wow. so God pre determines someones going to be evil huh? If thats th e case why even punish someone when if that was how it works? thats Not very loving is it?
Remember God has killed many himself out of love and he was right to do so.
originally posted by: yuppa
a reply to: Lazarus Short
I have said to you but you dont seem to grasp this. i have said HELL does not exist UNTIL THE END. No eternal punishment(thanks catholic church for twisting it yet again) But its hard to reconcile somethings. God said he cant abide sin correct?
The LAke of fire does not exist as eternal punishment but a place of ending. Remember God has killed many himself out of love and he was right to do so. SO why would he not mete out punishment again out of love? Instead of torturing a soul forever he mercifully ends its exestence. ALso Doing so removed that persons influence on any one they knew.
In other words all their memories will be gone. Its one reason why there is a line in the bible about there being no more tears in heaven. Why would you be sad about someone who never existed?
BUT.. maybe you are right. MAybe its just a cleansing place. I am sure we will see one day who was correct.
originally posted by: Krazysh0t
a reply to: tiberius10721
......
This also makes sense in that religion is super vague and completely open to interpretation. There is literally no way to confirm that you have the correct religion or not. Following Christian doctrine that unbelief in Jesus results in hell, you could wind up in hell just because you were born in the wrong place on the planet. Meanwhile, with reincarnation you have all these chances to try different religions and faiths until you get the correct one.
originally posted by: Rex282
originally posted by: Krazysh0t
a reply to: tiberius10721
......
This also makes sense in that religion is super vague and completely open to interpretation. There is literally no way to confirm that you have the correct religion or not. Following Christian doctrine that unbelief in Jesus results in hell, you could wind up in hell just because you were born in the wrong place on the planet. Meanwhile, with reincarnation you have all these chances to try different religions and faiths until you get the correct one.
I understand where you are coming from however this is flawed thinking.Re-incarnation is not going to "right a wrong" or improve anything especially if all religion is wrong it is just digging a new deeper hole in and old hole that leads to nowhere.
If there is a creator God nothing mankind can think is the solution to a dilemma that doesn't even exist.The fact would be (and is) there is no such place as hell nor heaven so there is nothing anyone can do to "get" there.They are both false constructs of the religious carnal mind.The only thing you can do (and is required) is to live your life.There is zero things anyone can do to solve this conundrum of "why are we here".It will all come out in the wash .
originally posted by: Rex282
I understand where you are coming from however this is flawed thinking.Re-incarnation is not going to "right a wrong" or improve anything especially if all religion is wrong it is just digging a new deeper hole in an old hole that leads to nowhere.
If there is a creator God nothing mankind can think is the solution to a dilemma that doesn't even exist.The fact would be (and is) there is no such place as hell nor heaven so there is nothing anyone can do to "get" there.They are both false constructs of the religious carnal mind.The only thing you can do (and is required) is to live your life.There is zero things anyone can do to solve this conundrum of "why are we here".It will all come out in the wash .
originally posted by: Eunuchorn
..........
I think we can all agree that the world we live in pretty much revolves around religion.
originally posted by: Eunuchorn
So what if we are being reincarnated here over & over until we (as an individual) move past it. The Christians are so f# if that's the case.
originally posted by: Eunuchorn
Reincarnation isn't about "righting a wrong", it's about true acceptance of morality & treating others well despite outside forces.
originally posted by: Eunuchorn
I think the Gnostics were the closest to being right.
"...collection of ancient religions whose adherents shunned the material world - which they viewed as created by the demiurge - and embraced the spiritual world. Gnostic ideas influenced many ancient religions that teach that gnosis (variously interpreted as knowledge, enlightenment, salvation, emancipation or 'oneness with God') may be reached by practicing philanthropy to the point of personal poverty and diligently searching for wisdom by helping others.