It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Pellinore
reply to post by JourPolaire
Hear hear! Well said, my fellow Canuck. Thank you for taking the high road.
I am also a proud Canadian. And I will be honest.
I cannot stand up and condemn those who participate in killing baby seals.
I don't agree with it and I would never do it myself, but I can't condemn it. Why?
Because I eat and wear animal parts and so do nearly all of you. Killing a seal = killing any animal. For fur, leather, burgers, bacon, sealskin, or medicine.
It's all taking life.
So why get bent about one but not another? Outrage at one killing but not another is an unconsidered and emotional response.
Isn't it? Feels like it to me.
Originally posted by Six6Six
Originally posted by Pellinore
reply to post by JourPolaire
Hear hear! Well said, my fellow Canuck. Thank you for taking the high road.
I am also a proud Canadian. And I will be honest.
I cannot stand up and condemn those who participate in killing baby seals.
I don't agree with it and I would never do it myself, but I can't condemn it. Why?
Because I eat and wear animal parts and so do nearly all of you. Killing a seal = killing any animal. For fur, leather, burgers, bacon, sealskin, or medicine.
It's all taking life.
So why get bent about one but not another? Outrage at one killing but not another is an unconsidered and emotional response.
Isn't it? Feels like it to me.
This is a poor attitude, Do you kill dogss? Do you kill cats or think thats is ok?
What about killing other humans....is that ok with you? After all many other people and species are killed every day....just asking if you think those are ok to kill too?
Originally posted by sweetstuff
First of all, Canada's national sport? Maybe you should educate yourself on the facts a bit, as the majority of Canadians, myself included live no where near any seals, nor engage in any seal hunting and there have been protests, as well as letters written to parliment on the practice which I agree is horrific.
However lumping all Canadians in as seal killing clubbers would be no different than me calling all Americans war hounds, etc. Deny ignorance.
Originally posted by Six6Six
reply to post by sweetstuff
Well a country is as a country does. You have voted for your current government and they are still not acting on this quickly enough.
IT seen worldwide as a Canadian THING. Its been going on for decade!! More people in canada last year protested for the legalization of POT that for the stopping of SEAL clubbling!! Why is that?
It's sad and it's cruel. It just shouldn't happen period. I just think that there are much more pressing issues going on in the World right now that are much more important.
Originally posted by Six6Six
Originally posted by Pellinore
reply to post by JourPolaire
Hear hear! Well said, my fellow Canuck. Thank you for taking the high road.
I am also a proud Canadian. And I will be honest.
I cannot stand up and condemn those who participate in killing baby seals.
I don't agree with it and I would never do it myself, but I can't condemn it. Why?
Because I eat and wear animal parts and so do nearly all of you. Killing a seal = killing any animal. For fur, leather, burgers, bacon, sealskin, or medicine.
It's all taking life.
So why get bent about one but not another? Outrage at one killing but not another is an unconsidered and emotional response.
Isn't it? Feels like it to me.
This is a poor attitude, Do you kill dogss? Do you kill cats or think thats is ok?
What about killing other humans....is that ok with you? After all many other people and species are killed every day....just asking if you think those are ok to kill too?
Originally posted by gate13
to be honest big deal in the scheme of the world.
The elite rich the 1% let the 99% of us starve and make life a battle for us all that is worse then clubbing seals and this happens every day...
Where does the Atlantic seal hunt take place? The hunt usually opens in March in the "Gulf" areas around the Magdalen Islands and Prince Edward Island. The main hunt on the so-called "front" usually begins in April off the east coast of Newfoundland. It's pretty much over by May. The total allowable catch for harp seals is split between two areas: 70 per cent for the waters off Newfoundland and 30 per cent for the St. Lawrence Gulf region. How many are they allowed to hunt? There are federal quotas for three types of seals: harp seals, hooded seals and grey seals. Most of the hunt is for harp seals. The 2009 harp seal total allowable catch has been set at 280,000, up slightly from the previous year. That's down from the 2006 quota of 325,000, and about the same as the quota set from 1997 to 2002. The catch in 2001 was 226,000. In 2000, it was just 92,000 seals. Seal hunters do not always catch as many seals as they are allowed and sometimes they are allowed to exceed the pre-season quota. The 2009 total allowable catch is 8,200 for hooded seals and 50,000 for grey seals. What about those cute whitecoat seals? Whitecoats are newborn harp seals. Most Canadians can recall pictures of whitecoated seal pups being clubbed. The images were so inflammatory that Canada banned all hunting of whitecoats and bluebacks (otherwise known as hooded seals) in 1987. You'd never know that from some of the anti-sealing groups that still prominently display pictures of whitecoats on their websites and in fundraising materials. One site even features a downloadable video of people hugging whitecoats. The reality is that whitecoats can't be hunted anymore. It's also true that young harp seals lose their white coats (and their protection) at about 12 to 14 days of age. After that, they're fair game for hunters, although they're usually about 25 days old before they're hunted. Most harp seals taken are under the age of three months. Young yes, whitecoats no. Are seals skinned alive? This is a frequent accusation levelled by hunt opponents. The International Fund for Animal Welfare says seals are routinely clubbed or shot and left to suffer on the ice until they're clubbed later. The IFAW also charges that seals are often "skinned before being rendered fully unconscious" and said its observers found that few sealers check for a blinking reflex to confirm brain death before skinning begins. Similar "skinning alive" accusations have also been made by other groups, with many citing studies claiming that up to 45 per cent of seals are "skinned alive." A 2002 report in the Canadian Veterinary Journal found that "the large majority of seals taken during this hunt … are killed in an acceptably humane manner." This study found that 98 per cent of hunted seals it examined had been killed properly. The federal Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO) cites this study among others as proof that the hunt opponents are wrong in their accusations of widespread cruelty. Regarding the "skinning alive" charge, the DFO says appearances can be deceiving. "Sometimes a seal may appear to be moving after it has been killed," the DFO says. "However, seals have a swimming reflex that is active, even after death. This reflex falsely appears as though the animal is still alive when it is clearly dead — similar to the reflex in chickens." Furthermore, the DFO says the club, or hakapik, used by many sealers is "an efficient tool" that kills "quickly and humanely." The Royal Commission on Seals and Sealing in Canada found that clubbing, when properly performed, is at least as humane as killing methods in commercial slaughterhouses. Opponents say clubbing often isn't "properly performed." The federal government acknowledges that it has laid more than 200 charges against sealers since 1996, but argues that shows it's serious about enforcing its regulations. How does the seal hunt benefit Canada? The economic value of the seal hunt is another one of those things that is open to interpretation. The federal government says the landed value of seals exceeded $16.5 million in 2005, providing a "significant" source of income for thousands of sealers — benefiting them and their families at a time when, according to the DFO, "other fishing options are unavailable, or limited at best, in many remote, coastal communities."