It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by FreedomXisntXFree
What you've heard about OWS being a bunch of "collectivists" that just want a hand out is a lie.
Originally posted by FreedomXisntXFree
Btw my comment about "living comfortable our whole lives" was directed towards middle class citizens which I fall under. But the middle class is a dying breed and its slowly becoming just the RICH and POOR.
I am sorry to hear that you didn't have some of the things I have taken for granted growing up. But no longer. I have grown up and denied ignorance. Sadly ignorance is bliss for some.
Originally posted by FreedomXisntXFree
That means people would have more money in their wallets. So another hypothetical question pops up. If your friend or family member got injured and needed help paying medical costs they people around you would have enough money to help. I know I would help if I had extra cash in my pocket. But maybe that is just me.
We as a people just need to be earning an amount of money that isn't kept at a minimum to live and struggle to get by. The elite in this world are so greedy that they horde all the money, illegally or legally, and keep enough of it so there's barely anything for us.
Keith Olbermann reads the OWS plea. Listen to the words. Don't get distracted by the images even though they do mean just as much.
Maybe I'm a collectivist. I don't know. But I care about people. Our brains are programmed that way almost. Its not that I want to live on a commune by any means.
But a "commune" mentality in terms of Food, Healthcare, and Education is attainable if all the wealth that was EARNED by the 99% was in possession of the 99%. Because we are the ones that do ALL OF THE WORK.
You just give me the impression if that you are just accepting this current tyranny because you believe the other route is tyranny even though it boasts of wanting to better humanity. That's the only part I see that I feel you are mistaken.
I can see how a collectivist attitude could be used against us and be corrupted like socialism and communism where the people higher on the totem pole get to run things which is where corruption ruins a good idea. The US of A was a good idea and corruption has spilled into our capitalist government as well. I still believe in Capitalism as its been proven to work.
Originally posted by FreedomXisntXFree
Socialism in the notion that you provide for yourself.....makes capitalism stronger.
Originally posted by nenothtu
Originally posted by randyvs
reply to post by nenothtu
So you don't / do have a side ? You are your own side ? You wouldn't fight to be free from tyranny ? I find your message cynical even tho it remains quite vague. Maybe you live in the Ozarks or the Blue ridge mountains ?
If thats the case, then I can at least see your point.
I'm from the Appalachians, west of the Blue Ridge, towards the Cumberlands, but I don't live there now.
I have fought to free others from tyranny, and will most certainly fight to free myself from tyranny. I don't see the benefits in trading one tyranny for another, which is what this "movement" is all about.
Sorry for the vagueness, but yes I am cynical to a fault, with reason. I've seen what these "Glorious People's Revolutions" prosecuted by Collectivists leave in their wake, and will fight like hell to keep it from taking over a neighborhood near you... or me. I know how they work, have seen them in action and have the T-shirt and scars to prove it.
You may have misunderstood me because I didn't make myself clear. There is nothing for you to be sorry about - if I had it to do all over again, I wouldn't change a single thing about it. I don't know if one would say it "toughened me up", gave me "character", or any of that other sentimental noble crap, but one thing it DID do for me that I would not change is that it taught me how to live with adversity and get through to the other side. Where other people will fold, I'll just keep putting one foot in front of the other, and make it to my goal. To me, that is worth more than all of the money Wall Street holds.
I still maintain that this is NOT going to end well.
Originally posted by randyvs
Holy crap ! With a tremendous amount of luck a person sure can make themselves look extremely smart.
As I said I can see your point.
Funny how you reminded me of people I know just with the little bit you wrote. I think my being born in Missouri
might have something to do with it. Anyways I totally understand your way of thinking and can even go as far as
envy. Your people raised you proud and head strong.
I feel like were brothers.
There is another member here . He is from W. Virginia, Conclusion 1. You remind me so much of him. I havn't seen him on here for awhile. He's down in the coal mines. Hope he's alright. Anyway you both have a tremendous understanding of what the hell is going on as Freedom does as well. You two are great examples
of members to this site. I'm enjoying this very much as I'm able to see what you both are saying. Good work
I still maintain that this is NOT going to end well.
And that is all what this thread is about. Manipulating that end.
Originally posted by FreedomXisntXFree
When I was using the word Socialism I'm using that to describe the idea of people helping one another when they need it.
I agree the "struggles" that we go through makes up our lives and teaches us things. But that doesn't mean the government/corporations can artificially create these struggles.
My biggest point is Freedom ends up being "socialistic" because people who are free take care of their fellow man. If we got to keep a majority of what we earned off OUR HARD WORK then that would mean more money for myself that I earned. No one handed it to me. I can use it as I please. I could use it to feed people with no food, healthcare, education etc. My point is we demand from our government all of these "rights". The mistake with demanding these things from our government is that it gives them the power of who gets educated, fed, and aid. Corruption prevents those things from happening.
True Freedom would be saying "screw you fed" we aren't giving you our money anymore because I made it off of my hard work. When the government taxes they tax to redistribute wealth TO THEMSELVES.
Ron Paul seems to be the only politician that wants to start giving our FREEDOM back. He wants to get rid of all these different government departments that in the end are Socialist.
We already have socialism in our GOVERNMENT and our anger shows it doesn't work.
You say you'll change the constitution
Well, you know
We all want to change your head
You tell me it's the institution
Well, you know
You better free your mind instead
But if you go carrying pictures of chairman Mao
You ain't going to make it with anyone anyhow
Originally posted by nenothtu
One other thought in regards to the "stuff" being used to control issue, and then I'll stop spamming your thread with my mega-posts.. or at least I'll try to...
Whether one believes in a religion or not, there are nuggets of wisdom to be found strewn here and there among all of them. Here's an example. Don't read it for religion, read it for wisdom.
In the Christian's Bible, there is a story of a rich kid who wanted to join the Disciples. I don't know, maybe it was a fad thing. Anyhow, Jesus tells him to sell all his "stuff", then he can come follow him. Well, the kid drops his head and walks off sad, because he had a lot of "stuff".
Jesus KNEW what that connection was. He KNEW who was free and who was the slave in that situation.
And he KNEW what created that slavery to begin with.
/end dragging religion in to the discussion.
edit on 2011/10/16 by nenothtu because: (no reason given)