It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by smithjustinb
In a world where everything is free, who would steal? In this way, theft is an illusion.
Originally posted by Nosred
Originally posted by smithjustinb
In a world where everything is free, who would steal? In this way, theft is an illusion.
In a world where everything is free, who would create?
Originally posted by Screwed
Originally posted by Nosred
Originally posted by smithjustinb
In a world where everything is free, who would steal? In this way, theft is an illusion.
In a world where everything is free, who would create?
I would.
Originally posted by Screwed
I would.
Originally posted by Nosred
Originally posted by Screwed
I would.
'Create' as in 'produce', as in growing crops, manufacturing clothing, making shoes, building houses, building vehicles, building roads, etc.
Originally posted by smithjustinb
Freedom doesn't mean manufacturing plants have to close down.
Originally posted by juniperberry
So you're all willing to create and then give it all away for free?
Where's the incentive?
If everything and everyone was free, what's to stop everyone from heading to the beach everyday and ignoring the important things like gathering food? Or feeding your children? Or building safe buildings? Or doing life saving surgery?
People do things for money (or advantage). If there was no advantage half the people would stop doing anything..
Soo.. good luck with that..
Originally posted by Mister_Bit
Whilst this theory sounds ideal I don't believe it would work for many reasons.
If, in my expression of true freedom I wanted to thump someone in the face would that be ok? No, of course not, so you would need someone or something to enforce those rules right?
So who enforces the rules? Who writes those rules? What if not everyone agrees to those rules? Who is in charge, who makes the final decision?
We can never be truely free, but we could start by removing money from society. This I believe is the real "prison" keeping us all from freedom.
Originally posted by Nosred
Originally posted by smithjustinb
Freedom doesn't mean manufacturing plants have to close down.
Yet they still would. What factory worker in his right mind is going to work several hours a day for nothing? What point would there be inspecting the quality of products being manufactured on an assembly line when you can just take whatever you want from anyone else without paying for it?
Where's all that metal to manufacture things going to come from? You think miners are going to risk their lives every day out of the goodness of their hearts so you can get a free television? Yeah, right.
And lumberjacks who cut down trees so paper and furniture can be made, there's no way they're going to risk losing a limb or a finger every day when all they have to do to feed their families is take food from someone else.
edit on 22-6-2011 by Nosred because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by smithjustinb
Everybody should know that they have to do their part. Just knowing that if it is to be its up to you SHOULD be incentive enough. Knowing that if it weren't for you working, nothing would get done and everything would die.
Responsibility.
Originally posted by Nosred
Originally posted by smithjustinb
Everybody should know that they have to do their part. Just knowing that if it is to be its up to you SHOULD be incentive enough. Knowing that if it weren't for you working, nothing would get done and everything would die.
Responsibility.
Yeah, coal miners are going to risk their lives every day because they need to "do their part" and because it's "the responsible thing to do". If a coal miner could put food on his families table without ever working another day in his life, you don't think he would?
Well, at least until the food ran out due to all the farmers that aren't farming and people hoarding food. I'm sure people would be carrying shopping carts full of free stuff out of their local grocery stores.edit on 22-6-2011 by Nosred because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by Nosred
Originally posted by smithjustinb
Everybody should know that they have to do their part. Just knowing that if it is to be its up to you SHOULD be incentive enough. Knowing that if it weren't for you working, nothing would get done and everything would die.
Responsibility.
Yeah, coal miners are going to risk their lives every day because they need to "do their part" and because it's "the responsible thing to do". If a coal miner could put food on his families table without ever working another day in his life, you don't think he would?
Well, at least until the food ran out due to all the farmers that aren't farming and people hoarding food. I'm sure people would be carrying shopping carts full of free stuff out of their local grocery stores.edit on 22-6-2011 by Nosred because: (no reason given)