It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by tanka418
reply to post by peacefulpete
Why is it that you Terrestrials continue to undervalue yourselves and over value ET?
I mean you liken yourselves to ants, and make ET some kind of god, and that is just simply wrong.
Extraterrestrials are not more "advanced" in any respect. Yeah, they might have a trick or two that you don't think that Terrestrials have, but, guess what!!!?!!
ET ain't got anything over you! PERIOD!!!
ET does not have advanced technology, at least not any more advanced than Earth already has. You all think that the ability to travel between stars is something special. its not. You have had that technology for at least 10 years
So, could y'all please stop putting yourselves down, belittling yourselves at every turn is not a healthy thing. And stop elevating ET to the status of a demi-god; he ain't nothin' but a hound dog! And seriously not worth all the BS you attribute to him.
YOU SERIOUSLY NEED TO WAKE UP TO THE FACT THAT YOU ARE ET's EQUAL!
In all respects.
Originally posted by Nephilimsreturn
I do not think they will invade us, for what reason would they want us, or this planet we have destroyed? Perhaps they will, as I sometimes think, they will simply rid this plant of us, in order to protect this planet which harbours other life (animals), from a virus like us.
Originally posted by peacefulpete
I don't really understand how you are saying that humans and ET's are equal.
You DON'T think their technology is much more advanced than ours? Please explain.
Also, OP is asking about weaponry I believe, and don't people think our weapons are primitive? Think of our handguns and revolvers firing physical metal bullets. Isn't this primitive weaponry? We are even replacing some guns with tasers (re: police) so even our own weapons have that new higher-tech weapon replacing old primitive guns. Our own weapons tech is always evolving and advancing.
So why would their weapons tech be the same as ours? Why would they not be much more advanced in all ways?
Serious questions and please explain because now I'm curious how you see it...
Originally posted by tanka418
Originally posted by peacefulpete
I don't really understand how you are saying that humans and ET's are equal.
You DON'T think their technology is much more advanced than ours? Please explain.
"Much more" advanced? NO! Absolutely not! A few tricks that let them do things you think is impossible Perhaps one or two.
Here is a "for instance" for you: Current "common" Terrestrial thinking is that Terrestrials have no "advanced space systems". That space propulsion is still currently being done with primitive rockets. You have a few "high tech" things on the "burner" but nothing seriously promising.
But, that is not reality.
Here is an article that is ore like your current reality: Field Drives.
Earth actually has a 10+ year old technology that allows for artificial gravity, field drives, and perhaps even a kind of primitive FTL. And that is right now in Aug. 2013! The "imaginary" space fleet is a reality (though no FTL yet.)
Also, OP is asking about weaponry I believe, and don't people think our weapons are primitive? Think of our handguns and revolvers firing physical metal bullets. Isn't this primitive weaponry? We are even replacing some guns with tasers (re: police) so even our own weapons have that new higher-tech weapon replacing old primitive guns. Our own weapons tech is always evolving and advancing.
So why would their weapons tech be the same as ours? Why would they not be much more advanced in all ways?
Serious questions and please explain because now I'm curious how you see it...
Actually you are replacing many weapons with rail guns and lasers. Both ageing technologies, that should have been on the "battlefield" 20 years ago.
Sure ET has better, weapons, but, not that much better. Their "directed energy" weapons (lasers) may compensate for atmosphere a bit faster, they ay be a bit higher power. That would actually be only a small advantage in combat. Terrestrials are highly intelligent and adapt very fast. Do you not think that yu can learn to handle a laser?
Earth other method of causing damage is to throw "high energy pellets" at something. Your basic "gun" . on a ore modern Earth this gun fires a 40mm projectile of very dense material at something like Mach 7...a rail gun.
Perhaps ET's "gun" fires 17eter asteroids at 50,000mph
My point is: ET does not need to be more advanced than Terrestrial Humans, and, that is a bit more in line with the reality of the near-by stars.
Using a Drake like equation it is shown that there could be around 10 advanced species visiting Earth, all from within 50 light years of Earth. At this distance "serious" FTL is necessary, a sort of "primitive" FTL can work.
Think of it this way: Really fast field drive, can get ya to nearly light speed in under a year. Through "frame dragging", Doppler, and a wee bit of luck, the effects of time dilation may be offset, making Alpha Centuari some 8 years away (for crew and people on Earth), Sirius perhaps a dozen years (12).
In all this; no need for weapons improvement, the old stuff, kept current works just fine..
Originally posted by peacefulpete
I just never thought anyone would imagine that an alien species (who could travel here) would also have human-like weapons and warfare strategies.
OK anything is possible but don't you think it's MUCH more likely that their weapons tech would be advanced just like their space travel tech?
Wouldn't it be much more likely that ALL their tech is advanced, overall?
Also, how much OLDER (than humans) are you imagining this alien species with star travel but with non-advanced weaponry?
The older their species, the more advanced tech in general, could be expected. Right?
Originally posted by tanka418
Originally posted by peacefulpete
I just never thought anyone would imagine that an alien species (who could travel here) would also have human-like weapons and warfare strategies.
OK anything is possible but don't you think it's MUCH more likely that their weapons tech would be advanced just like their space travel tech?
Wouldn't it be much more likely that ALL their tech is advanced, overall?
Also, how much OLDER (than humans) are you imagining this alien species with star travel but with non-advanced weaponry?
The older their species, the more advanced tech in general, could be expected. Right?
Weapons as advanced as their space travel? Sure, but their space travel isn't any more advanced than what Earth currently has.
Earth HAS field drives, and artificial gravity.
Earth HAS directed energy weapons of considerable energy
Earth HAS high velocity, high capacity rail guns; capable of launching small asteroids at incredible speeds (kinetic bombs).
And yes their Tech is more advanced than what Earth currently has. But, then again, Earth's current tech is vastly more advanced than it was just some 66 years ago, and yet remain fundamentally the SAME technologies.
How much more advanced than Earth is ET? Firstly it depends on which ET, but: We first need to understand that Earth and Terrestrial Humans have been help back at least twice, totaling nearly 2000 years, so your current state of technology has been altered (retarded) by outside influences.
The first time was about 200 years ago: Steam power was shelved by the Roan Empire; it would have eliminated the need for slaves, and their economy was based on slaves at the time. Good logic huh?
The second time was by the Catholic Church. Their fear was loosing power over the common man. At least Caesar had a real reason even IF it was pure BS.
So how advanced? the Sirians colonized the Earth some 6000 or so years ago, you were held back by those very Sirians via the Romans and later the Church so, that's about 4000 years. But, we have no idea about the technological progress and evolution in off-world societies, so it could be dramatically less.
The Grays and the Reptilians arrived near Earth only about 600 years ago; so they are not more advanced than Earth at all, and should be at about the same level (except for your "hold-back").
"The older the species, the ore advanced they are." Logic would seem to want to demand this be the case, and I think that on a level playing field that might tend to be the case. But, there are always influences, sometimes from within a society, sometimes from without, that modify the learning curve and a species response to it. Learning may be more difficult at some times, easier at others. And, of course, none of us can dictate the terms of learning and evolution.
Point is, most ETs currently visiting the Earth are from nearby, and not much older, nor advanced than Terrestrial Humans.
Originally posted by peacefulpete
You raise interesting points.
I still have to assume that any aliens who can travel the stars will also have advanced technology overall, in all aspects of their lives.
I think THAT is the most likely scenario.
Plus first-person accounts don't mention humanly weapons like revolvers lol. Accounts mention aliens causing memory loss, & causing mind-control, at will. I don't remember many accounts of aliens actually holding / firing weapons, but there are accounts of aliens disabling our missiles when they're supposed to be able to be fired.
I remember accounts of planes approaching UFO's and having their guns disabled when they got close.
This is how I tend to think of alien technology.
It sure seems much more advanced than some revolver 6-shooters lol.
Originally posted by Amagnon
reply to post by tanka418
I really struggle to comprehend you - our so called 'advanced' science has occurred over maybe the last 200 years.
There is every reason to believe that ET's arriving here may be MILLIONS of years more advanced than us in technology. Even if not millions, sheesh even 500 years more advanced than us is going to make our tech look pretty crap.