It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by DaveNorris
reply to post by dannotz
If you saw a rock covered in moss, would you say the rock itself was alive. Earth is that rock and we are but moss
Originally posted by Gorman91
You were going good until you said that because Antarctica looks like the brain it means the Earth has one.
The Earth is not sentient. Though you can very much so say it's alive.
Life=awareness of a kind, even if it's one we don't know how to communicate with.
If the Earth was sentient, the only logical thing to do would be to die.
This statement is nonsensical.
It's the only living planet it can see and know about,
There is absolutely no way for us to know that for sure.
and the only thing also sentient would be the things killing it. It would be equivalent to a sex slave, praying for death every day.
This statement is nonsensical.
There is absolutely no way for us to know that for sure.
I don't even know what to say to that..
Originally posted by Gorman91
You were going good until you said that because Antarctica looks like the brain it means the Earth has one.
The Earth is not sentient. Though you can very much so say it's alive.
If the Earth was sentient, the only logical thing to do would be to die. It's the only living planet it can see and know about, and the only thing also sentient would be the things killing it. It would be equivalent to a sex slave, praying for death every day.
You discount hope. Why don't all cancer patients commit suicide? Many fight to the bitter end, never giving up hope even when the cancer cells have clearly taken over. In fact, because I know personally three people who have miraculously simply healed with no logical scientific basis for doing so, this hope is not always misplaced.
I'm not arguing against you since I have no means of knowing for sure the earth is sentient, or not. I'm just adding another perspective.
Also, how do we know the earth is not committing suicide? It's a big beast and nearly everything it has done of great significance has thus far been on a scale that dwarfs our puny lifetimes. We could very well be living in its suicidal death throes and not even realize it. Every time I read science news articles I am taken aback time and time again at how very little we know about things, and even the things we thought we knew, keep having to be revised. I don't see how any of us can feel so confident as to declare anything with such absolute certainty when it is clear our science is still in its toddler stage.
Originally posted by wulff
I can;t believe so many members really think the earth is "alive" as in a biological sense.. like people, it is made of rock, (some molten) water, more rock, a metal core and organisms living on and slightly below it's surface!
Comparing rivers to blood vessels, etc. ridicules human intelligence God gave you!!
I will agree that there are a lot of strange things in this universe but come on people, get serious! We have come a long way from when people thought the Sun was a living being and would sacrifice (murder) a poor victim to please it so it would come up the next day! Or have we? Seems some of you have not evolved past that stage!
I think I will look for a more intelligent thread!