It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by MamaJ
reply to post by bogomil
Pseudo rational reasoning and preaching won't do it.
Why not? Why can it not be up to the reality in which the individual relates in.If it is preaching then...so be it? I am just trying to understand your rationale as I cant mine.
I go soooooo deep sometimes I wonder where in my mind the "deepness" comes from. A sense? Not sure....but for the sake of argument I want you to explain yourself in terms I can better understand. I know where you are coming from but I need more specifics regarding the reality. Reality of the now is different for me as it is for you. So.....
If someone were to have a reality involving scripture to the Higher Creative Energy force and understand it in ways we do not perceive their reality is true to them and not for you or me..... This is what I understand to be "Reality".
Originally posted by bogomil
reply to post by MamaJ
You wrote:
Quote: ["When people of ALL faiths pass on.....they all see Jesus (MANY videos and stories to read or view)."]
This is one of the most wild assumptions I ever heard.
This is not an assumption I made up my friend....this is Truth to them, the ones who experienced such.. as there are videos and texts written by the many....also the atheists who do not believe...some after experiencing talking with Jesus now have converted to now believing in such an entity and they all say they understand now what they must do....they all say the same thing. Coincidence??
Quote: ["When others share same Realities then there lies more Truth to them and even a confirmation of their own Truth of Reality as well."]
The same can be claimed from ANY set of theist premises.
It can be claimed from ANYONE...not just theists. This Truth holds for anyone who believes and pushes a belief.
Quote: ["What we may consider is not forming an opinion based on their Reality."]
And inversely and on subjective grounds not enforcing or pushing our reality on anyone.
I agree.....love does not create fear and the experience of Love is what we are to share if one believes in the message from Jesus. He taught love.
Originally posted by bogomil
reply to post by MamaJ
You wrote:
["Its all in the "mind" and the Truth behind the mind is a whole other subject based on the same thing though.....perception of the senses."]
Where does christian mythology come into this?
When it is presented to the Mind.
Quote: ["When you take out our senses.....what do we have? Nothing."]
Not a valid generalization for everybody. I am e.g. exempted from it.
HA! Whatever you say.
Quote: ["First one perceives through their own individual mind....reads something (like Scriptures) and then perceives it in the manner to which they read it based on prior Realities of their own truth. When this happens....the Truth is revealed and most want to reveal their truth to others. This is where the problem lies......"]
There are several scenarios different from this one.
ok
Quote: ["Some will ask.....well why then did Jesus make it hard for us to understand the Truth? He says it is because we are not ready and when he comes back he will tell us the Truth. To some this reality of Truth is not yet Truth until he returns. To others....there is no Truth in regards to His Word....... This too is where a problem arises."]
Yes...some. A growing majority is completely disinterested in even considering this perspective as true.
And a growing majority may disagree with your perspective as well. Whose Truth is right???
Originally posted by bogomil
Originally posted by SuperiorEd
reply to post by bogomil
As per yorr reply, I suggest you read this LINK suggested by user Oilse. Very impressive writing and thought.
Drowning a thread in links to material, where the answer is made on assumptions and premises constructed to 'prove' something circle-argumentatory, is a waste of time.
They have the same (what's basically preachings) rephrased. If something is questioned the first time, repeating it in other words, doesn't make it more true. Overusing such a method only results in people ignoring such links.
Anyway a debate forum should be between individuals mainly being able to carry their own claims. Not just being a passive directory to external sources conflicting with each other.
Originally posted by MamaJ
reply to post by bogomil
Pseudo rational reasoning and preaching won't do it.
Why not? Why can it not be up to the reality in which the individual relates in.If it is preaching then...so be it? I am just trying to understand your rationale as I cant mine.
I go soooooo deep sometimes I wonder where in my mind the "deepness" comes from. A sense? Not sure....but for the sake of argument I want you to explain yourself in terms I can better understand. I know where you are coming from but I need more specifics regarding the reality. Reality of the now is different for me as it is for you. So.....
If someone were to have a reality involving scripture to the Higher Creative Energy force and understand it in ways we do not perceive their reality is true to them and not for you or me..... This is what I understand to be "Reality".
reply to post by SuperiorEd
I agree. Humans learn by symbol, metaphor and analogy much better than technical writing. It's interesting to listen to a rational lecture come from someone with titles behind there name and then hear the same lecture in one sentence from the Bible or philosophy.
Semantics and preaching. This doesn't mean anything, unless you already accept it passively.
Or directed towards rational reasoning, if the message is meant for public use, where subjective faith is of lesser or no value.
Originally posted by bogomil
reply to post by SuperiorEd
You wrote:
["As I state in the title of the OP, truth is obvious."]
On your premises, not those of real science.
Quote: ["We stand for something or against everything with blame. Blame is the signature of those who look to others as the source of their problems. I'll stand on virtue and truth in deference to God."]
Semantics and preaching. This doesn't mean anything, unless you already accept it passively.
Quote: ["We are all free to define our perspectives in detail."]
And we're all free to oppose it. I'm far from suggesting censorship.
Quote: ["Any message travels better if directed toward belief and not directly against another."]
Or directed towards rational reasoning, if the message is meant for public use, where subjective faith is of lesser or no value.
Originally posted by MamaJ
reply to post by SuperiorEd
I agree. Humans learn by symbol, metaphor and analogy much better than technical writing. It's interesting to listen to a rational lecture come from someone with titles behind there name and then hear the same lecture in one sentence from the Bible or philosophy.
It was not written to coincide with the "now" slang/language of many..... nor was it meant for us to understand the message through one language. This is where one can argue the fact but in my reality....it is Truth. We cannot decipher the language in Jesus's time to fit with ours exactly so if Jesus spoke (as he did) metaphorically or in parables then all languages can read between the lines or have a better understanding.. Each human being can find truth in it...not in an every day type of language that we use presently.
For this reason Jesus used logic to satisfy his need for not one specific type of language but for all to understand within their own right and own language by using parables.
Maybe I am delsuional....lol....oh wait I am. I will be awakened to the True Reality soon though.
Originally posted by bogomil
reply to post by SuperiorEd
You wrote:
["Almost got it right. This doesn't mean anything, unless you already accept it actively, engaging it into your sense of virtue and intent of action. The whole point is to have actions and heart agree with intellect in equanimity. When your future choices agree with your past results in equal harmony, peace and bliss follow. Anything else activates cognitive dissonance, worry, guilt, and worst of all, shame. The heart will always be in a state of dispair and unrest when rationality is led by the ego. Truth is always there to sear the conscience."]
So the commonplace observation, that harmony is beneficial, 'proves' your mythology. It 'proves' buddhism, tao'ism, tantra and some parts of hinduism even more, leaving the bible and christianity rather low on the list of truth and applied truth.
And harmony in a greater social context is much better examplified and applied through utilitarian morality, which doesn't promote selective elitism or privileges.
Quote: ["Faith is evidenced by hope for clearly demonstrated good as a result."]
Amongst all religionists, in spite of the often big differences between their doctrines. So it's not the content of the faith, but just faith per se working. Besides there were also faithful nazis, who were filled with joy and hope for mankind as the genocide of jews went on.
Quote: ["We see the opposite in society each day when biblical virtue is rationalized and exchanged for the broader path of vice."]
You must live in a pretty awful place, 'seeing' that. I live a secular society and 'see' the opposite. You're simply making this up to fit your pre-determined answer.
Quote: ["Rationalization destroys what faith preserves."]
Yes, thank FSM for that. No more theocracies.
Quote: ["We see the opposite in society each day when biblical virtue is rationalized and exchanged for the broader path of vice."]
You must live in a pretty awful place, 'seeing' that. I live a secular society and 'see' the opposite. You're simply making this up to fit your pre-determined answer.
Originally posted by bogomil
reply to post by SuperiorEd