It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by RizeorDie
reply to post by swan001
who cares whether you like or dislike phage, this thread isn't about how much we like phage
if you have nothing useful to add apart from disagreeing then be gone
Originally posted by PuterMan
reply to post by NewAgeMan
It appeared that you linked but the link did not work. Horrible when that happens
Was this the link? January full moon mimics path of July sun
Interesting. I did not know that. Since I can see all settings points of the Sun from my study window I will have to check that out.
The Maya were not the only people to note solstices. Most agrarian societies do and did, for very practical reasons.
That just so happens to occur during the Winter Solstice this year. Now, people may believe this is a coincidence that the end of this huge cycle would fall on this solstice when others don't believe with coincidences.
As has been pointed out, the Sun does not (ever) align with the center of the Milky Way however it does align with the galactic equator, every year. As has been pointed out, this alignment has been occurring on the solstice for decades and will continue to do so. As pointed out, this year is not the most "perfect" such alignment. There is no evidence, other than the circular argument regarding this alignment, that the Maya were aware of precession. There is no evidence, other than the circular argument, that the Maya were aware that this alignment would occur.
In terms of alignments id love someone to clear up WHAT will align and whether the "On the winter solstice in 2012, the sun will be aligned with the center of the Milky Way for the first time in about 26,000" argument has any truth.
Why? It has nothing to do with the solstices. It has nothing to do with the equinoxes. It has nothing to do with the rising or setting points.
Ah HA - I feel vindicated thank you. I knew the moon did tricky sun mimicking things but I just didn't know how to describe it properly.
Originally posted by Phage
reply to post by MrConspiracy
The Maya were not the only people to note solstices. Most agrarian societies do and did, for very practical reasons.
I never said they were the only ones. And i am aware of the practical reason behind the acknowledgment of Solstices. However, I was merely pointing out that the December 21st date doesn't seem to be just any random date to end their current age.
What circular argument? The one that says the Maya must have known about precession because the end of the 13th baktun occurs when the Sun is aligned with the galactic equator, so if they knew that was going to happen they must have known about precession. The trouble is, there is nothing else which points to the Maya knowing about precession or that this alignment would be occurring during this time frame, or that the Maya would place any significance on the alignment even if they knew it would happen.
I understand that there is nothing that proves they knew. But on the same level, with the amount of information they seem to have been aware of in term of space.. One can understand people's assumptions about their possible knowledge of precession. However, a person that has their answers based on empirical evidence only, of course would see holes in this argument, and who can blame them.
Thanks for clearing some things up.edit on 16-12-2012 by MrConspiracy because: (no reason given)
But on the same level, with the amount of information they seem to have been aware of in term of space
Maya cosmology is not easy to reconstruct from our current knowledge of their civilization. It seems apparent, however, that the Maya believed Earth to be flat and four-cornered.
Some Maya also believed that the sky was multi-layered and that it was supported at the corners by four gods of immense physical strength called "Bacabs". Other Maya believed that the sky was supported by four trees of different colours and species, with the green ceiba, or silk-cotton tree, at the centre.
Earth in its flat form was thought by the Maya to be the back of a giant crocodile, resting in a pool of water lilies. The crocodile's counterpart in the sky was a double-headed serpent - a concept probably based on the fact that the Maya word for "sky" is similar to the word for "snake". In hieroglyphics, the body of the sky-serpent is marked not only with its own sign of crossed bands, but also those of the Sun, the Moon, Venus and other celestial bodies.
Originally posted by Raelsatu
Well, in 7 days we'll find out. I don't believe nor disbelieve the hype behind this date, but I do find the alignment at the very least to be worth paying attention to. People seem to either be on one side of the fence or the other.
Anyway, 1 week left.edit on 14-12-2012 by Raelsatu because: (no reason given)
But no I'm not a troll. Me I'm trying to build a bridge around a certain royal keystone that we can all walk across (toll free) into a new domain of new possibility and freedom with a better understanding and comprehension of our true place in the grand scheme of things.
That is simply bollocks, in 3 dimmensions every two objects can align at any point or time.
Originally posted by Phage
reply to post by NewAgeMan
Why? It has nothing to do with the solstices. It has nothing to do with the equinoxes. It has nothing to do with the rising or setting points.
Ah HA - I feel vindicated thank you. I knew the moon did tricky sun mimicking things but I just didn't know how to describe it properly.