It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
"It was a normal class," recalled Deandre Poole, in recalling an exercise that upended his academic career.
He had used the classroom activity before, and wasn't particularly worried about it. "I followed the directions from the instructor's guide," he said. The course at Florida Atlantic University was in intercultural communications, and the exercise involves having students write "Jesus" on a piece of paper, and then asking them to step on it. When they hesitate, the instructor has an opening to discuss symbols and their meaning.
Poole said that, as best he could tell, only one student in the course had an objection. That student -- whom Poole did not name in the interview, but who has come forward in local news reports saying he was suspended for objecting to the exercise -- refused to participate and then said repeatedly, Poole said, "How dare you disrespect someone's religion?"
After class, the student came up to him, and made that statement again, this time hitting his balled fist into his other hand and saying that "he wanted to hit me." While the student did not do so, Poole said he was alarmed and notified campus security and filed a report on the student.
The past two weeks, Poole said, have been extremely stressful. "I wake up in the morning not knowing what the day is going to bring."
He said he has received hate mail and death threats, some of them coming in forms particularly hurtful to an African American. "One of the threats said that I might find myself hanging from a tree," he said.
Much of the critical commentary about Poole has suggested that he is anti-Christian. In fact, he said, he has been connected to churches all of his life, has served as a Sunday school teacher, and understands the power of the word "Jesus" on a piece of paper because he cares deeply about Jesus.
“I am very religious,” he said. "I see how the name Jesus is symbolic. For people like myself, Jesus is my lord and savior. It's how I identify myself as a Christian."
Originally posted by xedocodex
hypocrisy...don't you think?
Originally posted by xedocodex
reply to post by retirednature
No, I don't think this is the first time it has happened.
But it seems like a huge deal is made about it when Muslims do it...and like I thought...no one seems to care where Christians do it.
If this was a thread about Muslims threatening a college professor in the United States because he used Mohammad in a teaching exercise...this thread would be blowing up about those evil Muslims.
A bit of hypocrisy...don't you think?
Originally posted by Xenoglossy
Originally posted by xedocodex
hypocrisy...don't you think?
hypocrisy is just another word for "religion"
basically the same meaning
Originally posted by charles1952
Just a few quick thoughts.
1) This is newsworthy because it's rare, just like that guy who burned a copy of the Quoran.
2) "This is what really happened?" All of the comments were the professor's.. He was simply telling his side of the story. I'm not going to assume that it's completely true. You shouldn't either.
3) The professor got a death threat (or maybe more), and that corresponds to rioting which killed our ambassador and others? Everybody who makes a public statement in America gets death threats. Obama, Reid, Palin, Limbaugh, Trump, Bloomberg, the list is endless.
Originally posted by Bleeeeep
The professor's body is no more a sacred thing than the napkin with Jesus written on it. It is what the symbolism represents that makes it sacred, and his actions were blasphemous, and he knows it.
The student in question is a victim to the lesson plan just as the professor is.
The lesson plan is the guilty party.
Originally posted by Bleeeeep
reply to post by Xenoglossy
One step away for you maybe. Sick and twisted much?
The lesson plan is having the professor make the students blasphemy God.
Reread what I wrote without your sick ideas.
Easy to condemn the e-mails, I do. I'm certainly glad no one makes excuses for Muslims.
You can't even bring yourself to condemn the Christians that did this...you just are going to make excuses for them.
Let's think about that. Assume that a professor orders his class to draw a picture of Mohammed and then spit on it. What would my response be then? What would the world's response be? I know the world would demand the professor was at least fired, if not jailed for a hate crime. That's if he even got out of the classroom alive. My response? Honestly, I'd think he'd gone temporarily insane. First, American professors just don't offend Muslims if they want a career. Second, he would have to know, unless he was insane, that his life, property, or both were going to be destroyed soon.
Somehow I don't think your response would be the same if this were Muslims threatening a professor in the United States.
Originally posted by NorEaster
I guess this thread settles the debate going on in my thread.
What amazing timing!
What the professor did wasn't okay. He knows better than to attempt to pursued students to blasphemy God. The professor's body is no more a sacred thing than the napkin with Jesus written on it. It is what the symbolism represents that makes it sacred, and his actions were blasphemous, and he knows it.
The student in question is a victim to the lesson plan just as the professor is.
The lesson plan is the guilty party.
Would you like to reconsider this?
Yes, the fanatics are no different on either side.
Originally posted by charles1952
reply to post by xedocodex
Dear xedocodex,
I understand that emotions can run very high. Sometimes we say things we really don't mean and it takes just a moment to correct our slip.
Would you like to reconsider this?
Yes, the fanatics are no different on either side.
With respect,
Charles1952