It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by AfterInfinity
reply to post by Korg Trinity
As a mortal, ignorant, finite being, you couldn't ever hope to understand what eternal youth would do to you. Clearly, you don't understand the full implications of watching everything you love die again and again. It is possible to become tired of living, you know.
How can an eternity of not existing be better than an eternity of life?
It is not childish or ignorant it is just the realization that any existence is better than no existence at all.
Originally posted by AfterInfinity
Not existing removes the possibility of pain and torment, something that very easily arises as a result of living through centuries of loss, fear, and despair.
Compared with what there is to see of existence and all the possibilities therein, you are an infant. You know nothing whereof you speak. I don't mean to sound rude, but you literally possess a tiny miniscule fraction of awareness regarding the possibilities of existence.
Some examples of existence would make anyone beg for death. That is a fact.
Originally posted by AfterInfinity
reply to post by Korg Trinity
As a mortal, ignorant, finite being, you couldn't ever hope to understand what eternal youth would do to you. Clearly, you don't understand the full implications of watching everything you love die again and again. It is possible to become tired of living, you know.
Originally posted by AfterInfinity
reply to post by justwokeup
I dont understand the negativity. If somebody offers me the ability to live to 500 i'll take it (unless its as a brain floating in a jar like Futurama).
I doubt any of this will come fast enough for me but if it did I would want to see what comes next. I want to be around when we crack the fusion problem. I want to be around to see the dawn of strong AI, the advent of colonisation of the solar system. The list is endless.
Religious people have nothing to fear, you will remain free to choose to die of old age while others live on. Nobody will stop you.
Easy. When life becomes as plentiful as water, people take it less seriously. Imagine what the world would be like if people started to take life for granted, even more than they do now. No one would care about someone's pain and suffering. Emotions would become like food, consumed and forgotten until the next course. Everything would fade away like so many books that have been read so many times you can practically feel it crumbling beneath your fingers, dying within your mind. Nothing lasts forever, but the closer we come, the more we want.
We're never satisfied. And if we attain immortality, we will only use it to immortalize our own vanity and cruelty.edit on 6-5-2013 by AfterInfinity because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by AfterInfinity
reply to post by Korg Trinity
So you are saying that life will always hold the same level of delight and fascination no matter what you see, feel, hear, or encounter over the course of your immortality? You believe that your perspective, the view you hold now, would not change over the course of a couple thousand years?
Of course your perception will change over time as you gain more knowledge and become wiser... but that shouldn't make you feel tired of life...
There should be a perception of development of oneself rather than a perception of decay.
Originally posted by AfterInfinity
reply to post by Korg Trinity
Of course your perception will change over time as you gain more knowledge and become wiser... but that shouldn't make you feel tired of life...
There should be a perception of development of oneself rather than a perception of decay.
Physics tells us that nothing lasts forever. There are several perfectly good reasons for this. Did you even bother to read the article I linked?
Originally posted by strato
IMO it's a greedy and selfish mindset. Why would you deserve to live that long? It's not ethical. When your 50 and your teeth fall out, your have tons of health problems and have to rely on meds, you should simply die and not waste any more resources. I personally don't want nor expect to live beyond 50.
Originally posted by AfterInfinity
reply to post by Korg Trinity
Yes, I would appreciate that.
#5. Evolution Will Turn You Into a Freak
Contrary to what many people believe, humans are still evolving. That's not a big deal if you have the kind of immortality that only lasts 1,000 or 2,000 years, but of course real immortality means you'll still be walking the earth, in your current body, a million years from now.
Science has no idea where future mutations might lead us by that point, so it's anyone's guess what your neighbors will look like in the future.
Their bodies and brains are going to continue to adapt to an ever-changing world. Yours won't. Will your digestive system be able to handle the same food they eat? Will your brain enjoy the same entertainment? Will your non-evolved tongue even be able to speak the languages they speak in the year one million AD? Would an unfrozen caveman be able to do all of that now?
#4. Nobody Can Ever Find Out
Let's say some kid goes rummaging around in your basement, finds that witch's old portrait of you and discovers that you are immortal. Word spreads and suddenly you're famous the world over. Sure, a lot of people might not buy the story at first, but folks have become famous for much less.
Sounds pretty sweet, right? Probably get a reality show out of it. But that's just scratching the surface. You're not just going to be famous; you're going to be a god. You have eternal life, which means you must know the secret to eternal life, which means you will immediately be the center of the world's newest and most popular religion. You'll be like a guy revealing himself to be Jesus, and proving it. Why would anyone continue to worship an invisible deity when they have a god walking around amongst them? Each morning your yard will be packed full of several thousand terminally ill people, or parents with their sick kids, asking you to grant them the same immortality you have.
#3. You're Still Getting Older (Mentally)
We're not saying that if you were to be magically granted immortality, you'd eventually get Alzheimer's anyway--we assume that the Elixir of Life you sipped will keep your brain physically young just like the rest of you. We're saying it won't matter.
Imagine if your cell phone number changed every week, and every week you were forced to memorize the new one. It gets exponentially harder because all of those old numbers are still in your memory, clogging up the works. Then imagine someone asked you to instantly recall the number you had five numbers ago.
That's one reason your memory degrades as you get older. Your brain and its ability to store and recall memories is limited, but the amount of stuff you're asking it to remember keeps piling up over the decades.
#2. Time Speeds Up Until You're Insane
How many of you out there are old enough to notice time speeding up? For those of you who aren't, can you remember when you were a kid and the school year finally ended and the summer was about to begin? It seemed like you'd been waiting half your life for it, while at the exact same time your mom was going, "Gah! Summer is here ALREADY?! " The fact is your perception of time speeds up with age. It's just math
So when you're 100 years-old, a minute will seem six seconds long compared to a minute when you were 10. If you live for 1,000 years, a 50-year marriage spent with a woman for her entire adult life, will have the same significance to you as the girl you dated for a few years back in college. If you live for 100,000 years, she'd basically be the nameless chick you made out with at a Weezer concert.
#1. You'll Eventually Get Trapped Somewhere (Forever)
We spend so much time being afraid of death that we forget the one, overwhelming benefit death offers every species: cutting short suffering. Obviously when we talk about immortality we're picturing always being young and healthy, not laying in a bed suffering from lung cancer forever and ever.
But it's a dangerous world out there, and any number of freak accidents could get you stuck somewhere, with no escape, for the rest of time.
Say an earthquake strikes the building that you're in, and it collapses while you're in the basement parking garage. You're pinned under a million tons of concrete and drywall. All you can do is wait for rescue. Only don't count on being rescued, because the people in charge of doing that tend to give up when # gets too hard to dig through and they've pulled enough people out to say, "We tried."
Originally posted by AfterInfinity
reply to post by Korg Trinity
The truth is, you can't know anything about the positives because you don't know there ARE any positives. You are assuming things will always stay the same throughout immortality.
Nope.. not saying that at all... Quite the opposite in fact.. your negatives are all about the individual staying the same while everything else changes.
I am simply stating that all things will change and adapt. Nothing will remain static.