It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Masonic Light
Originally posted by Jamuhn
Although the context of Salza's words were christian (though not all), the context of this thread is not a christian context, but much more broad.
Let me hop into the argument for a sec:
I've never heard of Salza, but will assume momentarily that he's telling the truth about being a former Mason. Even if this is true, we can easily see by his website that he has come under the influence of the Roman Catholic Church, which has waged relentless war against Freemasonry and other free thinking societies since the Inquisition.
It's also ironic that he accuses Masons of using fallacious ad hominem, while he himself engages in ad hominem repeatedly. I don't know about you guys, but where I'm from, this is called being a hypocrite. First someone posts some garbage about Masons being satanists or worshipping owl gods or whatever; a Mason responds by calling the accusation ridiculous, then an opponent of Masonry accuses the Mason defending the fraternity of using ad hominem. Surely I'm not the only one who sees the comedy in this "logic".
Fiat Lvx.
Originally posted by df1
Originally posted by Jamuhn
But, I am still wondering how many masons have broken their oaths by saying certain things on the board.
Of the ATS members that are Masons I would expect that few if any have violated the oath they took in their particular Lodge or jurisdiction. The fact that you are left wondering is the evidence that nothing has been divulged. If folks are still guessing, the secrets are safe.
And if they haven't I have attempted to answer why they haven't. Though I'd appreciate more on-topic responses about 'the masonic pysche.'
I accept that you posted in the NWO topic group by accident, however it being posted here does have an influence. Perhaps more Masons visit "secret societies" topic group than visit the NWO topic group. I'd expect that you would receive even fewer posts had it been posted under predictions.
.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
I still don't know the point of rituals...
Originally posted by Jamuhn
His beef is with masonry being indefensible to christianity.
And maybe you have not noticed it, but Masons on this board are employing such method...repeatedly.
But, back to your second post, how prevalent are the many rituals in Masonic books? As Salza says, rituals are the most important part in Masonry, and it is the rituals alone that Masons do not divulge when defending their Brotherhood.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
Yes....they have Masonic Light. I've seen many a people be called idiots, or morally bankrupt, so on and so forth, for bringing honest statements/questions in reference to the order at large, not even the individuals. I know that other stuff occurs, and I think it's significantly covered where it happens, so I'm not bringing that up. I guess by provoke, you mean to question the mighty order LOL. Some guy can accidently step on my toes, and this could be taken as a provocation. So do I start yelling at the guy, calling him names? Of course not.
So, then...maybe you could point me out to a couple rituals. Or rather, could you explain to me the purpose of blinfolding a man, putting a noose around his neck and a sword at his chest while he reads the masonic oath?
What I'd really like for you or another mason to do, is debate the statements of Salza point by point, and where he would have thought of such an idea if the statements were false. I can see it now...it's all in his head.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
LOL, I think I know what happened from my own experience. I don't need you or anyone else to tell me the course of events or the intentions of masons responding to statements/questions. The fact that you are trying to defend situations/people that are totally a mystery to you and that you want to tell me I read opposite is just plain silly...LOL
But anyway, the ritual is very interesting Masonic Light, but I guess that's just the tip of the iceberg, eh? And, the sword part I got from an ex-mason on this board, so I'm assuming that it just doesn't happen in your large. BUT IT'S NOT...false.
I am starting to understand a little more now, as for the statement about Masons being as right as they are wrong...perhaps to do with the diversity in lodges and orders?
Anyway, yes I do have particular statements/questions, which I have scattered throughout this thread...And another asking about the most/next-most noteworthy ritual in your lodge.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
LOL, yea, I stopped reading some of those mason threads, they are getting kind of ridiculous, aren't they. Well, when he Salza said "as right as they are wrong," I think he means that Masons believe strongly in relativity as opposed to absolute. I don't find this grounds to criticize any individual person on, especially seeing as I believe the same thing!
Here's a question (I'll warn you, I probably have a followup), are rituals only performed during conferrence of degree ceremonies? Are there rituals that occur as specified times throughout the years (like holidays)? And if the answer to the later is yes, I was wondering if you could give me an example.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
BTW, I have the Kant book 'groundwork...;' I haven't had a chance to read it yet, but it's on my list. I also have a book by Gay called "The Enlightment, The Rise of Modern Paganism." I haven't read it yet, but kind of a strange title. It seems the Enlightment had many spirits (no pun intended).
I think I'm starting to get a better understanding of Masonry now. I keep thinking back to the supposedly original Libertarians, who were the Illuminati. What does this have to do with Masonry? The original Illuminati believed in freedom, all around. And I still wonder, "so wait, why are they bad again...." "order out of chaos, you say" I just don't understand how that connection is made, but that's a different thread.
And, I still don't understand the part about women and the handicapped. I honestly don't buy the historical basis.
I mean, historically America had slaves and women couldn't vote. Things change, you know, I'd figure Masonry would too. I couldn't even fathom who or what would initiate such a change if it were to happen, do you know?
Originally posted by TheSeeker
First let me say that you are on the outside looking in, and Masonry is far from a glass house. You truly have no concept of The Craft, and therefore your constant prodding, guessing, and I assume, envy will never allow you to understand our order.
Originally posted by Jamuhn
Personally, I don't want to join something I don't know about. I've talked to many locally as well as on the board and I could talk to everyone in my city, but it would still take time to decide whether I wanted to join.
Originally posted by 7th_Chakra
DF1, Leveller.
does a man in a skeleton suit hug the 33rd degree mason at any point within washington?
Do 33rd degree masons leave through a different door then everyone else in the washington grand temple place?
Originally posted by theron dunn
ASK for g-d's sake and stop complaining, and MAYBE one of us will answer your question.