It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: hoth12
Daas, I have had my disagreements with you but I have to commend you for this thread. I think that it's clear that those opposing you in this thread have fallen over themselves unable to find any actual FACTS that confirm the US created ISIS. They fall back on half-truths and innuendo and the old "even if they didn't create it I believe that they would have". My favorite is the single unverified blog post repeated by so many on ATS that supposedly the Snowden materials confirm Mossad created ISIS. Falls in line with the whole "the holocaust didn't really happen, but we should have had it anyway". Point being - when there are no facts, fall back to what effectively is an ad hominem attack. These people will believe anything that goes along with their narrative.
People claim that ISIS exists because the US made it so. People claim that ISIS was created in Syria, during its civil war. People claim that the USA and UK directly and knowingly funded extreme Islamic groups in Syria. People claim that there are no moderate rebels in Syria, and that the US has been funding ISIS all along. Well guess what? All of this is bull# of the highest order.
So why then, are we having to deal with this misinformation? Why am i having to sit hear at the dead of night, authoring this piece to inform others of the truth surrounding the Islamist group that is ISIS? I feel it is due to an ignorance around these groups, and towards the USA in general. I know this thread has not touched on all of the bases, as it would take multiple books to even achieve such a feat. That said, i do hope that this thread has spurred at least one person to go further and conduct their own research into the overall situation.
originally posted by: daaskapital
originally posted by: CallYourBluff
So they swore allegiance to Al Qaeda who are funded by the USA and we can't blame the USA for funding ISIS?
Do you have evidence?
originally posted by: Charlyboy
I would only add that to sustain high levels of government funding for an over reaching military industrial complex one needs to generate a constant supply of threats. No proof, only 30 years observing the bizarre behaviour of governments and military. Soon ISIS will have WMD's or something akin to that. Leave the middle east alone, stop sticking military into places whose culture despises you and watch how they leave us alone. Ask yourself who started this garbage..... Protect and care for your own citizens and stop worrying about people in distant lands. reminds me of the crusades...
Indeed, ISIS is an organisation opposed to everything the USA and its allies have been fighting for over the last 20 years.
originally posted by: daaskapital
Many argue that ISIS has been directly supported by the USA in Syria. This claim is untruthful, as the USA has intended to only fund moderate rebels, of whom are a separate entity to their Islamist counterparts. Indeed, the USA has trained and financially supported members of the FSA, and yes, it is true that many have defected to ISIS. But it is simply wrong to suggest that ISIS itself, has received any such treatment from the West. It is also incorrect to conclude that ISIS has somehow been supported by the US, simply because it now controls the Eastern region of Syria - an area recently controlled by both, the Syrian government and moderate opposition. The USA has only supported appropriately vetted rebels, and while some have defected to ISIS, it should be noted that jihadists are not considered appropriate contenders for support.
originally posted by: demus
originally posted by: Charlyboy
I would only add that to sustain high levels of government funding for an over reaching military industrial complex one needs to generate a constant supply of threats. No proof, only 30 years observing the bizarre behaviour of governments and military. Soon ISIS will have WMD's or something akin to that. Leave the middle east alone, stop sticking military into places whose culture despises you and watch how they leave us alone. Ask yourself who started this garbage..... Protect and care for your own citizens and stop worrying about people in distant lands. reminds me of the crusades...
crusades?
there are others who may hold the same or similar opinion...
like former US President:
originally posted by: Thurisaz
a reply to: daaskapital
I support what your trying to do however, there is no absolute truth regarding ISIS.
There is too much propaganda going on.
originally posted by: Gh0stwalker
a reply to: ArJunaBug
This is the greatest response I have ever read. Kudos, my friend.