PLANET X('s inhabitants) - consider this.

I don't buy in to the whole Planet X story; I'm not saying it's not possible I just haven't read anything that really sold the idea to me.
However, working with the assumption that Planet X does exist and its orbit is about to swing it through our system, has anyone considered this:

It seems as though the panic being caused by believers of the Planet X theory is due to Planet X having some sort of catastrophic gravitational impact on planets in our system (someone please correct me if I'm wrong), if this is the case (and planet X is inhabited), couldn't the occupants of said planet be just as affected by the presence of the regular planets in our system? Am I missing something? Or is the fate of potential Planet Xians not a major concern for you promoters of the theory?

reply to post by ballsdeep


I am very limited on the subject as far as it is but, from what I recall... The inhabitants of said planet are supposed to be like this ancient race of Aliens...so they probably already have that sorted out.

reply to post by ballsdeep


planet X A.K.A. Nibiru passes by every 240,000 years. which is one quarter of a great year, and every great year is the end and beginning of a new world. 2012 is supposed to be the end of this great year and the closest pass of the planet. each other time the planet disrupted the earth within this great year resulted in cataclysmic events. it brought with it the comet that killed the dinosaurs, it shifted the poles causing the ice age and now its going to pass by even closer causing epic disasters, no telling really whats going to happen but its bad.

reply to post by ZackZombie


My post is about the effects of our planets on the visitor.

Originally posted by UberL33t
reply to post by ballsdeep

 

I am very limited on the subject as far as it is but, from what I recall... The inhabitants of said planet are supposed to be like this ancient race of Aliens...so they probably already have that sorted out.

But if we're in the same boat and the trauma isn't being brought on by any mistakes on our behalf, why wouldn't they help? I can't really imagine a race evolving to the point where they can have an extinction level event under control without being somewhat benevolent.

reply to post by ZackZombie


I believe in Divine Intervention. Do you?

reply to post by ballsdeep


a planet with such an extream eliptical orbit? not likely it has intelligent life. but if it did im sure they would experience little to no effect. the true devastation comes from the magnetic disruption of earth and the sun. its believed that Nibiru is even orbiting another sun and a whole different system that would be completely unscathed by the earths polarity. the planet passes in less than a week its enough to offput our solar system but not theirs.

reply to post by ZackZombie


Ok, so our planet is thrown out of whack because of the presence of one misfit planet, yet that misfit is unaffected by the presence of eight other planets and a star???

reply to post by ballsdeep

I'm following what your OP addresses!

The grey's have protective lenses over their eyes (example); Because for them to be alive and biological, yet the sun they (planet X) orbit has to be a dark star, because ours and where we are positioned, yada yada...is too bright for them.

It's basic physics isn't it, for every cause there is a reaction? So to think that this thing is not vulnerable to the same physics as us is just silly. Until I'm proven to be the silly one...

Originally posted by ballsdeep
reply to post by ZackZombie

 

Ok, so our planet is thrown out of whack because of the presence of one misfit planet, yet that misfit is unaffected by the presence of eight other planets and a star???

It would be affected directly by the planets and sun. Correct, this is logical.

But, we have to consider the fact that "If X exists, and IF life exists on it", than it must have adapted to it's bizarre orbital conditions...

Otherwise there wouldn't be anything alive on it.

reply to post by muzzleflash


Well IF life DID exist on it, chances are it evolved under very different conditions to those on our own planet; ergo their survival may not be down to technological superiority, just wild biology.

reply to post by muzzleflash


The planet is about the size of 2 jupiters it will have plenty effect on our solor system but it comes and goes so fast and its orbit is so immense that our solor system is only a speed bumb in its path. Nibiru has such a huge orbit it probably intersects alot more than just our system and yet its trajectory has never been affected in over a million years!

reply to post by ZackZombie


Trajectory, maybe not; it sounds like there would be terrestrial effects on Planet X during such an interaction.

reply to post by ballsdeep


It will get pretty close to our sun, enough to scortch the surface of the planet. If its lifeforms have adapted to its cold, dark climate then yeah, theyre toast just as we are.

reply to post by ballsdeep


If the object coming in is as large as Jupita then we are in for a wild ride. There is supposed to be an exact alignment with the incoming object on Sept. 27th of this year.

I'm not sure how a planet with an orbit as planet x could sustain any form of life which is being described. Earth is in the goldelocks zones which is the reason there is life here, the other planets does not have life (as far as we know) so how can this planet x have any life on it? I never understood why people believed life can exisit on a planet with planet x's orbit.

p.s - I don;t really believe in a planet x, i'm only interested in why other people believe in it and why that planet has life.

reply to post by Traydor


I think it's down to certain interpretations of ancient texts (again, correct me if I'm wrong)?

Planet X is nothing more than a MacGuffin used by doomsday peddlers.

Got to sell, sell, sell those books and DVDs.

2012 will come and go, and they'll be screaming "We're all DOOMED!!!" all over again. They'll wheel out a new MacGuffin and all the suckers will buy more books and DVDs.


THE END IS STILL NIGH!

Originally posted by ZackZombie
reply to post by ballsdeep

 

It will get pretty close to our sun, enough to scortch the surface of the planet. If its lifeforms have adapted to its cold, dark climate then yeah, theyre toast just as we are.

[citation needed]

Seriously, are you just making this stuff up? This is a rampant problem around here. The assertion of wild speculation as reliable evidence is hardly convincing. Also, the idea that phrases like "I feel" and "It seems to me" and "I had a dream about" should carry as much objective weight as phrases like "I verified through scientific analysis" and "My scientifically valid experiment shows" and "Actual non-fake NASA footage/images reveal..." is a bit off-putting.

I guess what I'm saying is that the opinion and instinct do not, even on their best day, qualify as science.

As for the OP - yes, of course, a star system with masses like what Planet X and Nibiru would have (would need, in fact, to even exist) would be just as effected by our system's gravitational forces as we would by theirs. I applaud this question because it's something I hadn't even considered.

The answer is very simple and quite scientifically sound. Fantasy beings are not affected by the laws of physics that exist in reality. So there is no need to worry about what happens to those beings. They will be just fine.