It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
So, the same ATS members who are convinced this is a work of fiction, flagged this thread 85 times?
Originally posted by rabidrabbithole
reply to post by Spacespider
At some point you have to admit that either the author or the alien is lying. Early in the vid the Alien states that it may never be found because it's whereabouts are unknown. Then early in the second video the alien says that it has been in constant contact with it's commander. This rabbit hole goes no deeper. Believe it or not. I wouldn't put too much faith with such a major inconsistency.
Originally posted by OOOOOO
Right from the beginning she said that the alien told her the universe, has been around for a trillion years, sense the alien had not learned English yet, how would it know what a solar year is, to say trillion years to start with.
I use the number "trillions" 30 (Footnote) because I am sure that the meaning was a number larger than many billions. The idea of the length of time she communicated is beyond me.
Originally posted by HumanoidX
reply to post by Oouthere
It just doesn't add up..Why recycle evil souls back to our planet.?
You battle the empire for thousands of years, but in the end you don't have the desire to undo their evils doings?
Is there not a less desirable planet to send the evil and unchangeable souls??
Why in Gods name would all Artist be considered evil?
Started out an interesting read and may even have some truths within....
That being said, the hands off approach is understandable.....but Why abandon a planet you have fought so long to free of the empire??
Originally posted by rabidrabbithole
Debunked. I'll admit that I had to listen to the audio for a third time before I found the "smoking gun". Early in the first video the alien explains that his "people" may find them in a few minutes or maybe never because they did not know where they were. Then early in the second video the Alien says that it has been in constant contact with it's commander. If there actually was an interview, then at the very least we know that the alien is a liar...
Originally posted by BigfootNZ
Hmm Space station 33?... for a million year old (not sure of that, cant properly remember from when I read it) civilization with intergalactic travel covering the galaxy...
However, I have not personally had intimate contact with beings on Earth since 5,965 BCE. It is not my primary function to interact with inhabitants of planets within The Domain. I am an Officer, Pilot and Engineer, with many duties to perform. Nonetheless, although I am fluent in 347 other languages within The Domain, I have not been exposed to your English language. The last Earth language with which I was conversant was
the Sanskrit language of the Vedic Hymns.
Originally posted by ipsedixit
I think this alleged conversation is a fraud.
On page 49 of the book it says:
However, I have not personally had intimate contact with beings on Earth since 5,965 BCE. It is not my primary function to interact with inhabitants of planets within The Domain. I am an Officer, Pilot and Engineer, with many duties to perform. Nonetheless, although I am fluent in 347 other languages within The Domain, I have not been exposed to your English language. The last Earth language with which I was conversant was
the Sanskrit language of the Vedic Hymns.
Wouldn't the use of the term BCE in relation to dates imply that some of the rest of what was said in the paragraph is a lie? The term BCE wasn't used until very recently and it is an English acronym. How could the alien communicate this sort of information to the interviewer telepathically and in these terms?
Originally posted by MysticPearl
So, the same ATS members who are convinced this is a work of fiction, flagged this thread 85 times?
Something doesn't add up. Either ATS members believe this and aren't willing to actually say that within the thread as they're scared of being ridiculed, or they simply can't hold a thought from one minute to the next and flag something they think is false and forgot when flagging the damn thread that they actually think it's false, which really makes ATS look bad and means the majority of opinions should be ignored.
But this just doesn't add up. Everyone within the thread thinks it's a work of fiction, yet it's been flagged 85 times?
Bravo, ATS.
Either man-up and be honest to the fact you believe it, or quit assisting hoaxes by flagging things you think aren't true.edit on 26-11-2012 by MysticPearl because: (no reason given)