It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by mordant1
reply to post by TheGiantPeach
perhaps there was a contributory component that the young man could have applied to his fate? Cops as much as they are primarily revenue enhancment officers and basically dim can't be expected to behave any more perfectly than the wonderful residents that hate them, primarily by threatening the underground economy of generalized lawlessness. Those that dont understand the dynamics of humans (and mostly rather dull ones at that) under stress dont get out much in the hood.
All I can say is that if I got shot by a cop, i'd damn well intended that esact outcome. It is, in other words, quite avoidable and done all the time. Cops on the street know and feel like they are facing an ever increasing insurgency of lawlessness, and they'd be right.
Originally posted by Druidae
I live in Oakland, and have a few things to say about this.
1. Quit calling Oscar Grant innocent. If he would not have been fighting on the BART train, it would have never happened. He put himself in that situation to be arrested. If he would not have gotten in the original fight on the train, none of this would have happened.
2. Involuntary manslaughter is a fair sentence. I also agree with the gun enhancement charge that Mehserle was found guilty of as well. Do you really believe Mehserle woke up that morning and thought to himself "I am going to shoot someone in the back today"?
3. Have you ever been to Oakland? Downtown is not pretty. I'd love to see some of you walk through downtown at night. Especially the vocal people on here. You would not make it a block with out losing your shoes, Ipod, any jewelry you were wearing and your wallet, if not your life.
4. Jdills - He was CONVICTED today, not charged. What and why would you have liked to seen him get a greater charge? And did the evidence support the greater charge?
5. Zroth - I'd like to know what you think about all the other homicides that go on in Oakland, and why people are not out protesting those. There are a hell of a lot more murders in Oakland than this one. It is not Mayberry. This was an unfortunate accident and someone lost their life. How is it a double standard, was he not convicted? I will ask you too, What and why would you have liked to seen him get a greater charge? And did the evidence support the greater charge?
5. Did you see the stunned look on the officers face right after he shot him, or the daze he was in 20 minutes later in even more video footage?
6. Anyone care to comment on Oscar Grants buddies who were also getting arrested for fighting on the BART train. Or how the police that were there, had to control an overwhelming new years eve crowd of intoxicated people yelling, shouting, and trying to interfere BEFORE O.G. unfortunately got shot?
People really need to step back, and examine the whole situation. Today was a mostly peaceful protest, and I hope it continues in to the night peacefully as well. The original riots that that occurred after the initial shooting were not pretty, and we are lucky more people did not get killed, be it a protester or an officer. I have seen a lot of ignorant comments about the entire mess, and that is what it is.. a mess. Both for the Grant family and for the Mehserle family. My heart goes out to both families, as both have now been torn apart by this unfortunate accident.
I really think that if people want to protest this one incident, they should protest EVERY MURDER that happens during the year in the same manner. Only then will there truly be the change that is needed in Oakland.
~Druidae
[edit on 8-7-2010 by Druidae]
Originally posted by Misoir
Where is the justice in our world? An innocent man who was only trying to stop a fight had a knee crushing his neck then shot, for what? He was not resisting anything and was shot dead by public authorities!
Originally posted by mordant1
reply to post by Druidae
OMFG! Actual facts! Hey all how about this starting a new trend where FACTS and UNDERSTANDING of the FACTS are considered and objectively applied before posting opinions not actually based on the FACTS or reality.
Thanks D for a refreshing and unusual degree of objectivity for those unfamiliar with such things, compared to the regular fare i see posted by some others
Originally posted by KilrathiLG
reply to post by boondock-saint
they currently dont have him in general custody they have him at the prisoner intake facility and then he is going to the county jail to be placed in protective custody for all the good its gonna do him....
Originally posted by boondock-saint
genpop is a term referring to prison
he cannot go to a prison until he's been sentenced
and that's not until next month I believe.
Therefore he resides as property of the county and
the local jail until after he's been sentenced.
The judge will issue him orders of where he will
be remanded to (incarcerated) during the sentencing
phase. Where this judge places him to serve his time
could mean whether he survives or not. Due to the nature
of his crime, law will not allow him to serve in a min
security facility. Only med or max.
Originally posted by boondock-saint
oh I see what the prob is now
ur talking about jail
and I was talking about prison